While I was continuing to write my fanfiction, and trying to find more plot devices and characterizations to relate Madara more to Naruto, this more or less just popped into my head while I was rewriting on how the two met or would later meet again where Obito and the Gedo Mazou were. I was trying to think of a line Madara could fetch such as, "This chakra is..Hashirama's? It's impossible..he even appears to show the same bravery and foolishness as him..Perhaps an heir?" "Who or what are you, yellow-haired brat?" Doesn't it seem strange that Madara was able to sense Hashirama's chakra, but could not sense that Naruto and Sasuke possessed their chakras as well?
Being a reincarnation of a transmigrant, does not mean that the chakra signatures are identical. You have Ashura/Indra's soul within you, and it affects your power, but the way it affects your chakra signature is obviously different from reincarnation to reincarnation.
That doesn't mean they have the same chakra. Naruto has Uzumaki and Namikaze chakra mixed in with Ashura's. It formed its own unique chakra, just like every other individual.
That statement is a fallacy. Hagoromo himself stated Madara manifested his rinnegan and the six paths chakra by combining the chakras of both sons, which were in Hashirama and Madara, and then Naruto and Sasuke.
If you mean last air bender, this is a different series written by a different author. You may find similarities, but they are neither the same story nor universe. And doesn't that sound a bit farfetched and gimmicky? I mean, if you possessed the same lives and powers of the previous ones, shouldn't that make you godly and possessing countless powers?
Sigh...I'm not talking about souls. Souls were not mentioned a single time in my op. I was referring to chakra, and based on Hagoromo's statements, logic suggests that Madara should have recognized Naruto and Sasuke's chakra natures.
When was it stated Naruto didn't have it? Not using it and not having it are two different things. It could be dormant like the sharingan or other kekkei genki, taking on a different form or Naruto may simply not being using it after the end of the manga.
You have Ashura/Indra's soul within you, and it affects your power, but the way it affects your chakra signature is obviously different from reincarnation to reincarnation.
That sounds a bit more reasonable and is one of the solutions I was thinking of. However, that would also include Kurama's chakra. And Madara not recognizing that in their first encounter, especially when it was visible seemed a bit odd as well.
That sounds a bit more reasonable and is one of the solutions I was thinking of. However, that would also include Kurama's chakra. And Madara not recognizing that in their first encounter, especially when it was visible seemed a bit odd as well.
If you mean last air bender, this is a different series written by a different author. You may find similarities, but they are neither the same story nor universe. And doesn't that sound a bit farfetched and gimmicky? I mean, if you possessed the same lives and powers of the previous ones, shouldn't that make you godly and possessing countless powers?
Sigh...I'm not talking about souls. Souls were not mentioned a single time in my op. I was referring to chakra, and based on Hagoromo's statements, logic suggests that Madara should have recognized Naruto and Sasuke's chakra natures.
When was it stated Naruto didn't have it? Not using it and not having it are two different things. It could be dormant like the sharingan or other kekkei genki, taking on a different form or Naruto may simply not being using it after the end of the manga.
Ok, for one, I was comparing what you believe to Avatar. In no way was I saying they are in the same universe, obviously they are in different universes and made by different people.
Two, ok, I meant to say that he does not have the chakra of Hashirama, just of Ashura
Three... -_- really
I get that you're just trying to troll, but c'mon man. You were successful though in rustling my jimmies a bit. But in the end, you're still wrong in believing Naruto has Hashirama's chakra
Call me a troll again and you'll be derepped and reported. I'm not in the mood for that garbage, and if you think I'm "trolling," by all means, test me and see what happens.
No I don't recall that. Even if it were true, Madara didn't have his rinnegan active at that time either. So his sensing ability was turned off and there were also a thousand other shinobi present.
No I don't recall that. Even if it were true, Madara didn't have his rinnegan active at that time either. So his sensing ability was turned off and there were also a thousand other shinobi present.
I can't find a link for it but I believe either Jiraiya or Minato stated it in either Orochimaru's Rebellion, The Search for Tsunade or the Pein Invasion arcs.
Technically, the sharingan can see chakra compositions, just not really chakra networks like Byakugan or Rinnegan. Sasuke showed this in his fight with Deidara. And Madara did activate Rinnegan before Kabuto told him Naruto was Kurama's jinchuriki. He even tried to summon Kurama when Naruto was next to him before Kabuto said a word about it.
Madara didn't sense Naruto and Sasuke's chakra cause they do not have Hashirama and Madara's chakra respectively
The only thing that related them to each other was Asura and Indra's soul. Hashirama had his own unique chakra, as did Naruto. Madara had his own unique chakra as did Sasuke
Ashura's soul simply moved from Hashi to Naruto, not his chakra. Indra's soul moved from Madara to Sasuke, not his chakra.
If that were the case, Madara would've thought that Sasuke had the same chakra as him, but the only thing he said was that they shared some connection. It would've been clear they share the same chakra if Madara said, he seems to have the same chakra as me, but he just said a connection. This connection was Indra's soul transmigrated between them.
So, no, Naruto and Sasuke did not share the same chakra as Hashi and Madara
I can't find a link for it but I believe either Jiraiya or Minato stated it in either the Search for Tsunade arc or the Pein Invasion arc.
Technically, the sharingan can see chakra compositions, just not really chakra networks like Byakugan or Rinnegan. Sasuke showed this in his fight with Deidara. And Madara did activate Rinnegan before Kabuto told him Naruto was Kurama's jinchuriki. He even tried to summon Kurama when Naruto was next to him before Kabuto said a word about it.
Sharingan can see chakra natures, I doubt it can sense a person's identity like the Byakugan.
Well, like I said. There were a thousand shinobi present and the Kyuubi hasn't given Naruto chakra at that point. I don't remember ever hearing that it leaked.
It only leaked when Naruto became angry and subconsciously unsealed it.
Your subjective, unfounded or explained view of transmigration is irrelevant. 
