[Game] Peaky Blinders Mafia Game Thread #24

[Michelle]

as Indie tbh, it only explains why he is so chaotic and emotional

lol, he is the most emotional town player except me I ever saw.

 

[xEphemeralx]

You reffused the CFD and started this nonsense. If he flips scum you are town hero. If he flips town.. i prefere to not say.

I asked you what your next move is after I flip town here if I get lynched

You're not answering my question mich, something wrong?

 

[Rej]

lol, he is the most emotional town player except me I ever saw.

no he can be fucking cool as town, especially when playing with new cast
that's what I know from town TSQ after playing with him in alot of different casts

 

[Elmage G Ace]

@Thestatusquo if you're town I'm afraid people going to waste a lynch on you just because they think you're scum from the way you play. But if you're s

This post is rather curious, and TSQ rightly pointed that out, because even though you didn't town read him, your wording seem to infer so, however, after reading your subsequent posts, I guess I can understand what you meant by this

You said the warning that I gave to you means I want to pocketing you. Absurd. First of all I don't see any problem with Elmage's vote. In my early comment I've made a theory that said "The post, it could be TSQ's strategy to catch scum by posting that". Here you're highly mistaken if you think I read you as town from that post. My comment should be read in a way if you're town.

So if you're town you should be blamed if town wasting the lynch on you. You still play a passive game like in the previous game. But the difference here you posting more. I have ISO your posts and most of it not looking really helpful. Many trivial comments that can't be a source of reference to other players. You know right which faction where their opinion not worth a dime???

Saying "You really did rand wolf didn't you?" How is that being helpful?

Ok you have voted 2 people so far but can I see your reasoning. You have stated why you vote Ephemeral but what is your reasoning on voting Rej???

If you are scum TSQ that means you've given people a sign. If they believe you're scum they going to vote you

But if they think it looks so easy and for someone who had in the previous game(Prime Number) rand scum maintaining the same approach in this game is something for people to evaluate.

Ansa gets a town read from me due to this post, this was one of the problems with TSQ earlier...

Morning. Waiting for Sagebee to catch up.
Welcome Sage

Until then @Ansatsuken talk to me about your reads. From your post to TSQ i see you dislike his former vote on Rej, do you town read Rej? Why? And why Eph vs TSQ have to be town/mafia or mafia/town?

@bolded it didn't seem like he disliked the post, I think his point was that TSQ wasn't invested in the vote, and hadn't made any significant contribution at this point

SK is never genuine. He is role playing no matter AI. This requres acting.
Idk from where you take these ideas Rej, but they are from bad to worse.
They are fine if you are mafia, nevertheless

Yeah, @Rej posts about SK seems concerning, I'll look into that

TSQ's former vote was Ephemeral not Rej. Rej is his current vote. And I never said I dislike any of his vote. I'm just asking for his reasoning.

I have shrunk my working ground in this DP and mostly focusing on 3 people rn. So both of them are in my PoE and also includes Mr Lonely.

1 from 3 of them could be Mafia.

-Ephemeral>Not doing any scum hunting yet. Most of the time he just asking and asking people about their opinion on a subject but never had an opinion to share with people on the same subject. To be honest I think he just dragging the situation further while not actually contribute anything.

-TSQ>Same with Ephemeral. No significant contribution coming from him yet. I made a theory on one of his early comment but I think that theory could be wrong. It's not actually like what I'm thinking. And what makes me questioned any town expectation on him bcuz of these posts;







Looks to me like an excuses to not contributing and an exemption from being check. Don't know why people gave a free pass. Why the special treatment??

And now he accused me of pocketing him instead of understand the right meaning of that message.

-Mr.Lonely>This fella being one of my suspect entirely on guts reading. So 50/50.

This seems to be town Ansa! What do you think about @Rej ?

I just think it’s funny how you guys say “Why is TSQ receiving special treatment” when in fact, the only “special treatment” i get is always being under the spotlight Day 1

You are looking for patterns when catching scum me without merely thinking how devastating it can be if you lynch me Day 1 without even giving my reads.

What if I flip town?

Seems like i’m not an asset if town any way, so what are we doing here?

Ansa please, talking special treatment. SK has been posting nothing but gifs, and he’s probably going to skate until he dies.

Oh, an emotional response! I love those! First of all, you attracted the spotlight to yourself, shouldn't be a problem if you're town, also at this point you still haven't contributed to town cause imo. SK always plays like that, I've played (and lynched) SK before, if I find him scummy, I'll build a case against him, no one is receiving special treatment, however, the tone of your post suggest that you're trying to stay in the game, and means you're at least invested in it, which is good

You’re relying on past experiences in order to catch a scum, you’d much rather ignore my posts and anyone else’s for that matter and think “Well TSQ isn’t doing this when he did this as a town game so let’s lynch him instead”

I’m sick and tired of this and it’s time y’all learned a lesson. Read my damn posts and don’t expect me to put on an act for you. Treat me like anyone else.

Still, at this point, not much contribution, however, I do like your subsequent posts

So you're waiting for me to put on more pressure for you to start speaking. But it mostly to defend yourself.

So now you're giving me a warning what if you flip town when you have dismissed my warning early on. How ironic.

You're not seeing as an 'asset' for townie because you never try to be one/play as one.

Ansa has a good point here, you had to be pressured before we see meaningful response from you, and like I pointed out, didn't contribute much at this point

This read is nonsensical if it comes from town and is by far more likely to come from scum that's assessing the game state with TMI.

Not to mention, this is a weird read regardless, because it targets the two players who perhaps have a way better view of what is going on, so making this comment on behalf of Rej is kind of weird, although, there is a very specific scenario where he does this in which he's probably town, but if I'm right on the money with, it will look like a far stretch to a lot of people and he won't even admit it in the first place.

Actually, part of it should account for only one of you, not so sure about the other, so all in all it could be that he is just wolf TMIng you.

Also, his posts just stick out like a sore thumb, every post he makes feels rather forced. This is a meta read and it could be because of IRL reasons so that's why I'm going to try and keep meta away when assessing people, unless there's a really compelling aspect that doesn't tie in with the IRL situation.

I don't get his read on Imperfection and Kyte at all. It seems like the only thing he town reads is...tone / newbiness or willingness to participate in a game (talking about his Imperfection read)

This to me is your first meaningful post, although I'm not saying I agree with it (not saying otherwise either)

I think Alice, Michelle, Ephemeral is a good enough town core to start building from.

I feel as though, even if I cleared Alice from her first post, her following ones have been coming from town, because Alice as a lurker is self-aware, going "What is your read on me?" on every opportunity she gets is kind of counter-intuitive. She doesn't want the attention when she has 2 different team mates. She'd had to have been gathering town reads early if she even crafted her first post to appear town somehow, but I think in the long run she realises that she's not going to keep the act on for a long time, thus, it feels rather pointless and overcoming laziness for nothing and I don't see Alice doing it.

This is the most useful post you've made at the point you posted it, and it makes sense, I feel that your evolution process in this thread is good enough to at least give you some townie points (Not necessarily a town read) from complaining about NAI to defending yourself to finally providing your reads and making contributions

Now, for the reason I voted you: I've been mafia a few times, infact, I'd say my style is more suited for mafia, however, I do not like being mafia, what I've experienced mafia do to seem town most times, is what I'd call reaction posts... Waiting for towns to post faulty logic or make a mistake or something, and then point it out, or just plain react logically to other people's reads, and when it's time to give theirs, because it's left late, the new information given in the reads would be minimal to zero, now, what I posted, on its own is not enough for a scum lean, however, your wording on the bolded part seemed to infer you're taking a similar approach because at that time, you had no thoughts on anyone, you're clearly indicating that you're waiting for other posters before then giving your thoughts, and you hadn't added new information yet. Of course you have now, which was what I wanted to see.

Before you may call me reason absurd, it's something that has happened a lot, you did it the last game, and I've played SK and Rej, and it's something they do as scum too, so I have enough reason. I do hope I explained myself clearly enough

Any questions for me guys?

Unvote

 

[Rej]

I expect the worst case scenario of this being a T/T lead wagonomic in better case an I/T (C) wagon or S/F wagon

 

[Elmage G Ace]

I'm currently reading the thread, at page 18, so what I just posted are up till that point, my view can change in the next post

 

[Ansatsuken]

gimme you reads on TSQ, Ephe and Michelle, for my logbook
or your interaction review atleast

TSQ's former vote was Ephemeral not Rej. Rej is his current vote. And I never said I dislike any of his vote. I'm just asking for his reasoning.

I have shrunk my working ground in this DP and mostly focusing on 3 people rn. So both of them are in my PoE and also includes Mr Lonely.

1 from 3 of them could be Mafia.

-Ephemeral>Not doing any scum hunting yet. Most of the time he just asking and asking people about their opinion on a subject but never had an opinion to share with people on the same subject. To be honest I think he just dragging the situation further while not actually contribute anything.

-TSQ>Same with Ephemeral. No significant contribution coming from him yet. I made a theory on one of his early comment but I think that theory could be wrong. It's not actually like what I'm thinking. And what makes me questioned any town expectation on him bcuz of these posts;







Looks to me like an excuses to not contributing and an exemption from being check. Don't know why people gave a free pass. Why the special treatment??

And now he accused me of pocketing him instead of understand the right meaning of that message.

-Mr.Lonely>This fella being one of my suspect entirely on guts reading. So 50/50.

 

[Michelle]

I asked you what your next move is after I flip town here if I get lynched

You're not answering my question mich, something wrong?

My next move after you get lynched and flip town is to check who pushed you during the day phase. And rechecking interactions, with the NKs info. And ofc all this if I am alive

 

[xEphemeralx]

My next move after you get lynched and flip town is to check who pushed you during the day phase. And rechecking interactions, with the NKs info. And ofc all this if I am alive

That's very vague

Deliberately so

You're gonna have to give me more than that, who do you suspect, why? How does it change your read on tsq?

Sounds to me like you're trying to avoid incriminating yourself upon my imminent town flip

 

[-PK-]

What is the current vote count?
Just got back to reading.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Unvote

 

[xEphemeralx]

Don't keep your options so open in a situation like this Mich

That's what scum do so they can wriggle their way out of suspicion later on and allow themselves to be flexible with their lynches... like your friend tsq over there

 

[Michelle]

That's very vague

Deliberately so

You're gonna have to give me more than that, who do you suspect, why? How does it change your read on tsq?

Sounds to me like you're trying to avoid incriminating yourself upon my imminent town flip

I can't ne incriminated because i am villager. It's simple as that.
I have no answers, I need to rereaf.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

TOWNLOCKING ELMAGE

 

[xEphemeralx]

I can't ne incriminated because i am villager. It's simple as that.
I have no answers, I need to rereaf.

Conveniently feigning ignorance when it suits you to avoid answering my question huh?

 

[Michelle]

Don't keep your options so open in a situation like this Mich

That's what scum do so they can wriggle their way out of suspicion later on and allow themselves to be flexible with their lynches... like your friend tsq over there

I have to be open to reevaluate if I can find reasons.

 

[xEphemeralx]

I have to be open to reevaluate if I can find reasons.

Of course, that's not what I meant in my post though

 

[Rej]

This is the biggest clusterfuck I have seen in a while.

 

[Michelle]

Conveniently feigning ignorance when it suits you to avoid answering my question huh?

spare me with this please, you don't have a good contribution to this game and you jumped at conclusions too fast.

 

[xEphemeralx]

This is the biggest clusterfuck I have seen in a while.

Pretty chill/straightforward eod ime

lol