Madara vs Itachi (3 scenarios)

[lanakau888]

For all scenarios:
Location: konoha crater (after pains Chou shinra tensei)
Mindset: IC
Knowledge: manga
Starting Distance 30 m
Restrictions: both are not edo, itachi is healthy in all situations, madara is in his prime. Koto Amatsukami.

Scenario 1:
Base Madara vs Base itachi
so no MS, EMS, Rinnegan

Scenario 2:
MS itachi vs EMS madara
So no rinnegan techs for madara (including meteor)

Scenario 3:
Full arsenal both ways.

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

Itachi wins scenarios 1 and 2. Madara wins 3rd scenario.

How?

Scenario 1: Itachi shuriken and kunai abilities plus his fire ninjutsu would overwhelm madara (well maybe not the fire part, but definitely the other).

Scenario 2: Madara is pretty much about to win when Itachi pulls out his "special crow"!

Scenario 3: Madara uses one of many yet to be seen jutsus.

 

[Protozoid]

-Scenario #1: Madara - A more vast knowledge of ninjutsu/genjutsu (with the exception of the sharingan [I believe Itachi has more genjutsu prowess than Madara with the sharingan] considering the criteria of the scenario)/taijutsu/etc, the ability to summon bijuu, etc.

-Scenario #2: Madara - EMS > MS + scenario #1 differences.

-Scenario #3 (no threads attached): Madara - Scenario #1 + #2 & self-explanatory differences in overall power. Including but not limited to: EMS/Rinnengan mastery compared to Itachi whereas he has solely MS mastery, wood element utilization, etc.

All in all: I believe Madara is more powerful than Itachi. At least based on the power he's displayed so far, IMO.

Interesting thread btw. Nice touch of creativity you threw in there.

 

[itachi49]

Madara in all 3 Scenarios.

 

[lanakau888]

Itachi wins scenarios 1 and 2. Madara wins 3rd scenario.

How?

Scenario 1: Itachi shuriken and kunai abilities plus his fire ninjutsu would overwhelm madara (well maybe not the fire part, but definitely the other).

Scenario 2: Madara is pretty much about to win when Itachi pulls out his "special crow"!

Scenario 3: Madara uses one of many yet to be seen jutsus.

sorry forgot about KA, its now restricted, but I still think he wins in scenario 2 since his susanoo w/ items >>> madara's shown susanoo.

 

[The Eye]

Madara in S 2 & 3

i dont t know madara base strength so yea...

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

Madara in all 3 Scenarios.

Love the sig! Trying to figure out why kakashi's hair is golden now - super saiyan? xd

 

[The Eye]

Itachi wins scenarios 1 and 2. Madara wins 3rd scenario.

How?

Scenario 1: Itachi shuriken and kunai abilities plus his fire ninjutsu would overwhelm madara (well maybe not the fire part, but definitely the other).

Scenario 2: Madara is pretty much about to win when Itachi pulls out his "special crow"!

Scenario 3: Madara uses one of many yet to be seen jutsus.

Ems>MS

itachi would die by overusing his susanno

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

sorry forgot about KA, its now restricted, but I still think he wins in scenario 2 since his susanoo w/ items >>> madara's shown susanoo.

Good point - Madara can do all he wants but it won't hurt the mirror and then he as to deal with that sword ...

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Madara for all 3

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

Ems>MS

itachi would die by overusing his susanno

Nah, he'd just go blind I agree with the other guy that his susanoo (with its items) >> Madara's susanoo (thusfar)

 

[Protozoid]

sorry forgot about KA, its now restricted, but I still think he wins in scenario 2 since his susanoo w/ items >>> madara's shown susanoo.

That's a pretty good point, I hadn't considered it before. But under standard MS conditions, Itachi would exhaust himself with the power of it, whilst Madara will be full of stamina and not fatigued in the least bit (at least according to his current status in the war after using EMS a few times [I think there may be a possibility that the EMS disbursts the major fatigue in MS usage]). And knowing Madara, he'd probably be able to pull something else out of his hat to stop the Susano'o considering that's pretty much Itachi's only feat in this battle.

 

[System001]

madaara in s 2 and 3

 

[King of Hell]

Madara in all three.

 

[-Vegeta-]

Scenario 1- Madara wins
Scenario 2- Madara wins
Scenario 3- Madara wins very easily.

Madara's superior to Itachi in every way.