The OP itself is flawed, in the first scan it was base Nardo and the next scans have rinnegan sasuke, had it been Riku Nardo then madara would've been cut just like that tree.You're not even answering the OP. All you're doing is being overly technical. If we want to get technical, Naruto couldn't even kill off Madara seeing as he was already nearly killed by Gai. At least it's part of the OP question. You are spouting nonsense that has nothing to do with the thread. Infact I can very well say without Sasukes plan, Naruto would be a lost duckling but that has nothing to do with thread and neither is what you're saying.
As for Madara not being effected by being cut in half that is purely an assumption. Narutos attack failed to cut him in half but somehow it's more effective than one that did. Makes absolute zero sense.
but if we go overall, then nardo did more that saske till now