[Discussion] pre TS CP9 vs Zombie Oars

VongolaX

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
17,133
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The CP9 is very skilled in Soru, so I doubt Oars could hit them that easy. After Blueno opens the door Lucci, Kaku, and Jabra quickly go in there and make quick work of Moriah in CQC.
Also take this into count please...

None of their Soru beat 2nd gear luffy, right?

Blueno also wasn't fast enough to escape base Luffy's speed with Soru.

Moria played with base luffy, and his shadows were too quick.

So can Blueno really open doors before Moria's shadow box?
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
There is no debate to be made here.

Each of CP9 dueled with a Strawhat, and the Strawhats beat each and every one of them. So naturally Strawhats>CP9.

And all the Strawhats plus 1 more man still couldn't even manage to land a major blow on Oars, so how in the hell do people think CP9 together could beat him? It took a powered up Luffy to take him out.

So Oars wins. Mid diff, only because theyd be hard to catch.
You do realize that they landed several major blows on Oars? They shattered his entire spine and rendered one of his arms unusable.

This isn't a matter of power, but the effects of abilities. It took an elaborate scheme to get Zoro to cut Oars' arm and for them to damage his arm. With CP9, they can all(minus Kalifa), just Geppo/Soru behind Oars, and all launch a Rankyaku at the same time. Oars lacks the ability to feel, or at least, his ability to feel is at a very miniscule level, so he wouldn't even know that his arm was severed and cut. CP9 are assassins, so they specialize in stealth. The very method that allowed the Strawhats to defeat Oars was having multiple people distract him while someone stealthily did damage. In order to beat Oars, you have to systematically and methodically tear him apart, and CP9 have the powers and intelligence to do just that. One member, like Fukuro, can Geppou up in the air and launch an attack at Oars. As Oars brings his attention to Fukuro, Blueno teleports them behind Oars and three launch three large Rankyaku's at one arm, Blueno and the other at another arm, and Kalifa drains the strength from his legs and make them smooth, systematically destroying all of Oars' limbs.

CP9 have the abilities to defeat Oars because of their intelligence. What you failed to consider was that it wasn't CP9 vs Strawhats as a group, it was 1 vs 1 battles. If CP9 fought as a group, the results could have been much different.
 
Last edited:

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
Also take this into count please...

None of their Soru beat 2nd gear luffy, right?

Blueno also wasn't fast enough to escape base Luffy's speed with Soru.

Moria played with base luffy, and his shadows were too quick.

So can Blueno really open doors before Moria's shadow box?
Blueno lost track of Luffy after Luffy used Gear 2, in base form, Luffy was even with Blueno. I'm not even sure you've ever read One Piece.
 

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
There is no debate to be made here.

Each of CP9 dueled with a Strawhat, and the Strawhats beat each and every one of them. So naturally Strawhats>CP9.

And all the Strawhats plus 1 more man still couldn't even manage to land a major blow on Oars, so how in the hell do people think CP9 together could beat him? It took a powered up Luffy to take him out.

So Oars wins. Mid diff, only because theyd be hard to catch.
Using your logic; Pre-gears Luffy>Enel and Enel>Lucci so therefore Pre-gears Luffy>Lucci.
 

VongolaX

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
17,133
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Okay sure.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
Last four scans were all I needed, as soon as Luffy times out Lucci went for the kill.

All he did was kept his distance by sending long range attacks mid air away from Luffy.


There you go, every single page between Lucci being slammed through two buildings, while Zoro was slammed into the wall of one, and when they got back to the Lobby building. Not a single page of Lucci ¨staying down¨, he got up, dodged around Luffy's hits and mauled him, and launched back onto the deck. You were incorrect on that front, just accept it.
He kept his distance from luffy, he stayed away from him above the ship.

Didn't go after him until he deflated.

On the basis that we saw it happen?
Luffy chasing Moriah while Oars starts his battle with the Strawhats.[ ] Fight officially started here[ ]. The fight continues here[ ], which means Oars has been fighting without Moriah for at least three chapters. Zoro is all bloody, when the fight began, he was unscathed, so Oars has indeed been fighting them for a bit without Moriah there. In fact, all of the zombies are capable of fighting without Moriah present, Oars isn't different in that regard. Then you even see Moriah conversing with Kuma, while Oars is fighting the Strawhats.[ Moriah didn't show up until a while after Oars and the Strawhats started fighting.
Even if Moria is not inside of Oars at the beginning, the shadows that he was controlling were.

Moria was sending his shadows left and right, it still Moria inside controlling Oars via shadow.

Which makes it worse for the CP9


I know Oars with Moriah aiding is above Oars by himself, I never said this threat level without Moriah is comparable to his threat level without Moriah. That's why I asked the OP if Moriah is there, if I thought it was comparable, I wouldn't have asked.
Zombie oars is Luffy's shadow and Moria's controlling a dead unfrozen giant.

You immediately said I was wrong before confirming with Op.

Chopper and Usopp here were able to avoid a barrage of Oars' giant limbs, it'd be laughable to think CP9 can't do the same with Geppou and Soru.[ ]
Zoro and Sanji didn't, so that means chopper/usopp>>>Zoro/Sanji now?



You do realize that, like Zoro, Lucci was battling before he was smashed through a wall? Lucci and Gear 2 Luffy were going at it for quite a bit before Luffy brought out Gear 3, so the fact that Zoro was damaged before he was slammed into a wall isn't an excuse.
Zoro just finish fighting a Wano zombie swordsmen, what does slamming into a wall have to do with anything?

Lucci mostly fought luffy through the whole thing, while Zoro battled Oars right after getting the sword from the samurai a that beat Brook.

It's not like they're just gonna stand there and let Moriah do so. Moriah moves to take a shadow, and gets a Rankyaku to the face, or they move away using Soru and Geppou.
Zoro, Sanji, Robin, and rest didn't just stand there either...

Look at what happened there...

Soru that couldn't surpass gear two isn't going nowhere I can assure you that.
 

VongolaX

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
17,133
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Blueno lost track of Luffy after Luffy used Gear 2, in base form, Luffy was even with Blueno. I'm not even sure you've ever read One Piece.
Blueno used Soru to escape luffy, Luffy turned and tagged him into a pillar.

Literally a stupid reply, why would you ask if I read onepiece if I know the characters name?
 

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Also take this into count please...

None of their Soru beat 2nd gear luffy, right?

Blueno also wasn't fast enough to escape base Luffy's speed with Soru.

Moria played with base luffy, and his shadows were too quick.

So can Blueno really open doors before Moria's shadow box?
No, none of their Soru beats G2 Luffy, but it definitely beats Chopper and Ussop's speed, and those two could dodge Oars. Moriah has never displayed CoO, so he wouldn't know if Blueno is opening a door behind him until it's too late. You're just in denial at this point and refuse to admit that ABC logic doesn't always work.
 

VongolaX

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
17,133
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No, none of their Soru beats G2 Luffy, but it definitely beats Chopper and Ussop's speed, and those two could dodge Oars. Moriah has never displayed CoO, so he wouldn't know if Blueno is opening a door behind him until it's too late. You're just in denial at this point and refuse to admit that ABC logic doesn't always work.
You're using ABC logic :|

Just because chopper and Usopp got out of Orz range, doesn't mean the CP9 will.

Sanji and Zoro didn't dodge Orz, does that mean chopper and Ussop are better than Sanji and Zoro now?

I'm start to wonder who's in denial now, but since you made up your mind I'll be taking my leave.
 

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You're using ABC logic :|

Just because chopper and Usopp got out of Orz range, doesn't mean the CP9 will.

Sanji and Zoro didn't dodge Orz, does that mean chopper and Ussop are better than Sanji and Zoro now?

I'm start to wonder who's in denial now, but since you made up your mind I'll be taking my leave.
ABC logic doesn't always work, it does work sometimes. You just need to think the matchup through to determine if ABC logic works or not. It doesn't work for CP9 vs Oars, but it does for CP9's ability to dodge Oars since Chopper and Ussop dodged him.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
Last four scans were all I needed, as soon as Luffy times out Lucci went for the kill.

All he did was kept his distance by sending long range attacks mid air away from Luffy.




He kept his distance from luffy, he stayed away from him above the ship.

Didn't go after him until he deflated.
1. He didn't just stay mid-ranged from Luffy, immediately after Luffy came out and destroyed the battleship, Lucci got into close range and mauled him, Luffy still had Gear 3 activated when Rob Lucci was in close quarters mauling him. You said he remained on the ground until Luffy timed out, I proved you incorrect. Twice now on the same point. That's that. Scans show Lucci not only getting up as I said, but engaging in close combat with Luffy.

Even if Moria is not inside of Oars at the beginning, the shadows that he was controlling were.

Moria was sending his shadows left and right, it still Moria inside controlling Oars via shadow.

Which makes it worse for the CP9
Nope, look at the scan again. Luffy was chasing Moriah's shadow at the beginning of the fight, Moriah nor his shadow were there the entire time, just the end.

Zombie oars is Luffy's shadow and Moria's controlling a dead unfrozen giant.

You immediately said I was wrong before confirming with Op.
What....I said does Oars have Luffy's shadow(Dumb question he HAS to), and if Moriah is present. I said you were wrong in that Moriah HAS to be there, I didn't say he wasn't there, just that he doesn't have to be

Zoro and Sanji didn't, so that means chopper/usopp>>>Zoro/Sanji now?
You must be registered for see images


Zoro, Sanji, Robin, and rest didn't just stand there either...

Look at what happened there...

Soru that couldn't surpass gear two isn't going nowhere I can assure you that.
Gear 2 is Soru dude, and Rob Lucci kept up with Gear 2 Luffy quite well, he even managed to outmaneuver and land blows on Luffy while he was using Gear 2. Soru isn't slower than Gear 2, Blueno's Soru is. Rob Lucci's Soru was the same as Luffy's Soru.
Zoro just finish fighting a Wano zombie swordsmen, what does slamming into a wall have to do with anything?

Lucci mostly fought luffy through the whole thing, while Zoro battled Oars right after getting the sword from the samurai a that beat Brook.
And?? Zoro didn't get any significant injuries from battling Ryuma, so what does it matter? He still fell unconscious from a lesser attack that Lucci was able to fight through.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
You're using ABC logic :|

Just because chopper and Usopp got out of Orz range, doesn't mean the CP9 will.

Sanji and Zoro didn't dodge Orz, does that mean chopper and Ussop are better than Sanji and Zoro now?

I'm start to wonder who's in denial now, but since you made up your mind I'll be taking my leave.
If Usopp and Chopper were fast enough to move, then so are CP9.
 

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No I'm not, because that's a different situation.
I wasn't calling you anything or accusing you of doing something so I don't see how "no I'm not" applies to anything in my post. You were saying that since SHs>CP9, and since Oars gave the SHs including Brook a tough fight, then that would mean that Oars beats them. You didn't take their abilities into consideration. They all have good enough Soru, so they can easily dodge any of Oars attacks. Kalifa can use her powers to make Oars feet slippery so that he will be stuck on the ground. Then, Kaku uses his attack that cut the Tower of Law in half on Oars, since Oars cant dodge it then. Now that Oars was cut in two, Kalifa washes away his arms' strength, and then CP9 breaks every bone in his body since he cant do anything.

If Moriah is in Oars, Blueno just has to open a door to Oars stomach, where Moriah is located, and allow Lucci, Kaku, and Jabra to go through his doors. Once they get inside they low diff Moria since Zoans, especially Carnivorous Zoans, excel in close quarters combat. After they quicky kill Moriah, they just do what I said above.
 

ultraChalk

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 17, 2014
Messages
4,873
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
This isn't a matter of power, but the effects of abilities. It took an elaborate scheme to get Zoro to cut Oars' arm and for them to damage his arm.
1. It's just as a matter of size as it is abilities, they're to small and lack the firepower to do anything
With CP9, they can all(minus Kalifa), just Geppo/Soru behind Oars, and all launch a Rankyaku at the same time.
Oars can sense them and blitz dodge. He has the exact same battle experience and multiplied speed/power of Luffy
Oars lacks the ability to feel, or at least, his ability to feel is at a very miniscule level, so he wouldn't even know that his arm was severed and cut.
He can look and see.
CP9 are assassins, so they specialize in stealth. The very method that allowed the Strawhats to defeat Oars was having multiple people distract him while someone stealthily did damage. In order to beat Oars, you have to systematically and methodically tear him apart, and CP9 have the powers and intelligence to do just that.
Let me point out the issue with that: All of them move in unison as a team. Their individual attacks aren't enough to do efficient damage. So that means that they all have to slow down and move at the speed of the slowest one of them all, Fukurou. And I assure you Oars can react to him. So that they all strike at the same time, as a team.
One member, like Fukuro, can Geppou up in the air and launch an attack at Oars. As Oars brings his attention to Fukuro, Blueno teleports them behind Oars and three launch three large Rankyaku's at one arm, Blueno and the other at another arm, and Kalifa drains the strength from his legs and make them smooth, systematically destroying all of Oars' limbs.
Fails at the first step. Zoro's speed is near double Fufus speed and Oz cleanly dodged and countered an attack of his. Then he detects the others, and uses GGN Gattling. They're fast, but against something of that size and speed it will mean nothing.
CP9 have the abilities to defeat Oars because of their intelligence. What you failed to consider was that it wasn't CP9 vs Strawhats as a group, it was 1 vs 1 battles. If CP9 fought as a group, the results could have been much different.
Mind showing me some feats of intelligence? If they were so smart, they could've outsmarted each Strawhat to beat them. They don't rely on their brains nearly as much as you're giving them credit for. Their flaw as Zoro(?) pointed out is being too reliant on their techniques and generally underestimating their opponents own strength.

Also should have/would have/could have but /did not/.

You're right, it's a different situation because this situation requires not just brute strength, but effective abilities and intelligence, and CP9 has it in spades.
Lol I wasn't talking about this match I was responding to something else.

I wasn't calling you anything or accusing you of doing something so I don't see how "no I'm not" applies to anything in my post.
You were basically putting words in my mouth, saying that because this logic works for this type of match, it will work for everybody else. so I said no, I'm not saying that Pre-gears Luffy>Enel and Enel>Lucci so therefore Pre-gears Luffy>Lucci.
 
Last edited:
Top