LordRaikage
Active member
they are no bad hokages but if had to choose it be 2nd hokage.we dont now alot about him + all the other hokage did something really heroic. I wont call appointing a new hokage heroic.
The Worst Hokage
- Thread starter Senju clan24
- Start date
LordRaikage
Active member
:flaw:
let naruto die wtf the fouth knew that naruto wud be the only one that can stop madara when he got older and control of the fox n there wud be no naruto series.
Itachi Sacrifice
Member
yeahhhhh the fourth sacrificed his life, & what did the others do? sit around and drink tea? Tobirama sacrificed his life to save his subordinates. Hiruzen sacrificed himself to stop Orochimaru, which in turn, saved the village. It's true Minato rocks, but u are just riding on his ****. If u weren't, u'd add him to the poll.
Hipster Madara
Active member
he didnt know that! he just took a shot in the dark! U cant say he knew the future. His decision did end up working but it could have easily failed if naruto was bad or not strong enough
it would have made a LOT more sense to save kushina because she already had ninetailed fox so it wouldnt rampage and kill hundreds of people! It was only because he was partially selfish in not sacrificing one baby, and protecting kushina for the sake of hundreds of skilled, innocent shinobi If it wasnt his baby, im sure he would have made that sacrifice
There not being a Naruto series is not a sufficient answer b/c he doesnt even know he is in naruto series
Shisui Namikaze
Active member
Naruto was his son. Kushina would have neve forgave him if he would have let madara kill naruto. If you were minato you telling me that you would watch him kill your sun? Saving your first born is far from selfish. Wow dude :flaw:
Hipster Madara
Active member
its selfish if it leads to hundreds of ppl dying esp. if ur the leader because ur supposed to put ur country/village before everyone else and make the hard decisions for the better good :shrug: im not saying it would be an easy decision
think of it like this- what if he HADN'T been able to stop tobi/madara then the whole village would have been destroyed. he just got extremely lucky and is very smart/strong but if things hadnt gone the way they did, the destruction of the village would have been his fault for saving that one baby then u guys wouldnt think he was so great
not saying he was a bad hokage, just saying he isnt as perfect as everyone seems to think he is
btw im not a dude -____- pls check gender
Last edited:
Mr.Beastie
Active member
True dat. Also the fourth didnt sacrifice his life for the village. He couldve survived he put being a father and a husband before fulfilling his duties as hokage. So he is the worst.
Last edited:
Hipster Madara
Active member
Finally someone gets it!!! +rep
ur supposed to put ur duty over ur personal feelings when u r hokage so minato kinda failed as hokage
i KNOw minato fanboys r on the way to flame me lol
Shisui Namikaze
Active member
Hipster Madara
Active member
that's ok but i bet u dont think minato is as perfect as u thought before
but anyways, its ok most ppl on this forums are dudes so its an easy mistake to make
masterylucain
Active member
the 3rd was the only elder that tried to prevent the uchiha, but he ran out of time. The 3rd was said to be the strongest hokage ever. Dude seriously thats kishis words.
And for you first thought, well the 3rd did not want Naruto to be in danger, if everone knew he was the 4th hokages son, then he would be a big target, and he kinda of had no one to learn from in the begining like sausuke had, yeah i do understand ur first point, so i half agree, half no. Mine is the 5th though. SHes a pretty good hokage, but she gota be abetter shinobi
I don't agree with this at all. I'd love to see you put someone or something before your child. He defeated madara and saved the village, so stop using what ifs because he didn't fail. He was an honorable hokage and the entire village sees it that way as well, and in jiraiyas own words was the greatest shinobi konoha ever produced.
Last edited:
Reborn
Active member
Awards
None of the Hokage were tyranical, power grubbing, or were obsessed with their own affairs over that of Konoha. None of them were bad, none were better then the others (IMO) because they all contributed in some way to Konoha's development/prosperity so I'm going to leave it at that.
Shisui Namikaze
Active member
I never said he was perfect. But where I'm from family comes before all. He's still a better hokage than most.
Hipster Madara
Active member
that's ok i was just stating my opinion obviously some ppl wont agree but minato did risk a lot and left a lot of room for error just pointing that out
he was really incredible to stop madara and give naruto the power to defeat him but many people forget that he also let hundreds of shinobi to die because of his decision so he is not spotless in blame
he was honorable but the entire village just knows he stopped ninetails they dont know anything else (the whole story) and some people who's family died im sure would not be incredibly pleased with his decision. ill leave it at that and come to this thread later
How can Minato be the worst? You act like he didn't do anything, you are so indifferent, Minato prevented the BIGGEST catastrophe of Hidden Leaf! Without Minato, Madara and the Kyuubi would cause major loses of Leaf's shinobis, the consequences would've been worser then they were.
Biased pool is biased. And what's the point of it if we can't see the results. Anyways, there's no such thing as "The worst Hokage", but Tsunade didn't do much for the village until now (Except tanking Chou Shira Tensei, but that's about it), so my vote goes to her.
People would've died either way. He did nothing wrong imo. He realized the threats and put a stop to them. I don't know what kind of poor decision you're trying to say he made. He stopped madara, stripped the 9 tails from his control, and sealed it into his son to preserve the balance of power between the 5 great nations. Yes some people died, but when an attack of that magnitude happens than of course people are going to die. It wouldn't of mattered who was hokage.that's ok i was just stating my opinion obviously some ppl wont agree but minato did risk a lot and left a lot of room for error just pointing that out
he was really incredible to stop madara and give naruto the power to defeat him but many people forget that he also let hundreds of shinobi to die because of his decision so he is not spotless in blame
he was honorable but the entire village just knows he stopped ninetails they dont know anything else (the whole story) and some people who's family died im sure would not be incredibly pleased with his decision. ill leave it at that and come to this thread later
Last edited:
Hipster Madara
Active member
Last post for real now just clearing up, I meant I hope u can see that minato had some faultsn his.plan even if u stick to ur opinion