[Game] Naruto Mafia Game [Game Thread]

[AL_sama]

First of all, I think the day actions are host triggered and not submitted by players. I wonder what their purpose is in the game and if there are consequences for not answering them.

what males you think that??

 

[Finalbeta]

Do you think it can be so easy just like that finding the first mafia? He said he is good or prefers to be mafia than a townie bcuz he think he suck playing as a townie. And let say he's mafia, do you think Gister see the way he played right now is the best way to play as a Mafia? It because it has to many flaws. Yes we can use those flaws as our reason to vote him.
He clearly unable play properly as a townie because the way he made a case for certain player is very confusing and he jumped from one player to other player with no proper connection to whole 'drama' that involving him. The 'drama' that started between him and Odd at first. To be honest he should have Odd at least in his suspicious list and not you and quite surprisingly Koto(a confirmed townie). These all are a good ingredients to suspect him as a mafia if not Serial Killer.

Ok other than Night bullet proof townie or invisible townie, Serial Killer also have night immunity from what I know so far. Its either they become invisible if no night activity from them or they have limitless bullet proof ability in NP and only lynching can kill them.

I'm very doubtful that Gister is a mafia. Why should he exposed himself like that? Its so easy. Something that feel so easy in Mafia game always ended up with a wrong result. But he could be SK for all we know.

And there is another thing about borderline role claiming from him. How he can tell very confident that Shadow Clone no jutsu is what makes him invincible in the NP unless he knows something about the role? This is not really likely a made up claim. He need to know something about the role he speak about. Uchiha Madara also know how to perform Shadow Clone no jutsu but Mafia leader never have Night Kill immunity. Only 'Innocent' revelation when being investigate by Cop. We dont get any roles list with their ability to fake the ability claim. What is Shizune's ability? I don't know.

There are many angles we can look into. Look at every angle and decide which angle is the right one.



.

I think that the Shadow Clone thing is quite easy to craft up either he did or someone helped him (still in the hypothesis territory) it is a very common ninja technique and it wouldn't be difficult to state to be invincible or something to look like a precious town role hence gaining credibility and value immediately

What turns me off is not this hypothesis though but his behaviour. From my experience panicking is rarely something one does come up with but instead it is a natural reaction which is completely not necessary

 

[MadieV]

what males you think that??

The second action makes me think that. "Posting your three main suspects" don't seem like a player action to me. But again, there could be stuff behind the scenes that I may be missing. Another possibility is that if a specific player is on the majority of people's suspect list then a specific action is performed on that player.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

I think we're all forgetting about fake claims. In flavor heavy games, it is almost mandatory to give fake claims and it is not uncommon to make 'main characters' FC in order to throw people off the loop.

I'm still not a 100% sold on Gister and expect him to perform better from this point onward if he's indeed town. If not, I'm pushing on his lynch full force.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Can players here give your opinion on Sagebee's actions so far. Someone that just came out of nowhere, with no prior build up, put a vote and then leave the game. In Finalbeta's game he was a mafia leader, rarely post something and just visited the thread to vote.

 

[MadieV]

Can players here give your opinion on Sagebee's actions so far. Someone that just came out of nowhere, with no prior build up, put a vote and then leave the game. In Finalbeta's game he was a mafia leader, rarely post something and just visited the thread to vote.

He's standing out so far. He's on the fence, not trying to solve the game, not interacting, not questioning other players and not doing much at all. So far, of negative value for town.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

Hoping to see more of Alice as well.

 

[Ansatsuken]

This game will end in Wednesday at 2am of my country's time zone. So I will start voting tomorrow(Tuesday).

Right now I will spend my time to read

 

[AL_sama]

I think we're all forgetting about fake claims. In flavor heavy games, it is almost mandatory to give fake claims and it is not uncommon to make 'main characters' FC in order to throw people off the loop.

fake claims in a game where claiming isn't allowed yeah nice going madie

 

[Alubama]

Can players here give your opinion on Sagebee's actions so far. Someone that just came out of nowhere, with no prior build up, put a vote and then leave the game. In Finalbeta's game he was a mafia leader, rarely post something and just visited the thread to vote.

I just see him pointing fingers and fairly warning a few others aswell. Seems a tad fishy to me but i'm not yet fully convinced what his motifs are.

 

[Ansatsuken]

I just see him pointing fingers and fairly warning a few others aswell. Seems a tad fishy to me but i'm not yet fully convinced what his motifs are.

I rarely saw player voting a player because he/she is inside that player's suspicious list. But I have saw many times player vote the player who voted him as a counter vote.

 

[Sagebee]

What kind of defence I need to put out when I'm not even voting you yet. Just put you in my suspicious list dont warrant any votes on me.

Are you new to this game because i know you're not. And what makes you believe people will have same head like you and go voting me?

Keep in mind the difference. You just already voting me without any concrete reason while I'm just only putting you inside my suspicious list with my own reason that is a "feeling". Yes its not a strong reason so that's why I'm not write down my vote on you yet.

And do you believe yourself that you're a trustful person so you feel very powerful and confident that your vote will left you a follower?

which one put more weight and tilt towards scum move? Voting without any strong reasoning or putting someone inside their suspicious list?
Answer me.

Putting suspicion is trying to vote me and my issue is you tried to put suspicion for no reason so why am I suspicious

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

I just see him pointing fingers and fairly warning a few others aswell. Seems a tad fishy to me but i'm not yet fully convinced what his motifs are.

So she the full situation tho I log in see him putting suspicion on me based on what before this I've made two comments one asking peoples favorite naruto character and saying a phase shouldn't be 48 hrs so how could he try to put suspicion on me it looks like hes randomly forcing a lynch

 

[MadieV]

fake claims in a game where claiming isn't allowed yeah nice going madie

Role claiming is NOT allowed.

The host said role claiming is not allowed. Flavor claiming and role claiming are two different things no?

 

[Sagebee]

I rarely saw player voting a player because he/she is inside that player's suspicious list. But I have saw many times player vote the player who voted him as a counter vote.

My issue is you randomly putting suspicion you give a good reason I'll get rid of the vote

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

He's standing out so far. He's on the fence, not trying to solve the game, not interacting, not questioning other players and not doing much at all. So far, of negative value for town.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

Hoping to see more of Alice as well.

Really than shouldn't this count for everyone right now it's the first phase and just observing what people are doing

 

[Alubama]

Putting suspicion is trying to vote me and my issue is you tried to put suspicion for no reason so why am I suspicious

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

So she the full situation tho I log in see him putting suspicion on me based on what before this I've made two comments one asking peoples favorite naruto character and saying a phase shouldn't be 48 hrs so how could he try to put suspicion on me it looks like hes randomly forcing a lynch

True to a certain point, asking for someone fav naruto character might be a subtle way of figuring out peoples roles no? Might be that secret tongue madara and his followers are using.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

But on the other hand not many returned an answer to that which makes me think you could also be a towny trying to figure it out.

I need to stop mindfucking myself here

 

[Sagebee]

First of all, I think the day actions are host triggered and not submitted by players. I wonder what their purpose is in the game and if there are consequences for not answering them.

On another train of thought, please stop role fishing. It is strictly forbidden as per the hosts announcements. It only works in detriment to us.



Early votes are used to promote interaction with players and to get reactions out of them. All those strategies are important in formulating reads.



All hosts are supposed to randomize the roles. It is clearly stated in the 'hosting rules'. I'm not sure I understand your angle here. And you being a chaotic element makes you more suspicious than 'cleared' in my eyes.



Why are you calling for protection on Ansa? What exactly makes him confirmed in your eyes? As far as I'm concerned, the only player who is confirmed so far is Koto. Don't get me wrong, with this I'm not saying the doctor should protect him. It's up to the doctor what he thinks it's the best approach for the night phase. However, your statement gave me the impression that you were doctor baiting. It's more like "Hey, protect this unconfirmed guy while we kill the only confirmed townie". I'm not liking it.

On the other hand, you've been somewhat of a chaotic element so far. I didn't like your reaction to Odd's vote. Too nervous. Too unsettled.




Or he could be Madara who most likely is detection immune and iron.

@Odd You called for a watcher/voyeur on Gister. What was your thought process for that?

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

@Sagebee

You're on the fence so far. All your posts are pure fluff. What are your ;in game' thoughts so far?

I've said about 3 things

First asking peoples favorite naruto character get slight basis of alignment

I said there shouldn't be 48 hrs those were my comments yesterday waiting to see what people will say

I log back in next day and see ansatsuken randoml put suspicion on me so voted him dont see what I'm doing as just fluff

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

True to a certain point, asking for someone fav naruto character might be a subtle way of figuring out peoples roles no? Might be that secret tongue madara and his followers are using.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

But on the other hand not many returned an answer to that which makes me think you could also be a towny trying to figure it out.

I need to stop mindfucking myself here

Actually yes I was trying to subconsciously figure out peoples alignment with that question dont see how that would mark me as scum

 

[Ansatsuken]

Putting suspicion is trying to vote me and my issue is you tried to put suspicion for no reason so why am I suspicious

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

So she the full situation tho I log in see him putting suspicion on me based on what before this I've made two comments one asking peoples favorite naruto character and saying a phase shouldn't be 48 hrs so how could he try to put suspicion on me it looks like hes randomly forcing a lynch

And did you see me pushing on that suspicion? And that's how mafia is played in the first DP. People put their suspicion or suspecting certain player to be a potential Scum. Why are you felt insecure here? I dont mind if you voted me base on your read on me(all my posts) in this game but that's not what happened in the actuality. You voted me based on two simple comments that talking about suspicion. That's unreasonable and unacceptable.

 

[Sagebee]

And did you see me pushing on that suspicion? And that's how mafia is played in the first DP. People put their suspicion or suspecting certain player to be a potential Scum. Why are you felt insecure here? I dont mind if you voted me base on your read on me(all my posts) in this game but that's not what happened in the actuality. You voted me based on two simple comments that talking about suspicion. That's unreasonable and unacceptable.

Lol you think putting suspicion is a light thing and my issue isnt about it being me its I'm confused for what could you put suspicion on me from and not just that saying I was the most suspicious so what's your reasoning?

 

[AL_sama]

The host said role claiming is not allowed. Flavor claiming and role claiming are two different things no?

yeah but lets ask

@Poison chan is any kind of claiming allowed???

 

[Ansatsuken]

@Sagebee its more Better if you came back here and then asking me why you(Ansatsuken) suspect me and we can discuss rather than straight blind voting without any reason at all. Be more logical m8.

 

[Sagebee]

Side question for anyone who hasnt commented or commented little so far

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

@Sagebee its more Better if you came back here and then asking me why you(Ansatsuken) suspect me and we can discuss rather than straight blind voting without any reason at all. Be more logical m8.

Again next comment is give me a reason and my vote seems logical to me when it looks like your randomly putting suspicion on people if I seen you do it to someone else I would still vote you so please answer my question

 

[Ansatsuken]

Lol you think putting suspicion is a light thing and my issue isnt about it being me its I'm confused for what could you put suspicion on me from and not just that saying I was the most suspicious so what's your reasoning?

It just my feeling/hunch. That's my reason. Sometimes it's right, sometimes it's wrong. But we can discuss right? One more day to go before the conclusion. And I have becoming a suspect of many players since the first time I played this game(many years ago). But my resolution to every suspicions being put on me were not by voting the players who suspecting me but through a discussion.

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

Side question for anyone who hasnt commented or commented little so far

Post automatically merged: Jan 28, 2019

Again next comment is give me a reason and my vote seems logical to me when it looks like your randomly putting suspicion on people if I seen you do it to someone else I would still vote you so please answer my question

Your vote sure seems logical to you and everyone will say the same for their part. But what is logical to you doesn't mean it logical for other players. Putting a vote is an attempt of desperation and not an attempt to look like a townie or clearing up the situation. You're voting me while me just suspecting you. To be honest you're the one who should being ask by me why you're voting me? Voting me because I'm suspecting you is not the strongest reason. I can just tie the vote if I want and leave it at that. But I don't like to play like that. I like to try to clear the situation first.