question on the whole minato being summoned

[clone101]

I am kinda confused by this whole thing. we all say that minato can not be summoned because he was sealed, but during the chunnin exams when oro invaded. oro summoned the 1st 2nd and 4th hokages. only reason y the 4th didnt show up was because the 3rd stopped it. so y is it that oro can summon him and kabuto cant, even thoe kabuto has kinda perfected the whole jutsu..

please explain and just dont say he was sealed because i know he sealed himself.

 

[Migualon J.J.]

it wasn´t Hiruzen´s doing, he only tried to stop it, and most likely he failed in that xd

 

[Talk No Jutsu]

Hiruzen didn't stop it, It stopped because the Soul isn't residing in pure world. Kabuto clearly explained that, that's why he isn't stupid enough to revive the rest of the hokages.

 

[-The Agent-]

Lol go read the Manga I don't think the 3rd coffin even rose out of the ground.. The Anime has mind ****ed everybody into thinking that it is possible by making it seem like the 3rd Hokage stopped it. When in reality it wasn't even possible.

 

[Baka Sennin]

the 3rd manage to stop the fourth's coffin rising, but it would have failed anyway. at least that's what i figure.

 

[D3A]

Hiruzen didnt stop it. You think throwing some shuriken on a box will stop a summoning? The summoning failed

 

[BarBoBot]

Kabuto himself said it failed because Minato was sealed....

This is the MANGA section....the anime means nothing here.

Kishi writes the manga, the anime writers don't follow the manga exactly therefore the manga ALWAYS trumps the anime.

Stop using anime references to prove points in the manga section....

 

[MinatoIsBestHokage]

Hiruzen didnt stop it. You think throwing some shuriken on a box will stop a summoning? The summoning failed

Exactly what I was going to say, all Sarutobi did was throw a couple of Shuriken at a box, but Minato wouldn't have stepped out anyway.

 

[NLee]

Thing like this can easily be explained if you pay attention to the manga. More than 90% of the questions people ask on these forums are things that have been clearly explained

 

[clone101]

Well I am gonna have to go back and read thanks

 

[MinatoIsBestHokage]

Well I am gonna have to go back and read thanks

You must be registered for see links

 

[Honord Sage]

It was assume that it might have ben the 4 Hokage, but it was never clearly or definitely stated that it was the 4 Hokage and from what Kabuto stated about Himself and Orochimaru studying Madara body over the years it might have ben an early attempt to bring Madara back then, we should know more in the next Manga and the ones after that for sure. One thing for sure as Kabuto demonstrated to Tobi when He first showed Him the summon, the jutsu is not complete till you attempt to awaken the individual, you can replicated the body with DNA but if the soul is not available all you got is an empty soulless corpse.

 

[Blaze Release]

Lol go read the Manga I don't think the 3rd coffin even rose out of the ground.. The Anime has mind ****ed everybody into thinking that it is possible by making it seem like the 3rd Hokage stopped it. When in reality it wasn't even possible.

This!!!

 

[99minutes]

Lol go read the Manga I don't think the 3rd coffin even rose out of the ground.. The Anime has mind ****ed everybody into thinking that it is possible by making it seem like the 3rd Hokage stopped it. When in reality it wasn't even possible.

Mr. Dave has the right idea U_U
In the manga, it never appeared and Orochimaru comments on it's failure. In the anime, it appeared and then retreated.

 

[BarBoBot]

It was assume that it might have ben the 4 Hokage, but it was never clearly or definitely stated that it was the 4 Hokage and from what Kabuto stated about Himself and Orochimaru studying Madara body over the years it might have ben an early attempt to bring Madara back then, we should know more in the next Manga and the ones after that for sure. One thing for sure as Kabuto demonstrated to Tobi when He first showed Him the summon, the jutsu is not complete till you attempt to awaken the individual, you can replicated the body with DNA but if the soul is not available all you got is an empty soulless corpse.

the same chapter that Kabuto shows Tobi how IWR works, he says the third coffin oro summoned WAS the fourth Hokage, but it failed because he was sealed.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

it looks like someone don't read the manga properly