Am I the only one who thinks that Boruto's byakugan is from Himawari and not Hinata?

[JENchuuriki]

You can be right about the activated/deactivated thing - but it saddens me to think it's from Hima! I doubt it. I believed he awakened his own byakugan

 

[Prince Badman]

Just about every prediction I read or hear about regarding Boruto's byakugan believes that he got the eye from Hinata. Alot of these people then go even further as to doubt that they would kill off Himawari.

I disagree however , and here is why:

In the panel , we saw Boruto activate that byakugan in what was previously a normal eye (like when Uchihas activate their sharingan eyes). The only case of a byakugan that activates like the sharingan that we have ever seen is Himawari's byakugan. No normal byakugan (like Hinata's) has been shown to activate/deactivate to and from a normal eye.

The fact that Boruto's activates/deactivates like a sharingan makes it more likely in my opinion that Boruto has Himawari's eye , and not Hinata's (whose eye would most likely just permanently stay white in Boruto's eye instead of activating/ deactivating).

It is notable that we have already seen one case of a transplanted byakugan in that kirigakure shinobi Ao. Ao (who got his eye from a normal Hyuuga) already showed that a transplanted byakugan from a normal Hyuuga would just stay white. This further supports my belief that Boruto's byakugan can't be Hinata's.

I will admit however , that I can think of one possible explanation as to why Boruto would be able to deactivate a normal byakugan when Ao couldn't. Unlike Ao , Boruto is actually half Hyuuga. Being a partial Hyuuga (like Himawari) may be what allows a person to activate /deactivate a byakugan eye.

This may be the case . However , I see it as much more likely that Boruto's byakugan is simply Himawari's eye.

What do you guys think?

Well i still think that it neither Hinata's nor himawari's. I think its definitely a transplant because nothing else would explain the scar on his eye..the other theories would be simply too weird.....Well since Konoha is developed in the timeline it might have also happened that his original eye might have been damaged and then he awakened the byakugan in that eye....I know it sounds ridiculous but for this manga i would not keep out this possibility too.
And why doesn't anyone consider that it may belong to Hiashi or anyone else maybe be even Hanabi...?

 

[lndra]

Borutos byakugan is Neji's. Bookmark this comment for WHEN I'm proven right.

A major theme in the new series will be something along the lines of choosing your own path and destiny again. As a call back to Neji, he will somehow end up with his Byakugan as a keepsake. I'm telling you all right now.

I want my reps when I'm proven right.

Lmao bet

 

[Yatori]

I hope boruto got new power eyes. Using same dojutsu is kinda lame.

 

[Vulpini]

I hope boruto got new power eyes. Using same dojutsu is kinda lame.

I hope it's some kind of new doujutsu too. Byakugan is lame and it would be lame for him to have it lol

 

[HyuugaHeir]

Or he could awaken his, we wouldnt know until that time comes. So far no one is dying yet