Plothole: When did Hagoromo become a Juubi Jin?

[Legitimate]

No... I just wanted to show how earlier version told us story work until chapter 690.

and how the story of later version told us story work afterr 690+

As I said No matter how you look at it Ten tails host Hagoromo happened and it was at the same time and it happened after Ten tails was beaten up and sealed.

I'm not arguing whether he is a Juubi Jin or not, my point is there is a plothole, you can disregard Hagoromo creating the moon on his deathbed because that is based off a modified stone tablet. But you can't disregard Hagoromo, Kurama and Kaguya's memories and statements.

So yes, there is a plothole between earlier and latest version. The Gedo Mazo inside Hagoromo.

the problem is that hagoromo didnt create the moon o his bed and therefore didnt seal the gedo in the moon at that time because moon was created by both hamura and hagoromo when they fought the juubi....meaning the only logical conclusion is that the gedo was sealed in the moon when it was created...and not on sage`s deathbed...which means he was a jinchuuriki without the gedo mazou somehow...similar to how naruto is,in some way?

The problem is according to Yin-Kurama there is a Gedo Mazo inside Hagoromo that kept him alive after creating Kurama and the others.

 

[KCMNaruto]

I'm not arguing whether he is a Juubi Jin or not, my point is there is a plothole, you can disregard Hagoromo creating the moon on his deathbed because that is based off a modified stone tablet. But you can't disregard Hagoromo, Kurama and Kaguya's memories and statements.

So yes, there is a plothole between earlier and latest version. The Gedo Mazo inside Hagoromo.




The problem is according to Yin-Kurama there is a Gedo Mazo inside Hagoromo that kept him alive after creating Kurama and the others.

I aree with that as long as Hagoromo being Jinchurki is not plot hole and it is manga fact.

Other issues well, Kishi's retconn or weak memory is reason

 

[Legitimate]

I aree with that as long as Hagoromo being Jinchurki is not plot hole and it is manga fact.

Other issues well, Kishi's retconn or weak memory is reason

It's a plothole. There are 2 moons and 2 Gedo Mazo.

 

[ninjarasengan]

It's a plothole. There are 2 moons and 2 Gedo Mazo.

Didn't Madara at some point refer to the Moon as Juubi's sealing stone? and Nagato referred to the prison he made for 8tails Kurama as a moon?

Maybe when they fought Kaguya the moon wasn't sent into the sky...where did they even battle Kaguya anyway? They could've fought her in one of her dimensions and created a moon there and Hagoromo researched releasing It...leading to him needing to become Jinchuuriki.

or when they first sealed Juubi it could've been breaking free and they had to resort to sealing it in Hagoromo.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

It's a common misconseption that Hagoromo created the Bijuu on his deathbed. He actually extracted the bijuu when he was a juubi jin, and that killed him. Not old age at all.

 

[Legitimate]

It's a common misconseption that Hagoromo created the Bijuu on his deathbed. He actually extracted the bijuu when he was a juubi jin, and that killed him. Not old age at all.

Kurama disagrees.

2.) Inspired by his younger son, Hagoromo separated the Ten-Tails within his body and used his Creation of All Things ability to divide it into nine separated bodies, creating the tailed beasts and giving each a name.

As a result of extracting them(Tailed Beasts) all at once, Hagoromo was left weakened and incapacitated for several months, though the powerful life force of the Ten-Tails' husk(Gedo Mazo) kept him alive:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[ninjarasengan]

It's a common misconseption that Hagoromo created the Bijuu on his deathbed. He actually extracted the bijuu when he was a juubi jin, and that killed him. Not old age at all.

Wasn't it extracting the Gedou Mazo that killed him? I agree that extraction killed him though.