PhotM: Discussion/Theme Suggestion Thread
- Thread starter Scorps
- Start date
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
em not against of any rule,
em just saying to review it and what ever the mods will decide is fine by me.
em just asking to make the obligation on those images only which don't have any NB proof, only those images should be submitted by 2 more images with NB proof.
2 more images which authenticates the main pic should not be necessary, if the main pic already have the NB proof itself.
tell me what do you think ?
Hey Aertes
em not against of any rule,
em just saying to review it and what ever the mods will decide is fine by me.
em just asking to make the obligation on those images only which don't have any NB proof, only those images should be submitted by 2 more images with NB proof.
2 more images which authenticates the main pic should not be necessary, if the main pic already have the NB proof itself.
tell me what do you think ?
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
You mean that we can have both rules and the members decide which one they want to follow?
If the main pic has NB on it, we don't need to submit two more pictures for authentication and if the members don't want to embed the NB sign on their entry they need to submit more pics? Is that your proposal?
I am not against it, just as long as members understand that either way is fine and don't start complaining about who did most work or why someone does this and not that etc.
Wait, I didn't get that.
You mean that we can have both rules and the members decide which one they want to follow?
If the main pic has NB on it, we don't need to submit two more pictures for authentication and if the members don't want to embed the NB sign on their entry they need to submit more pics? Is that your proposal?
I am not against it, just as long as members understand that either way is fine and don't start complaining about who did most work or why someone does this and not that etc.
Frankenstein
Active member
Awards
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
Oh man it has been a long time since this contest had some tension :heh:
In Thor's case I think the logical thing to do, since the photo did include the NB sign in it, which was and still is enough to prove the validity of the pic, would have been to allow the entry.
I prefer the three pics rule of course but it was the first time and the NB sign inclusion was only replaced by the three pics rule for ease and in order not to limit the members' options when taking their photo. The rules can coexist, since they are not mutually exclusive, though I see no reason to not click the camera two more times.
In Waindo's case, I can assure you that almost always the picture that won was the best taken or at least top two (I was inactive during some period though so some scum might have won undeservedly
).
Salt is good in contests as long as it's not toxic, it means there is competition.
Oh man it has been a long time since this contest had some tension :heh:
In Thor's case I think the logical thing to do, since the photo did include the NB sign in it, which was and still is enough to prove the validity of the pic, would have been to allow the entry.
I prefer the three pics rule of course but it was the first time and the NB sign inclusion was only replaced by the three pics rule for ease and in order not to limit the members' options when taking their photo. The rules can coexist, since they are not mutually exclusive, though I see no reason to not click the camera two more times.
In Waindo's case, I can assure you that almost always the picture that won was the best taken or at least top two (I was inactive during some period though so some scum might have won undeservedly
). Salt is good in contests as long as it's not toxic, it means there is competition.
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
@green, was it for me ??
I am not saying all this because my pic was not selected, Absolutely Not.
I am just suggesting to make amendments because it sounds more logical,
off course when I ever take pic i shoot extra pics too and it doesn't cost any thing to upload extra pics too. but when the main pic itself has the NB proof, so what reason is left to upload the extra 2 pics em just saying that.
--
However I think we already discussed allot on this matter lol, let mods decide now, I am ok with either one.
@Bold, Yeah thats exactly what I am saying.
@green, was it for me ??
Hey Frankenstein !Oh man it has been a long time since this contest had some tension :heh:
In Thor's case I think the logical thing to do, since the photo did include the NB sign in it, which was and still is enough to prove the validity of the pic, would have been to allow the entry.
I prefer the three pics rule of course but it was the first time and the NB sign inclusion was only replaced by the three pics rule for ease and in order not to limit the members' options when taking their photo. The rules can coexist, since they are not mutually exclusive, though I see no reason to not click the camera two more times.
In Waindo's case, I can assure you that almost always the picture that won was the best taken or at least top two (I was inactive during some period though so some scum might have won undeservedly
Salt is good in contests as long as it's not toxic, it means there is competition.
I am not saying all this because my pic was not selected, Absolutely Not.
I am just suggesting to make amendments because it sounds more logical,
off course when I ever take pic i shoot extra pics too and it doesn't cost any thing to upload extra pics too. but when the main pic itself has the NB proof, so what reason is left to upload the extra 2 pics em just saying that.
--
However I think we already discussed allot on this matter lol, let mods decide now, I am ok with either one.
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
After discussions with uncle Scorps, we've decided to make this as a test rule:
Users will have the option to submit one picture with the NB proof on them, which will proceed to voting (note that this image doesn't have to be supported with other pictures)
So basically, you can choose to submit one picture with the NB proof on it which will proceed to voting without supporting pictures, or you can choose the previous rule.
After discussions with uncle Scorps, we've decided to make this as a test rule:
Users will have the option to submit one picture with the NB proof on them, which will proceed to voting (note that this image doesn't have to be supported with other pictures)
So basically, you can choose to submit one picture with the NB proof on it which will proceed to voting without supporting pictures, or you can choose the previous rule.
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
Or is this test rule the one that we'll have to use ?
If that is so, Tom, I don't like it U_U !
Does this mean that we can choose between each option ?
Or is this test rule the one that we'll have to use ?
If that is so, Tom, I don't like it U_U !
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
Tom is doing a good job U_U !Yes you can choose between the options
And its a test rule in the sense that we'll monitor it and see if anyone tries to exploit it.
Alice in Noodleland
Active member
Awards
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
You have no idea.
>.> the theme is so simple that it was so hard what subject to choose. T.T
You have no idea.
You must be registered for see images
Re: PhotM: Discussion Thread
Nope, it was a general comment.
I just need to steal find a boat.