Could Minato have stopped the Uchiha clan Massacre

[CrazyTheorist]

What do you think?
Remember, it was the 9 tails attack that started the scrutiny that the Uchiha clan fell under. If Minato had survived the attack, would he have been able to make peace between the Uchiha and the rest of the village?
Kushina and Sasuke's mother were apparently friends, so maybe Minato and Fugaku were also good friends. Could Minato have talked down Fugaku?

 

[Mari Makinami]

Yes, he could. Would be enough to mark every Uchiha clan member with FTG in public. I'm sure Itachi would've helped to do that.

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Yes he would of been able to save them or rather their death's probably would not of even be needed if he had survived.

 

[loj]

He surely would.

 

[New knight48]

Yeah minato probably could've prevented it.

 

[Urda]

Only those who are able to control the Kyuubi are Hashirama and the Uchiha. So, the suspension would have still be on the Uchiha Clan. It is unknown, but him stopping the massacre would not make a difference as the Uchiha upraising is a cause that would bring about War on a global scale and further hurt Konoha.

 

[CrazyTheorist]

Yes, he could. Would be enough to mark every Uchiha clan member with FTG in public. I'm sure Itachi would've helped to do that.

That would have only made the situation worse...not to mention it would be amoral and totally against his personality.

 

[Ricardo]

I believe if he was alive, he could had avoided the massacre, he said that himself.

 

[Urda]

I believe if he was alive, he could had avoided the massacre, he said that himself.

Scan?

Also, the Uchiha were already feeling oppress from being isolated. It was only a matter of time.

 

[Ken Kaneki]

The only requirement to stop massacre are that he must have been stronger than Danzo and Fugaku. He was stronger than both so yes.

 

[Ricardo]

Scan?

Also, the Uchiha were already feeling oppress from being isolated. It was only a matter of time.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Urda]

You must be registered for see images

He said maybe. >.> So he don't even know. But, I'm sure he would have given them more involvement in village affairs.

 

[blazekev90]

Stop the massacre in what aspect? Finding an alternative rather than killing the entire clan or defeating Itachi/Danzo?

 

[Sentinel of Light Style]

The real question is if he could have prevented the uprising, rather than the massacre.

 

[Gold Lightning]

Most likely.

It's annoying that we don't know what Fugaku and Minato's relationship was. Their wives were like best friends, so the two husbands should have an interesting relationship. If Sasuke could TNJ Sasuke, I'm sure Minato could do the same.

Only problem was Danzo, and he wouldn't dare oppose anyone except spineless Hiruzen.

 

[yondaimeminato]

Only those who are able to control the Kyuubi are Hashirama and the Uchiha. So, the suspension would have still be on the Uchiha Clan. It is unknown, but him stopping the massacre would not make a difference as the Uchiha upraising is a cause that would bring about War on a global scale and further hurt Konoha.

It's true, but minato could have united the uchiha and village to fight this person with the mask. Minato didn't know who he was but he would have urge the higher ups to worry more about finding out who this masked guy was rather than blaming it on the uchiha blindly. I am pretty sure he wouldn't blame it on the uchiha. instead he would ask for their help and assistance to find who this mask guy was since the uchiha possessed the sharingan which makes them good at tracking. This would have been a good way to reunite the uchiha and village.

 

[Mari Makinami]

That would have only made the situation worse...not to mention it would be amoral and totally against his personality.

Against whose personality? That same man that murdered hundreds of Iwa's shinobi in the very same manner because they were a threat to Konoha? I don't think you understand what does it mean to be Hokage, bruh.

And how would it had made situation worse if it would've prevented any coup what so ever? The whole clan being alive and well, just guaranted to not attack Konoha due to being marked, is worse than the whole clan wiped out? :| Awesome logic.

 

[Urda]

It's true, but minato could have united the uchiha and village to fight this person with the mask. Minato didn't know who he was but he would have urge the higher ups to worry more about finding out who this masked guy was rather than blaming it on the uchiha blindly. I am pretty sure he wouldn't blame it on the uchiha. instead he would ask for their help and assistance to find who this mask guy was since the uchiha possessed the sharingan which makes them good at tracking. This would have been a good way to reunite the uchiha and village.

The Uchiha has the eye power to control Tail Beast. I'm sure Danzou would used that.

 

[yondaimeminato]

The Uchiha has the eye power to control Tail Beast. I'm sure Danzou would used that.

minato knows pretty well that it requires a powerful person like madara to control the size of the nine tail demon fox. not all uchihas have the power of madara. if obito was able to control nine tail demon fox was because of the infused chakra of hashirama. Minato is smart enough to rule out the uchiha clan. Minato was recognized as a genius by the village. Not only third hokage would have been on his side but also many others. danzou wouldn't have been able to say anything had minato survived

 

[-Akuma-]

Probably, Hizuren was the most spineless Hokage, Minato couldn't take Danzou's shit and would likely try and help Itachi.