Hinata and Sakura comparison

[SPIRTofleo]

Well the novels are not canon that is clear. You then asked for legitmaticy of The Last movie. You got your answer for that. Now I don't get whats the confusion about?

It was never stated that the novels were canon or not also their is no confusion, I already seen your post that the last was canon, and that's not even the main point of this thread.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

It was never stated that it was canon or not also their is no confusion, I already seen your post that the last was canon, and that's not even the main point of this thread.

You compared Hinata's character with Sakura's character based on there display of character from the Last and the non canon novel. So it is the point of this thread.

 

[Shruikan]

What do you mean?, he kept bringing up the fact that the novel was not canon, which was not proved yet, and it's not even the main point of the thread, but he keeps trying to deny everything I have to say.

I haven't read the past pages but these are facts

1.Novels written by different authors
2.Take place between 699 and 700
3.Not explicitly stated canon
4.The last is written by Pierott with Kishi during the script here and there and is stated canon



My opinion

There is no need to rely on novels to state Sakura >Hinata as Hinata is much too irrelevant than Sakura even for a side character in the canon story line

Also those who aren't accepting Hinata wearing apron isn't a housewife in 700 are gonna get a rude awakening in part 3

 

[SPIRTofleo]

You compared Hinata's character with Sakura's character based on there display of character from the Last and the non canon novel. So it is the point of this thread.

You obvisouly can't read properly, because I was talking to swagnurotobo about what he was saying, you keep jumping to different conversations, also I never said the last was not canon, I just wanted proof, that's all

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

You obvisouly can't read properly, because I was talking to swagnurotobo about what he was saying, you keep jumping to different conversations, also I never said the last was not canon, I just wanted proof, that's all

Dude I asked you what the confusion was about? Now you are telling me that I don't know how to read properly? What the **** are you talking about? I don't think you even know what the purpose of this thread is anymore.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

I haven't read the past pages but these are facts

1.Novels written by different authors
2.Take place between 699 and 700
3.Not explicitly stated canon
4.The last is written by Pierott with Kishi during the script here and there and is stated canon



My opinion

There is no need to rely on novels to state Sakura >Hinata as Hinata is much too irrelevant than Sakura even for a side character in the canon story line

Also those who aren't accepting Hinata wearing apron isn't a housewife in 700 are gonna get a rude awakening in part 3

I only used the last and novels, because I mostly wanted to show who's grown more, which is why in the thread I said "shows more facts why Sakura>hinata", In one of the discussions on the page, I also stated reasons from the manga

 

[Shruikan]

Dude I asked you what the confusion was about? Now you are telling me that I don't know how to read properly? What the **** are you talking about? I don't think you even know what the purpose of this thread is anymore.

I thought the purpose of this thread was Sakura vs Hinata and I was expecting good comments.I was disappointed

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Dude I asked you what the confusion was about? Now you are telling me that I don't know how to read properly? What the **** are you talking about? I don't think you even know what the purpose of this thread is anymore.

Their is no confusion, and I do know what I'm talking about.

 

[lndra]

I thought the purpose of this thread was Sakura vs Hinata and I was expecting good comments.I was disappointed

Thank God those are gone. Anyone saying Hinata could beat Sakura is on crack.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

I thought the purpose of this thread was Sakura vs Hinata and I was expecting good comments.I was disappointed

The thread had a flawed logic from the begining. He compared a non canon evidence with canon material. And called one character better by using a filler. Lol

Their is no confusion, and I do know what I'm talking about.

No you don't. You think you do but you don't.

 

[Shruikan]

I only used the last and novels, because I mostly wanted to show who's grown more, which is why in the thread I said "shows more facts why Sakura>hinata", In one of the discussions on the page, I also stated reasons from the manga

Well as to the novels canonicity we should see if it's relevant in Part 3?if Sakura actually has opened a medical unit and all the shit the novels are tellin us,than its canon otherwise not really.
Yeah even in the last the way she keeps knitting that scarf was hilarious and even after marriage.I mean that's something my granma used to do.Dusting shelves>Knitting scarves

 

[SPIRTofleo]

The thread had a flawed logic from the begining. He compared a non canon evidence with canon material. And called one character better by using a filler. Lol

You could really hop off of me, because like I clearly stated in the thread, I was talking about the last and the novels, also in some discussions I brung up some stuff about the manga aswell, so their is no flawed logic.

 

[lndra]

Well as to the novels canonicity we should see if it's relevant in Part 3?if Sakura actually has opened a medical unit and all the shit the novels are tellin us,than its canon otherwise not really.
Yeah even in the last the way she keeps knitting that scarf was hilarious and even after marriage.I mean that's something my granma used to do.Dusting shelves>Knitting scarves

I don't see how knitting scarves is bad when Kushina also made one for Naruto, and he also received an assortment of gifts. I mean it was winter, and I think for her that is how she shows a peace of her love. Similar to how Molly Weasley gave her children knitted sweaters for Christmas, she was knitting a scarf. It was winter after-all.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

You could really hop off of me, because like I clearly stated in the thread, I was talking about the last and the novels, also in some discussions I brung up some stuff about the manga aswell, so their is no flawed logic.

You might want to get some reading lessons then.

Spoiler

If you haven't noticed,you can see that for the most part, Hinata character still didn't change, the difference is that she got with Naruto, but even looking at last movie, mostly all Hinata was doing was trying to impress her Naruto-kun still being shy and still getting saved By Naruto and just like for the whole story, her whole character is just being based on being with Naruto.

While In Sakura Hidan, (Shown in spoilers) Sakura is doing things for herself and is actually Interacting and being helpful to the village and it's not just Sasuke centre, she's interacting with more people and doing other things, even from scenes in the last show, she's more useful now

Not Saying that Sakura is a good female lead, but this just shows more that Sakura>Hinata

^That was your original arguement. You used the novel and The last as the basis of your argument. And over here you state that I don't know how to read properly?

 

[Shruikan]

I don't see how knitting scarves is bad when Kushina also made one for Naruto, and he also received an assortment of gifts. I mean it was winter, and I think for her that is how she shows a peace of her love. Similar to how Molly Weasley gave her children knitted sweaters for Christmas, she was knitting a scarf. It was winter after-all.

Kushina is a housewife and knitting is normally their trademark.Molly Weasley was also a housewife for near entirety of all 7 books except when she took down Bellatrix in the last book.Dusting shelves isn't that bad in comparison.It may seem a little more insulting but it's less of a trademark of a housewife

 

[Dannie]

It's funny how you got what you wanted in the end, and yet you are still trying to bicker on Hinata's character as if it has any influence on Sakura's, and trying to act as if Ssakura's justification is any better.

If you haven't noticed,you can see that for the most part, Hinata character still didn't change,

I guess you didn't read the war arc, when Hinata went from

You must be registered for see links

, to someone who

You must be registered for see links

when all seemed lost.

the difference is that she got with Naruto,

And what's the difference between Sakura in part 1 and Sakura in part 2? Oh I know. The difference is that she got with Sasuke..

but even looking at last movie, mostly all Hinata was doing was trying to impress her Naruto-kun still being shy and still getting saved By Naruto and just like for the whole story, her whole character is just being based on being with Naruto.

You want to talk about character do you? A good character starts from the base and then expands upon that base. If you are blank and have no information on your life or past, family or clan then you are not even developed to begin with.

Hinata started off as a weak girl and her father didn't have any faith in her talent and even banned her from the home for her weakness. This gave her a lot to think about and even questioned her own strength, but Naruto came along and changed all that.

The difference between Hinata and Sakura is quite easy to see. Hinata knows what to find in herself and she has enough respect to cling onto a guy that will treat her well. What do we have with Sakura? Constantly trying to make herself look foolish and pathetic in bringing Sasuke to her way of thinking? Sasuke has repeatedly told this girl off and almost ended her life on several occasions and still she constantly continues to cling onto him and call him her lover without knowing a damn thing about him. That's ignorance.

Unlike with Sakura, at least Hinata has a redeemable backstory and past. Your argument is from the last, is it? Well, that's fine and all, but both of these females sole purpose was to be supporting figures for the male leads. I'm pretty sure we have heard plenty of "Sasuke-kuns" in the entire story and you are still complaining about Hinata's "Naruto'kuns" as if she is the only one who does it?

You are basically implying that Sakura is not all about Sasuke while Hinata is all about Naruto when you have it backwards. They are both about their respective counterparts, but the thing is quite clear. Hinata deserves to love Naruto. Sakura trying to force love on someone who was never interested in the same way does not deserve to be loved back.

While In Sakura Hidan, (Shown in spoilers) Sakura is doing things for herself and is actually Interacting and being helpful to the village and it's not just Sasuke centre,

And do you have any proof that Hinata isn't doing anything for the village? I'm pretty sure that she is taking care of her kids while Naruto is busy running the village. At this point, you are just making assumptions when in fact you don't even know what Hinata does with her life.

she's interacting with more people and doing other things, even from scenes in the last show, she's more useful now

*Yawn* go cry me something else I already didn't know.

Not Saying that Sakura is a good female lead, but this just shows more that Sakura>Hinata

And this is enough proof that you are just trying to start something and still can't come up with any good point to begin with.

It must be a known thing for Sakura fans to make countless shit threads just to prove that she is better than someone else. How pathetic.

 

[SPIRTofleo]

You might want to get some reading lessons then.


^That was your original arguement. You used the novel and The last as the basis of your argument. And over here you state that I don't know how to read properly?

Yeah they were the base of my argument, I also talked about the actual manga, in argument with dead pool, on on one of the pages In this thread, so like I said you can kindly get off of me, because their is no flawed logic.

 

[lndra]

You might want to get some reading lessons then.


^That was your original arguement. You used the novel and The last as the basis of your argument. And over here you state that I don't know how to read properly?

The bad part was that he had to use Hinata as a justification to make Sakura seem like a good character. Oh the irony

 

[SPIRTofleo]

The bad part was that he had to use Hinata as a justification to make Sakura seem like a good character. Oh the irony

I wasn't trying to justify sakura's character, this thread was aimed at the people who thought that Hinata was better then Sakura, so oh the irony to yourself

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

Yeah they were the base of my argument, I also talked about the actual manga, in argument with dead pool, on on one of the pages In this thread, so like I said you can kindly get off of me, because their is no flawed logic.

So I was supposed to search up a post of yours with deadpool? When your opening post was stating something else? Dude you are a terrible troll.

The bad part was that he had to use Hinata as a justification to make Sakura seem like a good character. Oh the irony

He did it because people claimed Hinata was a better character. So this whole thing was a childish attempt anyways.