[Question] How big is OP planet size?

[Nox]

There's nothing that suggests that.

Is there something that suggests otherwise? I am quite interested to see.

 

[Hexuze]

Is there something that suggests otherwise? I am quite interested to see.

How can you say at the very least the universe is as small as Jupiter? The only feat. we got was that the OP world has 6 moons. How you came to that conclusion is what I'm asking.

 

[Nox]

How can you say at the very least the universe is as small as Jupiter?

I looked at the size of the planet, looked at the sizes of the moon. Thought back to my sixth grade science class and the planetary chart that was there and decided to settle on the biggest planet on our solar system. Its all about the gut feeling. Which is why I showed interest in your post as you seemed to have something more concrete to disprove my crack pot claim. Now do you have a panel/idea/theory that may disprove me or can I go on believing in my 'belief' until Oda provides panels.

 

[Hexuze]

I looked at the size of the planet, looked at the sizes of the moon. Thought back to my sixth grade science class and the planetary chart that was there and decided to settle on the biggest planet on our solar system. Its all about the gut feeling. Which is why I showed interest in your post as you seemed to have something more concrete to disprove my crack pot claim. Now do you have a panel/idea/theory that may disprove me or can I go on believing in my 'belief' until Oda provides panels.

How did you even scale the size of the planet by just looking at the panel? I'm just curious. I have no idea how that relates to the universe, you mean the OP world, yeah?

 

[Nox]

How did you even scale the size of the planet by just looking at the panel? I'm just curious. I have no idea how that relates to the universe, you mean the OP world, yeah?

Yeah. IDK its was another one of my random whimsical decision. I figured OP should be just as big as gas giant so I settled on the biggest one I knew. It was one of those misconceptions you hold for a long time you start believing it yourself,

 

[Hexuze]

Yeah. IDK its was another one of my random whimsical decision. I figured OP should be just as big as gas giant so I settled on the biggest one I knew. It was one of those misconceptions you hold for a long time you start believing it yourself,

Even then, how could you come to that conclusion? I don't think saying that just because it has 6 moons, it's the size of Jupiter.

 

[Love Cook]

If it was as big as Jupiter you can't reach the other side by boat.

End of discussion

It's pretty obvious that the planet is around Earth size.

 

[Tomato God]

There's nothing that suggests that.

except it has basically a mini solar system orbiting it.

 

[Hexuze]

except it has basically a mini solar system orbiting it.

Yeah 6 moons, that's no where close to the amount of moons Jupiter has. Love Cook's comment should end this debate. Although I'd like to think it's slightly bigger than planet earth.

 

[Tomato God]

Yeah 6 moons, that's no where close to the amount of moons Jupiter has. Love Cook's comment should end this debate. Although I'd like to think it's slightly bigger than planet earth.

One of its moons. Has a moon. So therefore all its moons must be atleast the size of a planet

You must be registered for see links

So lets say for arguements sake that that planet with a moon is the size of mercury.

You must be registered for see images

Obviously those distances are scaled just like we do with our moon to earth globes.
This is an actual disance of a moon to a planet like ours

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

That would make the big ceneter planet at least the size of Neptune.
And to have a satilite that has a satilite it must be big enough to have the satilite's moon not be sucked into its gravitational feild so its gotta be able to mantain a HUGE distance (star's to its planets type disance)
So for that planet to have a moon that has a moon it should be by our worlds standards the size of a super giant or a mini dwarf star.

So saying jupiter is a conservative estimate.

 

[Hexuze]

One of its moons. Has a moon. So therefore all its moons must be atleast the size of a planet

You must be registered for see links

So lets say for arguements sake that that planet with a moon is the size of mercury.

You must be registered for see images

Obviously those distances are scaled just like we do with our moon to earth globes.
This is an actual disance of a moon to a planet like ours

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

That would make the big ceneter planet at least the size of Neptune.
And to have a satilite that has a satilite it must be big enough to have the satilite's moon not be sucked into its gravitational feild so its gotta be able to mantain a HUGE distance (star's to its planets type disance)
So for that planet to have a moon that has a moon it should be by our worlds standards the size of a super giant or a mini dwarf star.

So saying jupiter is a conservative estimate.

Then there's no way you can travel by a ship. Jupiter has 60+ moons, whereas the OP world has only 6. I don't think the scale is correct either.

 

[Tomato God]

Then there's no way you can travel by a ship. Jupiter has 60+ moons, whereas the OP world has only 6. I don't think the scale is correct either.

Yea but Jupiters moons dont have moons.

If jupiter's moons had their own moons jupiters gravity would over rule its moons and then those moon's smaller moons would just orbit jupiter....

Any thing that can have a moon is atleast a planet.

So all the moons around the one piece world are planet sized

And if A big thing has planets orbiting it. Its probably the size of a star.

 

[Love Cook]

Yea but Jupiters moons dont have moons.

If jupiter's moons had their own moons jupiters gravity would over rule its moons and then those moon's smaller moons would just orbit jupiter....

Any thing that can have a moon is atleast a planet.

So all the moons around the one piece world are planet sized

And if A big thing has planets orbiting it. Its probably the size of a star.

Don't be dumb, they're sailing in a wooden ship to the end of the world and back again.

If you would walk 5 mph it would take you 345 days to walk around the earth. For Jupiter it would be 50 years or 23 days in a plane at 880 km/h.

You clearly cannot fathom how large this planet is.

[video=youtube;u1Yi58jtNdY]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1Yi58jtNdY[/video]

OP world is around Earth size, anything bigger would be ridiculous. The only evidence you have is a guestimate of the size of a moon of a moon. It could also be some kind of significant satellite around the moon which would totally change the perspective.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

No way the SHs could sail from the East Blue to the Grand Line, and then sail halfway across the planet in less than a year if the One Piece world was as large as Jupiter.

 

[Tomato God]

Don't be dumb, they're sailing in a wooden ship to the end of the world and back again.

If you would walk 5 mph it would take you 345 days to walk around the earth. For Jupiter it would be 50 years or 23 days in a plane at 880 km/h.

You clearly cannot fathom how large this planet is.

[video=youtube;u1Yi58jtNdY]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1Yi58jtNdY[/video]

OP world is around Earth size, anything bigger would be ridiculous. The only evidence you have is a guestimate of the size of a moon of a moon. It could also be some kind of significant satellite around the moon which would totally change the perspective.

I guess you're right... The world has to be small enough to sail around it.

 

[Ridoku X]

It's about as big as Uranus. :| :snick:&autoplay=1[/YOUTUBE