Are some asian nations more asian-er than others?

Conspirator.

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
19,435
Reaction score
3,378
Very doubtful of this, but I could be wrong.



I know that Wikipedia is not the most reliable source of information, but you can verify this information for yourself by looking at other sites, or by talking to some other British people. I'm almost a 100% certain that I'm right in this case.
 

Prometheus Beta

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
877
Reaction score
111
"Asian" as a continental term is not a very meaningful category -unlike with Europe, there is no single racial group, and relatively little social and cultural uniformity, common history etc by comparison as well. In fact, "western Asia" also includes the Middle East in the geographic sense but I accept the convention that "Asia" refers to the region East of Iran.

Now I have not read all that much into the history of that continent but it seems to me that there are several meaningful groups if we try to categorize its peoples: first, there are the "East Asians" consisting of two distinct groups, namely the North East Asians of Mongolia, China, Korea and Japan, and the South East Asians (e.g. Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines etc).

Another group are the Central Asians: this comprises the "stan" countries barring Afghanistan and Pakistan, i.e. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and the others. Probably relatively little known outside Russia considering that they were effectively absorbed by the Russian empire and later became part of the Soviet Union, and only became independent states some few decades ago.

Then there is the familiar South Asian group of Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. Afghanistan is somewhat anomalous because it is at the boundary of several regions and is highly ethnically diverse but I would put it here since the dominant group there, the Pathans, seem to have closest affinity to Pakistan (they also inhabit the North-West region of that country). The same goes for Nepal though the Nepalese have a far greater affinity to China than Afghanistan does to Central Asia.

PS SkyFall is correct, here we use the term "Oriental" for the East Asians and "Asian" for the South Asians.
 
Last edited:

Conspirator.

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
19,435
Reaction score
3,378
"Asian" as a continental term is not a very meaningful category -unlike with Europe, there is no single racial group, and relatively little social and cultural uniformity, common history etc by comparison as well. In fact, "western Asia" also includes the Middle East in the geographic sense but I accept the convention that "Asia" refers to the region East of Iran.

Now I have not read all that much into the history of that continent but it seems to me that there are several meaningful groups if we try to categorize its peoples: first, there are the "East Asians" consisting of two distinct groups, namely the North East Asians of Mongolia, China, Korea and Japan, and the South East Asians (e.g. Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines etc).

Another group are the Central Asians: this comprises the "stan" countries barring Afghanistan and Pakistan, i.e. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and the others. Probably relatively little known outside Russia considering that they were effectively absorbed by the Russian empire and later became part of the Soviet Union, and only became independent states some few decades ago.


Then there is the familiar South Asian group of Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. Afghanistan is somewhat anomalous because it is at the boundary of several regions and is highly ethnically diverse but I would put it here since the dominant group there, the Pathans, seem to have closest affinity to Pakistan (they also inhabit the North-West region of that country). The same goes for Nepal though the Nepalese have a far greater affinity to China than Afghanistan does to Central Asia.

PS SkyFall is correct, here we use the term "Oriental" for the East Asians and "Asian" for the South Asians.

The bold is especially true. I only know about them since I was watching one of those quiz shows with prize money on the line some years back, and one of the questions was "How many countries in the world end in "Stan". Afterwards, I looked them up. Otherwise, I probably wouldn't know about most of them. Lol
 

Ludicrous

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Dec 22, 2012
Messages
1,567
Reaction score
151
Yep, I'm Bengali and I can't even use the word Asian to describe myself in front of kids anymore. Everyone has stereotyped it to the point that it means a super smart Chinese kid.
 
Last edited:

Hexuze

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Reaction score
1,533
Yep, I'm Bengali and I can't even use the word Asian to describe myself in front of kids anymore. Everyone has stereotyped it to the point that it means a super smart Chinese kid.

Then use "south asian".
 
Top