[Discussion] Bartolomeo, Viola and Kyros won't join the Strawhats.

[Limbo]

I honestly get surprised every time somebody says that either Bartolomeo or Kyros will join the SH, logically it shouldn't happen since Bartolomeo already has his own crew, the best he can do to the SH is become and allied to them.

Kyros probably won't join seeing as he finally reunited with his daughter, why should he join them?

Viola won't join because she can finally be with her family again, however, amongst the three, i think that it is most likely that Viola will join the SH.

Anyway, what are your thought on this?​

 

[Skylar Knight]

I agree with you. I'd like for Sugar to join, though.

 

[Limbo]

I agree with you. I'd like for Sugar to join, though.

Sugar? Isn't that the girl that eats grapes all the time? Nah bruh, i dislike her <:

 

[Ryuma720]

Viola-chan For StrawHat !!!!

 

[Anduril]

If Barto cannot join the strawhats, then Barto for First division commander of strawhat pirates!!

 

[Dannie]

Either Violet or shitty Rebecca will join.

 

[Naruto Power]

bart it the same as franky
its called the barto club when he is announced in the ring
franky had a club also. just bart already has the bounty

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

I honestly get surprised every time somebody says that either Bartolomeo or Kyros will join the SH, logically it shouldn't happen since Bartolomeo already has his own crew, the best he can do to the SH is become and allied to them.

Kyros probably won't join seeing as he finally reunited with his daughter, why should he join them?

Viola won't join because she can finally be with her family again, however, amongst the three, i think that it is most likely that Viola will join the SH.

Anyway, what are your thought on this?​

Those arguments could've been said for Nami (Cocoyashi Village) and Franky (Franky Brothers)

A Strawhat always has a sad past, and is inspired by other fictional characters or real people

All three have these characteristics. So they all have a chance of becoming a Strawhat

 

[Skylar Knight]

Those arguments could've been said for Nami (Cocoyashi Village) and Franky (Franky Brothers)

A Strawhat always has a sad past, and is inspired by other fictional characters or real people

All three have these characteristics. So they all have a chance of becoming a Strawhat

Yes, but there's nothing that suggests that these three have some sort of dream of their own, which has, up till now, been revealed during a member's past.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Bartolomeo is captain of his own crew, if he joins SH that he would literally let down whole his crew. And whole BP can't join, since that would be too much members.

Other two are possibility, if I had to choose I would pick Viola over Kyros.

 

[Skylar Knight]

Bartolomeo is captain of his own crew, if he joins SH that he would literally let down whole his crew. And whole BP can't join, since that would be too much members.

Other two are possibility, if I had to choose I would pick Viola over Kyros.

Both of them have just reunited with their family after eight whole years. Viola has her kingdom to take care of, and Kyros can finally be the father he always wanted to be. Just 'cause they all cool and would fit the crew perfectly, doesn't mean they don't have things they want on their own.

I agree with you on Bartelomeo, though.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Yes, but there's nothing that suggests that these three have some sort of dream of their own, which has, up till now, been revealed during a member's past.

Oda's flashbacks are not uniform. For example, Brooks was the last three chapters of the Thriller Bark Arc and Robins was during the Ennies Lobby Arc (four arcs after she joined the Strawhats). We also didn't know Nami's goal or Choppers goal until after they joined. Franky, Brook and Robin didn't even talk about their dreams until the very end of an arc.

Viola - Based on Violet Gibson
- Assassins, known for shooting Benito Mussolini (Doflamingo?)
- Viola could be a lookout, a position yet to be filled in
- She has already hinted that she wants to leave Dressrosa
- Sanji offered her to join them, she refused only because she "had business to take care of", much alike Jinbei who will almost certainly join them
-We already know of her dismal past
-She has bonded closely with Sanji, Zoro and Luffy - THE MONSTER TRIO, just about seals the deal really

Kyros - Based on Cyrus the great
- Great colosseum heroes come criminals after retiring from being a Gladiator, Cyrus also used to be a Roman General
- Unsure of a role in the crew right now, although he doesn't necessarily need one that functions on the ship (like Robin or Zoro)
- He has bonded closely with Luffy, Zoro, Usopp, Robin and Franky
- He has also had a horrific last ten years of his life
- However, he is heir to the Dressrosa throne, so he might not leave

Barolomeo - Based on Alice Cooper
- Famous for disruptive and mocking behaviour (similar appearance as well)
- Could be the "protector of the ship", with his barriers blocking all cannonfire
- He admires the Strawhats, he dreams of joining them
- He has met all of the Strawhats currently on the Island (and allies + Sabo)
- Having lived in slums for all of his life, he must have had a sad back story yet to be fully revealed
- His Pirate crew don't seem to be very important at all, only showing Gambia on three pages, he could easily leave them for the Strawhats anyday

 

[WhistleBlower]

Lol, i have and still do not believe anyone will join the strawhats this early in the new world. Strong & loyal Allies, yes but no new crew members of Dressrosa.

For reasons you have discussed above and also because all the contenders people like to mention have their own allegiances and responsibilities.

And for the love of god , please people stop comparing the first half of series to the second half. Oda doesn't repeat stuff, his only getting better as time goes by.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Lol, i have and still do not believe anyone will join the strawhats this early in the new world. Strong & loyal Allies, yes but no new crew members of Dressrosa.

For reasons you have discussed above and also because all the contenders people like to mention have their own allegiances and responsibilities.

Franky and Sanji had their own allegiances and responsibilities, did they not?

 

[WhistleBlower]

Franky and Sanji had their own allegiances and responsibilities, did they not?

Ill give you sanji but not franky. Frankys situation was different.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Both of them have just reunited with their family after eight whole years. Viola has her kingdom to take care of, and Kyros can finally be the father he always wanted to be. Just 'cause they all cool and would fit the crew perfectly, doesn't mean they don't have things they want on their own.

I agree with you on Bartelomeo, though.

Yeah they were away from their family for 8 years, I don't see a problem with them being away a little more. That wouldn't be first time in manga history that reunite will postponed for a little longer. With words "we waited this long, we can wait little longer."

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Ill give you sanji but not franky. Frankys situation was different.

No different. They were both encouraged to leave.

I'm sure if the Barto Club Pirates know Bartolomeo's dream is to join Luffy then they'd let him

 

[WhistleBlower]

No different. They were both encouraged to leave.

I'm sure if the Barto Club Pirates know Bartolomeo's dream is to join Luffy then they'd let him

How naive of you to think a captain can just throw away his crew as if they were mere tools.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

How naive of you to think a captain can just throw away his crew as if they were mere tools.

Bartolomeo would do anything to achieve his goals, a characteristic shared with every Mugiwara.

Isn't that what:
Don Krieg, Wapol, Crocodile (except for Daz Bones), Enel (although he isn't really a captain), Lucci (again, not quite a Pirate Captain), Bege, Sakazuki (not a captain, had many subordinates though), Hody and Caesar did? Leaving Subordinates behind, not thinking much of them

 

[WhistleBlower]

Bartolomeo would do anything to achieve his goals, a characteristic shared with every Mugiwara.

Isn't that what:
Don Krieg, Wapol, Crocodile (except for Daz Bones), Enel (although he isn't really a captain), Lucci (again, not quite a Pirate Captain), Bege, Sakazuki (not a captain, had many subordinates though), Hody and Caesar did? Leaving Subordinates behind, not thinking much of them

Bartho is not like all those you mentioned.
As for your "would do anything to achieve his goals, a characteristic shared with every Mugiwara". Further Explain upon this argument please.