A new type of versus thread ( I think )

[Disquiet]

Spoiler

this is my first time posting a vs thread, but I thought I'd change it up a bit, I don't really like vs threads and I'd figure I would try to get a new type started. hope this goes well.

rules:

1. teams only

2. the victor will be decided by adding together the amount of time it took each winner to beat their opponent. the team with the less amount of time wins (of course you will be posting your own opinion, all vs threads will almost ALWAYS be based on your opinion)

3. to eliminate arguing over the victor of just one fight and thus defeating the purpose of the thread, these must be match-ups that has actually been shown in manga, i.e., we know that kakashi (without MS) can beat zabuza, but how fast can he do it will be the debate.

4. when making teams, they must be evenly matched, for every one person that has been shown to win in manga, the other team must also have a winner, if it is 3, it could be evened out like this, deva path vs kakashi, and temari vs tenten (exams). okay now for the match.

sasuke (without MS) kimimaro, kisame, and shikamaru(team 1) vs deidara, gaara, gai, and hidan (team 2).


who wins?


note: if you don't like it, just say so in a respectful manner, if you can't DON'T POST U_U, I'm just trying to throw ideas out there.

 

[Alphonse Elric]

The way I see it for the first pair sasuke vs deidara it took to much time. Costing them both a point seeing how long it took.
For kimmo vs gaara, I wouldn't count it against kimmo seeing how he almost killed gaara and lee if it wasn't for him dieing. So the point goes to team 1.
For kisame vs gai I'm guessing it when kisame was weakened aka without his sword. Then team 2 gets that point because of the sheer speed gai beat kisame at.
For shika vs hidan I would give team 2 the point. Not due to the time but due to shika preparing everything causing more time taken up in the battle.
So overall it would be a draw. First battle took to long for sasuke to win, second battle was pretty quick but gaara won by kimmo's disease, Gai pretty much swiftly defeated the weakened kisame and shika vs hidan took too long to prepare.
But I would lean more towards team 1 due to them being closer to victory because of kimmo.


Is this how you wanted it? o.o I got a bit confused on your rules.

 

[Disquiet]

The way I see it for the first pair sasuke vs deidara it took to much time. Costing them both a point seeing how long it took.
For kimmo vs gaara, I wouldn't count it against kimmo seeing how he almost killed gaara and lee if it wasn't for him dieing. So the point goes to team 1.
For kisame vs gai I'm guessing it when kisame was weakened aka without his sword. Then team 2 gets that point because of the sheer speed gai beat kisame at.
For shika vs hidan I would give team 2 the point. Not due to the time but due to shika preparing everything causing more time taken up in the battle.
So overall it would be a draw. First battle took to long for sasuke to win, second battle was pretty quick but gaara won by kimmo's disease, Gai pretty much swiftly defeated the weakened kisame and shika vs hidan took too long to prepare.
But I would lean more towards team 1 due to them being closer to victory because of kimmo.


Is this how you wanted it? o.o I got a bit confused on your rules.

yeah, that was it, that was a good assessment