So Kakashi out Smart Shikamaru & out taijutsu Lee?? Datebook 1

BenjerminGaye

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
19,423
Reaction score
823
That's because they were caught off guard, he didn't know he would be fighting Akatsuki nor did he know about their capabilities. Kakashi praised Shikamaru being able to make a plan after fighting them once and even reworking that plan to include him so Shikamaru had a plan to fight Kakuza and Hidan without Kakashi. Shikamaru had more than 1 plan, he had backup plans in case something goes wrong. He trapped them with Asuma blade that mimic his shadow possession. Use the needle to get Kakuza blood if Kakashi gets a chance. To separate them.
You must be registered for see images
They went looking for the akatsuki. Kakashi's praised him for doing somthing kakashi does all the time. Heck. Kakashi does it mid fight where as shikamaru needs a day and a half. All the plans you mentioned was to foil hidan since he had no info on kakazu's abilities.
The blood? Ruin hidan's ritual.
Trapping them in the shadow? Using hidan to find out kakazu's abilities and again to fck up hidan's ritual.


Why bring up Asuma dying? I remember Kakashi being leader of his team when Rin got kidnapped and it resulted in Obito "dying" but really turning evil that brought about war and many deaths which includes their teacher (Minato). See what happens when you look at the bad?
Because kakashi was hyped like that from back in Gaiden days...... Oh wait. He wasn't. The hype in question is in reference to part 2 and part 1.
Shikaku was the acting leader of the alliance and Shikamaru took over after that.
and then drwe blanks...
Both Shikamaru and Kakashi first learn what they can about their opponent then put a plan together,
never did i deny that.
Shikamaru can put together more plans which makes him the better strategist
based on nothing
Kakashi was literally doing nothing but watching Naruto and Sasuke fight Kaguya to see what all 3 can do.
What could he do? All the planning in the would would mean jack squat if the difference in power is too great. Yet the moment he closed some of the gap kaguya got served. He planned sasuke's approach (cuz he was too slow to even touch her) he planned naruto's setup (seeing how she got tricked by it before) he cut off her options(warped her bone and portal away/ripped her arm) he even made sakura useful.

Face it, kakashi's is just as good if not better than shikamaru at planning and analysis.
 

xxSAGExx

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
5,197
Reaction score
296
You must be registered for see images
They went looking for the akatsuki. Kakashi's praised him for doing somthing kakashi does all the time. Heck. Kakashi does it mid fight where as shikamaru needs a day and a half. All the plans you mentioned was to foil hidan since he had no info on kakazu's abilities.
The blood? Ruin hidan's ritual.
Trapping them in the shadow? Using hidan to find out kakazu's abilities and again to fck up hidan's ritual.


Because kakashi was hyped like that from back in Gaiden days...... Oh wait. He wasn't. The hype in question is in reference to part 2 and part 1.
and then drwe blanks...
never did i deny that.
based on nothing
What could he do? All the planning in the would would mean jack squat if the difference in power is too great. Yet the moment he closed some of the gap kaguya got served. He planned sasuke's approach (cuz he was too slow to even touch her) he planned naruto's setup (seeing how she got tricked by it before) he cut off her options(warped her bone and portal away/ripped her arm) he even made sakura useful.

Face it, kakashi's is just as good if not better than shikamaru at planning and analysis.

Ah you're right about that, I was remembering the many groups in the anime where they couldn't find them at all for a while. Considering Kakashi has more years of experiences, of course he would do it all the time, Shikamaru went from being lazy to stepping up as a leader in part 1 then Tsunade decided to give him many leader roles to gain experiences. Shikamaru did it mid battle 2 times in the Chunin exam when he fought the sound ninja girl and when he fought Temari. Without info he set up the Sasuke's retrieval team order to best utilize their skills and be ready if attacked from different angles. He also used it to fight Tayuya who was much stronger then him out smarting here before Temari came and finished her off.

That day and a half where he was mourning Asuma while spending time with his dad to get some advice, then deciding to get revenge and start planning? He started to play about here then it shows him studying something and training with Asuma blade then they were getting ready to go, it was a couple of hours since it was still bright out when they left. Yes and to take out Kakuza as well, they didn't know about the 5 hearts yet the getting Kakuza blood was a backup plan increase they didn't take them out with the first plan which was using his shadow possession and exploding Kunai to push them where he wanted then use Asuma's kunai which had Shadow possession chakra in it and .

Besides Kakashi praising Shikamaru for his many step plan, Kakuza praised his smarts too . He even planned out using Hidan to kill Kakuza and he even had backup plan where Choji would Attack if something happened to get one of them from control . Shikamaru plans have many steps and backup steps in case something happens. Actually yes, Kakashi was hyped back then; you would think the guy who graduated the academy at 5 and became Chunin at 6 would be smart since you need more than just skills. Chunins need to have the menality to lead their own ninja teams and Jounins need to not only have the menality to lead groups but have greater mentalities then Chunins. Kakashi was a Jounin in Kakashi Gaiden while Shikamaru was Genin and Chunin with these feats.

Drawing blanks that one time and because he could t see how they could fight such a being but he was the one to come up with everyone using earth jutsus and Bee using his tbb to try and divert the Juubi's Tbb and rallied up the whole alliance to not lose hope and to wait on the right time to Attack which made Temari praised him for being Hokage worthy. Shikaku putting Shikamaru in charge of the whole alliance strategies before he died instead of Kakashi is what makes him better strategist, you put the best in charge which is why A made Shikaku the acting leader when he and Tsunade left to fight Madara. Kakashi was still there at the time too, since that's when Neji was still alive.

All the strategies in the world huh? Yet Naruto was making his own strategies that landed hits on Kaguya right? Obito even made a strategy to save Sasuke but what could Kakashi do but watch and observe the battle. Make Sakura useful? She was always useful, I can list how useful she's been in the whole manga and it will show her being more useful then Lee, Neji, and many more ninjas. She was just healing the whole alliance with Tsunade, keeping Naruto alive, helped saved Sasuke, and helped beat Kaguya so no Kakashi didn't make her what she always was.

Kakashi's 29 years of experiences still puts him under Shikamaru's strategies, the next generation surpasses the last.
 

BenjerminGaye

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
19,423
Reaction score
823
Ah you're right about that, I was remembering the many groups in the anime where they couldn't find them at all for a while. Considering Kakashi has more years of experiences, of course he would do it all the time
I don't see what years have to do with it.... the hype in question isn't about anbu kakashi or Gaiden kakashi but current kakashi.
Shikamaru went from being lazy to stepping up as a leader in part 1
irrelevant from the point and the hype.
then Tsunade decided to give him many leader roles to gain experiences.
she had 0 other options for the sra mission, and she wasn't gonna let him go after the immortals without Kakashi.
Shikamaru did it mid battle 2 times in the Chunin exam when he fought the sound ninja girl and when he fought Temari.
I already acknowledged that.
Without info he set up the Sasuke's retrieval team order to best utilize their skills and be ready if attacked from different angles.
yet it ended up being 1v1's...and I'm quite sure he did have intel. Seeing as how the sound 4 fought the leaf twice b4.
He also used it to fight Tayuya who was much stronger then him out smarting here before Temari came and finished her off.
he outsmarted her once, at the cost of his finger, and still had to get saved by temari.

That day and a half where he was mourning Asuma while spending time with his dad to get some advice, then deciding to get revenge and start planning? He started to play about here then it shows him studying something and training with Asuma blade then they were getting ready to go, it was a couple of hours since it was still bright out when they left.
Dosent compare to kakashi's mid match feats.
Yes and to take out Kakuza as well, they didn't know about the 5 hearts yet the getting Kakuza blood was a backup plan increase they didn't take them out with the first plan which was using his shadow possession and exploding Kunai to push them where he wanted then use Asuma's kunai which had Shadow possession chakra in it and .
that's to get kakazu's blood on hidan's blade and to try force kakazu to use his abilities.

Besides Kakashi praising Shikamaru for his many step plan, Kakuza praised his smarts too . He even planned out using Hidan to kill Kakuza and he even had backup plan where Choji would Attack if something happened to get one of them from control . Shikamaru plans have many steps and backup steps in case something happens.
your acting like Kakashi doesn't have multiple step plans. Against kaguya he cut her arm cutting off her attack options, used kamui on bone spike cutting off her portal options, and had sakura lie in wait cutting off her flight options.
Actually yes, Kakashi was hyped back then; you would think the guy who graduated the academy at 5 and became Chunin at 6 would be smart since you need more than just skills.
prodigy? Yes. Being as smart as shikamaru? No. How can he be hyped to be as smart as someone who isn't born yet?
Chunins need to have the menality to lead their own ninja teams and Jounins need to not only have the menality to lead groups but have greater mentalities then Chunins. Kakashi was a Jounin in Kakashi Gaiden while Shikamaru was Genin and Chunin with these feats.
wasn't shikamaru crying cuz his first Chunin mission went bad?

Drawing blanks that one time and because he could t see how they could fight such a being
yet your holding kakashi accountable for being in the same situation with kaguya. ..
but he was the one to come up with everyone using earth jutsus and Bee using his tbb to try and divert the Juubi's Tbb
which didn't work
and rallied up the whole alliance to not lose hope and to wait on the right time to Attack which made Temari praised him for being Hokage worthy.
hinata and sakura rallied the troops too... so I'm not really seeing your point with this.
Shikaku putting Shikamaru in charge of the whole alliance strategies before he died instead of Kakashi is what makes him better strategist
oh please bruh, that was a father son moment. He'd be a jerk if his last words was leaving it to kakashi.
you put the best in charge which is why A made Shikaku the acting leader when he and Tsunade left to fight Madara.
that was shikaku's role, kakashi was busy fighting the 7 swordsmen and obito.
Kakashi was still there at the time too, since that's when Neji was still alive.
already addressed.

All the strategies in the world huh? Yet Naruto was making his own strategies that landed hits on Kaguya right?
Naruto blitzed her, and overpowered her. Things he could do at any given moment, no plans necessary. Y? The power difference between them was minor.
Obito even made a strategy to save Sasuke
obito had kamui and again he needed naruto and sakura to even pull it off.
but what could Kakashi do but watch and observe the battle. Make Sakura useful?
Because Sakura could land hits on the god of nv without a plan from kakashi...
She was always useful, I can list how useful she's been in the whole manga and it will show her being more useful then Lee, Neji, and many more ninjas. She was just healing the whole alliance with Tsunade, keeping Naruto alive, helped saved Sasuke,
None of which has to do with the situation in which he made her useful.
and helped beat Kaguya so no Kakashi didn't make her what she always was.
due to kakashi's plan.

Kakashi's 29 years of experiences still puts him under Shikamaru's strategies,
age has nothing to do with the hype in question.
the next generation surpasses the last.
Greatest lie in the history of the manga.
 

xxSAGExx

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
5,197
Reaction score
296
I don't see what years have to do with it.... the hype in question isn't about anbu kakashi or Gaiden kakashi but current kakashi. irrelevant from the point and the hype.
she had 0 other options for the sra mission, and she wasn't gonna let him go after the immortals without Kakashi.
I already acknowledged that.
yet it ended up being 1v1's...and I'm quite sure he did have intel. Seeing as how the sound 4 fought the leaf twice b4.
he outsmarted her once, at the cost of his finger, and still had to get saved by temari.

Dosent compare to kakashi's mid match feats.
that's to get kakazu's blood on hidan's blade and to try force kakazu to use his abilities.

your acting like Kakashi doesn't have multiple step plans. Against kaguya he cut her arm cutting off her attack options, used kamui on bone spike cutting off her portal options, and had sakura lie in wait cutting off her flight options.
prodigy? Yes. Being as smart as shikamaru? No. How can he be hyped to be as smart as someone who isn't born yet?
wasn't shikamaru crying cuz his first Chunin mission went bad?

yet your holding kakashi accountable for being in the same situation with kaguya. ..
which didn't work
hinata and sakura rallied the troops too... so I'm not really seeing your point with this.
oh please bruh, that was a father son moment. He'd be a jerk if his last words was leaving it to kakashi. that was shikaku's role, kakashi was busy fighting the 7 swordsmen and obito.
already addressed.

Naruto blitzed her, and overpowered her. Things he could do at any given moment, no plans necessary. Y? The power difference between them was minor.
obito had kamui and again he needed naruto and sakura to even pull it off.
Because Sakura could land hits on the god of nv without a plan from kakashi...
None of which has to do with the situation in which he made her useful.
due to kakashi's plan.

age has nothing to do with the hype in question.

Greatest lie in the history of the manga.

You brought up Asuma dying so I brought up Kakashi being leader and people dying on his watch plus wasn't Asuma the leader of the team at the time of his death? Differences is Kakashi was a jounin, meaning he was seen to have a greater outlook and focus than a Chunin yet Shikamaru as a Chunin loses 1 person on his team and you bring that up when Kakashi lose both of his teammates and sensei. I wasn't talking about Sasuke retrieval team at that point, after they failed to get Sasuke Tsunade gave Shikamaru leadership roles for a lot of missions so he would gain more experiences as Kakashi Gaiden to part 1 and 2 Kakashi had gained over time so me bring up Kakashi Gaiden plays more than 1 role.

She told him she'll give him more missions to give him experiences after failing to get Sasuke in the anime and they didn't know what the sound 4 could do since they only used a barrier during the Chunin exam for the most part plus Shikamaru didn't know who Orochimaru might of sent, he guessed it might have been chunin's or jounin level ninjas and asked for Chunins and jounins to be on his team. Shikamaru outsmarted Her before they fought when they tricked her to get Sasuke (in the container) . Did it again after that, he also took control of her chakra monsters , then and .

Shikamaru have keen analyzing skills while Kakashi have the added help of the Sharingan to improve his already good analyzing skills yet Shikamaru has been shown to read Tayuya's movements from her finger placement. He wasn't trying to force Kakuza to use his abilities, that was a backup incase the first plan failed, that's why he told Kakashi if he gets a chance to use it and they had both Kakuza and Hidan trapped until Kakuza freed himself. Shikamaru figured out about the hearts before using Kakuza blood they seen what Kakuza can do thanks to Shikamaru's strategy and Kakashi's fighting skills; I will give Kakashi credit because he did use some analyzing skills himself but the overall analyze and plan was Shikamaru which earned him praised from Kakashi, Kakuza, and Sakura. Kakashi didn't even know how to fight them, he asked Shikamaru what they should do .

Shikamaru use multi-steps strategies in all his fights, Kakashi doesn't, he uses the Sharingan to see through most ninjutsu and counters with his own Attack or outsmart them with a clone while Shikamaru actually have welled detailed plans plus backup plans incase something happens since they wouldn't know everything the enemy could do. Who said he was hype to be better than Shikamaru? His skills and smarts were hyped in general and him being able to tapidly raise through the rank at such an early age shows he is smart since you need to be more than just brawns which is why Sasuke, Naruto, and Neji weren't made Chunins like Shikamaru who was purely brains.

Wasn't Kakashi crying because he thought he Obito died on his first mission as a Jounin? Then again with Rin's death? Anime showed how much their death impacted Kakashi and when Kakashi found out what Obito became he was depressed and mad at himself. Hinata rallied Naruto who rallied everyone, Sakura rallied everyone by using Naruto as an inspiration while Shikamaru made everyone believe in their own strength. No, Shikaku would be a big jerk to leave the role of strategist to someone who isn't the best, the father son moment was their convo of saying goodbye, this is a war, it's not the time and place to choose someone who can't best handle the planning.

It was Shikaku's role because he was the best at strategies, had Kakashi been better he would be where Shikaku was and Shikaku would be fighting. Shikamaru was given his role as lead strategist because he's the next best one after his father, simple as that. No plan nessacary? Naruto plan is what allowed him to hit her when Sasuke couldn't, what allowed him to trick her when he was fighting her allow, then when she was weakened he blitz her to harm her. 2 of 3 times were from planning and the other from her being low on chakra and trying to gather more.

That's his own power so why wouldn't he have it? Obito used his brain to even figure out what they should and could do and used them as part of his strategy just as Kakashi did with his Kaguya plan, he couldn't do his plan without Naruto, Sakura, or Sasuke but it was still his planning right? Same with Obito and Shikamaru have no special power but his brain yet he fights people stronger than him and usually comes out on top. Naruro as a genin fought Chunin and jounin level ninjas and beat them in part 1 due to his unique strategies. You called her useless yet she did just as much if not more then Kakashi, she helped saved Sasuke and helped beat Kaguya while Kakashi helped beat Kaguya. So Kaguya was only useful after getting Obito's power while Sakura has been useful with her own power? Ok then, even Obito said he had to go back to save Kakashi .

Age has everything to due with the hype in question, how do you think Kakashi skills in analyzing and forming plans improved from when he was in Kakashi Gaiden? By gaining battle experiences throughout the years while Shikamaru has shown experiences improve his strategic mind from his plans in part 1 to what they are in part 2. Oh is it? So Naruto, Sasuke, Lee, Shikamaru, Gaara, Temari, Sakura, Choji, or Shino didn't surpass the likes of Iruka, Kakashi, Kurenai, Gai, Asuma, Anko, ect....? They're in their 30-33 yrs right now and many of them surpassed their teachers in some way before the 12 yrs time skip.
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
Again his feats dont compare to Kakashi's.

Beating a bigger opponent, with bigger allies doesn't = better strategist or better feat.

If it was Shikamaru instead of Kakashi.. the fight would've been alot more smoother. Shikamaru has the aptitude of a stratigist Kakashi does not.
 
Top