I have tried very hard to restrain myself from this topic but the amount of stupidity (one line sentence or made up things) I have read from both arguments has forced me to here. I don't mean everyone in here as people who at least put some detail into why they think Nagato would win or Itachi would win weren't bad to read but somewhere a bit off.
I know from my name it seems I'm a huge Itachi fan which I am but Nagato and Minato are on that list also (which I know they are all most talked chars). The reason for the user name is due to most I put in were taken (Sage-Pein, Yellowflash, Genflash), so I put this in and went thru so I could care less if anyone points me out to be a fan boy.:flaw:
As far as we speak of this 3 v 1 is just ridiculous, it wasn't considered a battle among both Itachi and Nagato. The thing with this is Nagato tried capturing Naruto and bee, while Itachi tried saving them. If you look at it that way Itachi succeed saving them from Chibaku Tensei with all three using there strongest attack but Itachi sealed Nagato at the end that is it. I think a lot of people don't give credit where it should be given, I mean how quick did Itachi figure out Chibaku Tensei weakness which is considered one of Nagato's strongest attacks? If people open there imagination and if Itachi beat Nagato in a 1v1, all Nagato fans would be fuming and arguing about how Nagato wasn't at full strength or was under Edo so either way there is no winner.
I see a lot of people stating Nagato being the strongest because it supposedly took 3 people to take him out. I say we open up the imagination again and switch Nagato with Itachi, so in other words Nagato escaped Edo and Itachi didn't. It's safe to assume if that was to happen than Kabuto would take away Itachi's emotions and activate Susanoo with the Spiritual sword and shield. It would end up taking three of them to fight him off due to the fact Naruto and Bee are more close combat fighters with the sword that won't happen so Nagato (since he knows a lot about Itachi's tech) or someone there would need to figure out how to defeat him. So now would that make Itachi the strongest in manga?
It also came to my mind were people assume one attack can't take out Chibaku Tensei. I don't recall reading in the manga that one attack would work or it wouldn't. Here's an example of why Itachi got Naruto and Bee to use there tech's, In football (soccer in some places) when a striker is going for net would the two defenders just back off? so the goalie makes the save or at least tries? no they would try to stop that striker in order to win. This is were the three tech's comes in Itachi wasn't just gonna use his tech why not get Naruto and Bee also as they all were present there would stand a bigger chance in ending everything. Even if one tech was used if it did or didn't destroy Chibaku Tensei, Nagato would have been wary and done something.
I was very glad to see Nagato once more as well as Itachi and very pleased to hear that Nagato was actually much stronger/faster than we seen him in the past. I wish in his case there was a better ending so most Nagato fans can be happy with it but sadly even I wasn't too happy with how Kishi ended him but we may see something next chap? hopefully? just before his sealing ends.
Also to all those Nagato fan boys you continuously point out Itachi fan boys but you are no less than itachi fan boys either (ranked in the same cata). You believe Nagato can beat anyone as most Itachi fans believe that also for Itachi. Itachi fan's do come in and put one line sentence like Genjutsu, Sasuno'o, Amaterasu, MS and etc. The Nagato fan boys also continuously say Nagato would win with Shinra Tensei, Chibaku Tensei, Rinnegan, 6 bodies, or etc. We all know one attack won't finish off a battle especially with top rank shinobi, it's like saying Sasuke will win becuase of Kirin, genjutsu, Susano'o or even Amaterasu and Naruto would win with resengan, the cloak, kyuubi or so on. So, please fan boys come from both sides and the fact is no one will listen.
I've also read in this topic and others the just because Itachi didn't use genjutsu, Nagato is all of a sudden immune to it? So, Nagato, Naruto, Bee and Itachi didn't use many attacks lets all of a sudden assume they are all immune to it * sarcasm*. Tobi did state that Rinnegan is superior but it doesn't mean, he won't be affected by genjutsu. I mean Kurenai was very good at using genjutsu by Itachi still manged to flip her genjutsu on her and than Kakashi with a sharingan thinking he can match toe to toe was pretty much owned, Sasuke was young but he was even under genjutsu, till the end. So, no evidence, no case here.
What people fail to realize here is when have we even seen Itachi at his best? where have we seen Itachi fight to survive/kill? Itachi mastered the sharingan at a young age, he became a anbu captain at age 13 (this is like having a 13 year old being a commander of an army or captain of a huge sports team), his battled with Deidara ended before it began, Oro being a genius was also a victim of a regular Sharingan, Kurenai/Kakashi were out match and would have been destroyed by Itachi if it wasn't for them being Konoho shinobi's, Jiriaya stated that no one has escaped the belly of the toad when he caught Itachi and Kisame but yet Itachi got out a long with Kisame, 30% Itachi encountered Chiyo/Sakura/Naruto/Kakashi even tho Chiyo and Sakura just helped Naruto a little to get out of the genjutsu (which was just a regular sharingan) it took them (Naruto, Kakashi) to defeat Itachi even all he was doing is stalling time and not even trying to kill (Yes, I do realize Naruto and Kakashi are beyond that lvl now), and the closet to a battle we seen was Itachi VS Sasuke but even than he wasn't serious as he planned to let Sasuke kill him but he still out lasted Sasuke even tho he wasn't at a 100% and his eyesight was done, Sasuke was out of chakra even tho Itachi had MS activate the whole match and managed to seal Oro away (the reason why the battle last long he needed Sasuke to ran out of chakra for him to seal Oro or else Sasuke would have been in trouble). So, if anyone has seen a legit battle than please let me know.
If you remember correctly what did Tobi state after the Amaterasu fail attempt? He said, "There was a few things I hid from Itachi, if not for that I would have been dead." So, Tobi here is pretty much saying if Itachi knew about Izanagi (as it is safe to say that was one thing he hid from Itachi and how he survived against the Amaterasu attack) he would have been able to kill him. Itachi figuring out how to defeat an Izanagi user and while he's dead able to activate a plan, could have still stood a chance on killing Tobi. Itachi intelligence itself being a deadly weapon.
IMO between Nagato VS Itachi, I have no conclusion as to both are great in there own standings and assuming a victor here without full knowledge is pathetic. So, it's a draw or a battle that won't end and I can give F what anyone thinks about my opinion.
So, please quit degrading both Nagato and Itachi's character and move on. I typed a brick wall so there maybe mistakes feel free to add, flame (as usually), or correct me.