I see you though you have a point for once but no. If you read carefully then you'll notice that he's more surprised about his rinnegan able to deter the effects of IT and save others as well. It doesn't validate your point that without it they're not immune.
Yes it does, BZ makes an assumption, Sasuke confirmed it page later. Deny it all you want, but repeating one thing over and over again won't make it true. Kaguya's action did not contradict Sasuke's statement, because last time I asked you to prove it with manga facts you brought this BZ argument of knowing that Naruto is immune, and as I explained it doesn't make sense, because BZ thought that whole team 7 should have been affected.
You're basically arguing that a person has a rifle(usual attacks) and a C4 explosive(IT). He knows the C4 explosive will destroy the bunker for certain and yet he uses a rifle which does nothing to the bunker. Realize how stupid that sounds lol.
Again if Kaguya's IT was effective she'd have used it.
I don't care how stupid it sounds, I didn't write this manga. The statement about Naruto being vulnerable was made. To contradict this, Kaguya would need to cast IT, so that we could see Naruto's immunity. She didn't cast IT, we don't know the reason why. Yet your whole argument is this :
Kaguya didn't use IT because Naruto is immune
How is Naruto immune?
Because Kaguya didn't use IT.
Why didn't Kaguya use IT?
Becase Naruto is immune.
But how do you know that he's immune?
Because she didn't use IT on him.
Realize how stupid that sounds now...Especially that you still didn't answer how Kaguya know that Naruto is immune, without actually trying IT on him.
You're using these 2 topics and trying to connect them. You're using the fact of Kaguya not using IT and trying to connect it to prove Naruto's fanfic immunity.
But in actual manga, these 2 aren't connected. We don't know why Kaguya didn't use IT on Naruto, or even if she could back then, but we do know thanks to Sasuke that Naruto would be affected. Im still waiting for an answer on how do you know that Kaguya knew Naruto is immune, when manga told us otherwise.