[Predictions] Fairy Tail Manga Chapter 483 Discussion and 484 Predictions

[Caliburn]

Thats a positive movement this chapter gave.



Yeah I agree.



I really want to discuss properly about this chapter but I got bad moment and not just one day maybe entire life.....My internet connected devices(tablet and netbook) got stole by someone and it occurred at my home

For this topic/chapter...

I like your coloring of Eileen

Also do you really believe (if Eileen was Erza's Mother) her scare is resulted from childbirth in forceful way bcus I dont think that the position a women do their cesarean operation even in forceful way?

Spoiler alert!!!!

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

The cut line is horizontal one.

Its too far side on Eileen's abdomen.

I don't think you should take real life cesarean section to literal in manga terms and that's under the assumption the scar is supposed to be the result of one, which I don't think it is. If it was, then that means there wasn't anything unusual about Erza's birth and thus no reason for such an unusual scar to be there. Also if it was a cesarean section, the scar should have been straight. Instead we have a rather large, crude and irregular scar, meaning it was inflicted in an unconventional way and weapon. Hence the reason for my hypothesis that Erza was in a violent way separated from Eileen.

If a regular cesarean section was used, well then there was nothing in particular unusual and then there wouldn't have been a reason in the first place to leave that scar. Then Hiro could have just made it a regular childbirth.

 

[Ansatsuken]

I don't think you should take real life cesarean section to literal in manga terms and that's under the assumption the scar is supposed to be the result of one, which I don't think it is. If it was, then that means there wasn't anything unusual about Erza's birth and thus no reason for such an unusual scar to be there. Also if it was a cesarean section, the scar should have been straight. Instead we have a rather large, crude and irregular scar, meaning it was inflicted in an unconventional way and weapon. Hence the reason for my hypothesis that Erza was in a violent way separated from Eileen.

If a regular cesarean section was used, well then there was nothing in particular unusual and then there wouldn't have been a reason in the first place to leave that scar. Then Hiro could have just made it a regular childbirth.

Even if it was not exactly like a normal cesarean section as what it should be, the person who doing it(by force) still will cut open Eileen's abdomen from the center and not like the picture. Thats how I think.

 

[Caliburn]

Even if it was not exactly like a normal cesarean section as what it should be, the person who doing it(by force) still will cut open Eileen's abdomen from the center and not like the picture. Thats how I think.

My point is that if someone was performing a controlled cesarean section, there would be nothing special about the birth. Eileen and Erza look so much alike that any familial connection between the two is quite obvious. So having an unusual scar Eileen would have gained from a regular childbirth, would be pointless. That scar, in my opinion at least, only can have any kind of significance if it happened involuntary/violent or something along those lines. We know that Erza must have been separated at a very young age, which follows that line of thought.

I don't know if you have seen the 2011 remake of Conan the Barbarian, but at the beginning there's a scene of Conan's birth where his mother gets stabbed in the side while being pregnant. His father then cuts Conan out of her because she knew she was dying and wanted to see her child before that. This is the kind of stuff I'm envisioning and the reason why is because that scar is diverting from the norm. There would be no point in considering an unusual birth if there's nothing unusual about he scar.

 

[Ansatsuken]

My point is that if someone was performing a controlled cesarean section, there would be nothing special about the birth. Eileen and Erza look so much alike that any familial connection between the two is quite obvious. So having an unusual scar Eileen would have gained from a regular childbirth, would be pointless. That scar, in my opinion at least, only can have any kind of significance if it happened involuntary/violent or something along those lines. We know that Erza must have been separated at a very young age, which follows that line of thought.

I don't know if you have seen the 2011 remake of Conan the Barbarian, but at the beginning there's a scene of Conan's birth where his mother gets stabbed in the side while being pregnant. His father then cuts Conan out of her because she knew she was dying and wanted to see her child before that. This is the kind of stuff I'm envisioning and the reason why is because that scar is diverting from the norm. There would be no point in considering an unusual birth if there's nothing unusual about he scar.

We can wait and see

 

[Memento Mori]

hmm....Now we moved to delivery position of the baby!. Okay!. I understood where you both are coming from. While we are at it...I want to consider also the baby-shifting-the-positions-in-the-womb. I meant fetal positioning of the baby!. That is why that scar!. And yeah there also has to be some drama along with that reason of birth!.

Yep. Let us just wait and see rather than discussing about it here!. btw...Yesterday(May 3rd) is Mashima sensei's birthday!. A lot has been happened in twitter. You can check his twitter to see comments and all!.

I hope we will be having an early chapter this week!