What if Sasuke Never Found oUt the Truth About Itachi?

Mikasa Hagaromo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
235
Would he have returned to the village?

What path would he have walked following his vengeance?

I seem to recall him deciding to find and kill Madara when he realized Itachi had help.

Would his vengeance have stopped at Madara (if found him)?

Was Sasuke destined to walk the dark path even if Tobi didn't reveal the truth to him??
 

UCE

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
12,766
Reaction score
963
He would have return to the leaf and bang some chicks and naruto to
 

Chie

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
8,333
Reaction score
1,599
Would he have returned to the village?
What path would he have walked following his vengeance?
I seem to recall him deciding to find and kill Madara when he realized Itachi had help.
Would his vengeance have stopped at Madara (if found him)?
Was Sasuke destined to walk the dark path even if Tobi didn't reveal the truth to him??

No, he wasn't destined to walk the dark path at all. He would have returned to the village, had Obito not told him the truth. He would have went back to the village and trained his MS to get stronger. Itachi never wanted Sasuke to get involved with Obito, but he told him that story about Madara taking Izuna's eyes, because he knew that one day Sasuke's MS would go blind & he expected Sasuke to take his eyes. That's the only reason he told him about Madara. So, if not for Obito's influence...Sasuke would have gone back to train at Konoha and still have EMS regardless. He would also be thought of as a hero for killing an S-Rank missing-nin, which was confirmed in one of Sasuke's own flashbacks where Konoha shinobi were praising him for supposedly killing Itachi. Sasuke was actually viewed as a hero until his stunt at the kage summit, but now he's making up for it.

P.S., I like your sig but now it's time to get a new one. All the Uchiha this story centered around bar Itachi relied on Senju DNA. Especially Sasuke right now. Itachi is the only one who is 100% Uchiha and relied on his own power w/o taking anything.
 

Optimistic

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 16, 2012
Messages
15,747
Reaction score
1,562
Lel people can't read sasuke said that after he kills itachi madara(obito) is next on his list.
 

Xāvî1

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 13, 2011
Messages
23,665
Reaction score
1,415
he would have returned to the village, we wouldn't have either ems or ms..thats for sure
 

USSJ Future Trunks

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
18,518
Reaction score
1,067
he would go after obito like he said he would and get himself lolstomped by nagato.
obito doesnt have to tell him the TRUTH. just tell him some more people involved in the uchiha genocide. maybe the sand ninjas paid danzo off with resources to help him do it, or so obito will spin it.
that or he wanders the earth looking for another purpose and something worth fighting for, while being hunted by danzo who undoubtedly takes power.
he would have returned to the village
for no reason. you have no reason to be saying this given it would be completely out of character, illogical and stupid. sasuke surely knew he was now in the bingo book and a missing nin the moment he beat naruto. just because itachi thinks theyd welcome him back ike nothing happened doesnt mean sasuke thinks that.

Back to the village
wrong. he has no reason to go back given he swore to kill obito. killing itachi doesnt rid him of the bloodlust and need for exacting justice on all of his family's killers.
No, he wasn't destined to walk the dark path at all. He would have returned to the village, had Obito not told him the truth. He would have went back to the village and trained his MS to get stronger.
no he woudlt have. he has absolutely no god motherfukin reason to do so. and even if he wants to, he would know they could never accept him like nothing ever happened. he almost killed naruto twice. do you think they'd suddenly let it go?
if he comes back, he comes back to a village half against him and half indifferent with only 2 people left who actually even care.
sasuke was always about itachi and his love/hate for his brother. so if sasuke killed him he would then finish off itachis partner. then wander the earth looking for a new purpose in life. or outright kill himself.
why do peopel think he would go back when he already cut ties?
. Itachi never wanted Sasuke to get involved with Obito, but he told him that story about Madara taking Izuna's eyes, because he knew that one day Sasuke's MS would go blind & he expected Sasuke to take his eyes.
this is nonsense. itachi has no reason to think this unless he believes sauske will lose his goddamn mind and mutilate a corpse.
that said, sasuke was already evil so meeting obito changed nothing.
what sauske will do is hunt obito down with his own powers. not the eyes of the man who fukin killed everyone he loved. we know this because this is in character. you are demanding sasuke act illogical and do monstrously evil shit. like use itachis eyes and not care what said eyes have seen and done.
second, sasuke has absolutely no reason not to fight obito first. fuk konoha. he already cut ties with it.
. So, if not for Obito's influence...Sasuke would have gone back to train at Konoha
all obito did was give sasuke a target. sasuke was already steeped too far in darkness to expect or seek redemption. especially since he thinks he did nothing wrong. he abandoned konoha because he viewed them as weaklings playing ninja. oro was his only true sensei.
 

Chie

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
8,333
Reaction score
1,599
he would have returned to the village
for no reason. you have no reason to be saying this given it would be completely out of character, illogical and stupid. sasuke surely knew he was now in the bingo book and a missing nin the moment he beat naruto. just because itachi thinks theyd welcome him back ike nothing happened doesnt mean sasuke thinks that.


wrong. he has no reason to go back given he swore to kill obito. killing itachi doesnt rid him of the bloodlust and need for exacting justice on all of his family's killers.

no he woudlt have. he has absolutely no god motherfukin reason to do so. and even if he wants to, he would know they could never accept him like nothing ever happened. he almost killed naruto twice. do you think they'd suddenly let it go?
if he comes back, he comes back to a village half against him and half indifferent with only 2 people left who actually even care.
sasuke was always about itachi and his love/hate for his brother. so if sasuke killed him he would then finish off itachis partner. then wander the earth looking for a new purpose in life. or outright kill himself.
why do peopel think he would go back when he already cut ties?

this is nonsense. itachi has no reason to think this unless he believes sauske will lose his goddamn mind and mutilate a corpse.
that said, sasuke was already evil so meeting obito changed nothing.
what sauske will do is hunt obito down with his own powers. not the eyes of the man who fukin killed everyone he loved. we know this because this is in character. you are demanding sasuke act illogical and do monstrously evil shit. like use itachis eyes and not care what said eyes have seen and done.
second, sasuke has absolutely no reason not to fight obito first. fuk konoha. he already cut ties with it.

all obito did was give sasuke a target. sasuke was already steeped too far in darkness to expect or seek redemption. especially since he thinks he did nothing wrong. he abandoned konoha because he viewed them as weaklings playing ninja. oro was his only true sensei.

Sasuke is a goal-oriented individual and follows power. At some point, he would go blind and need Itachi's eyes. It makes sense that he would want to take them. He'll do anything for power, he's even stated this himself.

He would have to go back to Konoha. Orochimaru was gone. He created Hebi to help him locate Itachi and take him down, prior to meeting Obito, Hebi had lost its purpose to Sasuke after he defeated Itachi. Sasuke wanted to go after Obito later on and would need to get stronger. He would go back to the village, that's the only possible place he could go to get stronger and continue learning. If he had never learned the truth, he wouldn't feel any malice towards Konoha. He would want to go back to Team 7 and continue, he would have succeeded in his mind of honoring the Uchiha by eliminating Itachi.

The village would take him back. What harm did he even do at that point? He had been known to kill Deidara, Orochimaru, and Itachi...3 S-rank criminals. They would view him as a hero, and he would just say that he avenged his clan. Tsunade didn't even send the Anbu after him when he first left Konoha back in pt1, even though she was supposed to. Sasuke has gotten free passes due to Naruto throughout the series. Naruto/Sakura/Kakashi would be more than happy to have him back. Naruto has talked to villains and caused them to have a total change of heart, even though they had been commiting crimes for decades. Naruto can convince a skeptical village that now respects him to accept Sasuke back. The only crime he was known to commit at that point was literally just being a missing-nin, which wasn't a problem considering that he took down 3 Akatsuki members to more than enough make up for it.
 

Bad Touch Yakushi

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 26, 2011
Messages
19,411
Reaction score
1,553
Sasuke's innocence was still intact before the Itachi fight. He was forming bonds with his team and was stern but seemingly content being around them. I feel like if he never found out the truth about Itachi he would've never returned to the Leaf, they saw him as an outlaw and had already attacked Leaf Shinobi.

He had no real link on Madara and wasn't personally afflicted by him so I doubt he would've been bloodlusted to find him considering as killing Itachi would've filled his revenge fantasy. In my opinion he'd stay with Team Hebi (never becoming the Hawk) and pick up jobs as mercenaries before settling down and trying to rebuild the Uchiha clan away from the 5 nations. In fact I REALLY want to see this version of him.
 

Mikasa Hagaromo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
235
No, he wasn't destined to walk the dark path at all. He would have returned to the village, had Obito not told him the truth. He would have went back to the village and trained his MS to get stronger. Itachi never wanted Sasuke to get involved with Obito, but he told him that story about Madara taking Izuna's eyes, because he knew that one day Sasuke's MS would go blind & he expected Sasuke to take his eyes. That's the only reason he told him about Madara. So, if not for Obito's influence...Sasuke would have gone back to train at Konoha and still have EMS regardless. He would also be thought of as a hero for killing an S-Rank missing-nin, which was confirmed in one of Sasuke's own flashbacks where Konoha shinobi were praising him for supposedly killing Itachi. Sasuke was actually viewed as a hero until his stunt at the kage summit, but now he's making up for it.

P.S., I like your sig but now it's time to get a new one. All the Uchiha this story centered around bar Itachi relied on Senju DNA. Especially Sasuke right now. Itachi is the only one who is 100% Uchiha and relied on his own power w/o taking anything.

I wonder about the bold though. It seems to me that Sasuke would have sought revenge from one person after another as the story unfolded and he would've still eventually learned about Danzo's involvement. I think in the end, he still would've ended up wanting to destroy Konoha. His quest would've been never ending.

Regarding the sig- Nah. Still keeping it. Sasuke didn't seek out the hashi cells nor the rinnegan. It's being given to him while he's dead. Plus shit's ironic. I love irony.
 
Last edited:

Mikasa Hagaromo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
235
he would go after obito like he said he would and get himself lolstomped by nagato.
obito doesnt have to tell him the TRUTH. just tell him some more people involved in the uchiha genocide. maybe the sand ninjas paid danzo off with resources to help him do it, or so obito will spin it.
that or he wanders the earth looking for another purpose and something worth fighting for, while being hunted by danzo who undoubtedly takes power.
he would have returned to the village
for no reason. you have no reason to be saying this given it would be completely out of character, illogical and stupid. sasuke surely knew he was now in the bingo book and a missing nin the moment he beat naruto. just because itachi thinks theyd welcome him back ike nothing happened doesnt mean sasuke thinks that.


wrong. he has no reason to go back given he swore to kill obito. killing itachi doesnt rid him of the bloodlust and need for exacting justice on all of his family's killers.

no he woudlt have. he has absolutely no god motherfukin reason to do so. and even if he wants to, he would know they could never accept him like nothing ever happened. he almost killed naruto twice. do you think they'd suddenly let it go?
if he comes back, he comes back to a village half against him and half indifferent with only 2 people left who actually even care.
sasuke was always about itachi and his love/hate for his brother. so if sasuke killed him he would then finish off itachis partner. then wander the earth looking for a new purpose in life. or outright kill himself.
why do peopel think he would go back when he already cut ties?

this is nonsense. itachi has no reason to think this unless he believes sauske will lose his goddamn mind and mutilate a corpse.
that said, sasuke was already evil so meeting obito changed nothing.
what sauske will do is hunt obito down with his own powers. not the eyes of the man who fukin killed everyone he loved. we know this because this is in character. you are demanding sasuke act illogical and do monstrously evil shit. like use itachis eyes and not care what said eyes have seen and done.
second, sasuke has absolutely no reason not to fight obito first. fuk konoha. he already cut ties with it.

all obito did was give sasuke a target. sasuke was already steeped too far in darkness to expect or seek redemption. especially since he thinks he did nothing wrong. he abandoned konoha because he viewed them as weaklings playing ninja. oro was his only true sensei.


Yes! 98% of what this guy said^^
 

USSJ Future Trunks

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
18,518
Reaction score
1,067
Sasuke is a goal-oriented individual and follows power.
no he follows revenge. hes too cocky to believe he doesnt already have the power to kill off obito. in his mind hes already taken down who he thought to be the strongest guy out there
Sasuke's innocence was still intact before the Itachi fight. He was forming bonds with his team and was stern but seemingly content being around them.
sasuke had become a corrupt madman psychopath as soon as he left thanks to CS influence and itahci influence.
he betrayed his own people by disowning them as weak "playing ninjas", tried to kill naruto, laughed like a nutjob, joined a known mass murderer, tried to kill and wipe out his entire old team without batting an eye, commented y many people to no longer be the person he once was.
and a brief regression in the bee fight doesnt change that. if anything it proves he would have stayed with hebi and looked for suigetsus swords, not gone to konoha. in his mind they are the only people left he cares about and who care for him.
At some point, he would go blind and need Itachi's eyes. It makes sense that he would want to take them. He'll do anything for power, he's even stated this himself.
theres some things he wont do. and one of them is taking the eyes of the guy who murdered his family for the giggles. bit strange for someone to do that, no matter how far theyve fallen. sasuke only ended up doing it because he had gotten so in the esctacy of killing danzo that he wanted to crush konoha with full power.
having a target gave him a reason to be even more evil.
without the elders as targets, sasuke would still have no reason to go back to a place he disowned and betrayed. he pretty much disowned team 7 to their faces and tried to murder them so yeah why woud he think they'd want him back after that.
Sasuke wanted to go after Obito later on and would need to get stronger. He would go back to the village, that's the only possible place he could go to get stronger and continue learning.
again itachis maniulation was such that he convinced sasuke he hadnt been doing or learning ANYTHING while there. the gap between sauske and itachi hadnt changed, whic meant that he needed to leave and seek power elsewhere. going back contradicts that. if konoha wasnt making him obito level before, how can they now.

your not getting into sasukes mindset here. your just letting itachi's plans confuse you. understand that itachis plan was stupid and never was gonna happen.
If he had never learned the truth, he wouldn't feel any malice towards Konoha.
DOESNT MEAN HE LIKES THEM EITHER. he tried to kill his old team plus two new guys. he had lost his mind. if he went back, konoha would definitely look like pussified fools to him. not like the ruthless man he had become.
he disowned them as weaklings and wouldnt go back even if he had the option. not while obito lived anyway.
if he did become a good guy and settle down, it would probably be as otogakures new boss. 3 years there compared to 5-6 years in konoah without his family? yeah im pretty sure he thinks of otogakure as far more of a home. hes only trying to go back now because he thinks he needs to change them from their corrupt old ways.
He would want to go back to Team 7 and continue, he would have succeeded in his mind of honoring the Uchiha by eliminating Itachi
this was personal revenge. not some heroic mission of justice. he had already steeped himself in evil too much to suddenly be like "zomg my quest is over, now im nice again". hatred doesnt work like that. it continues. it festers. obito being alive would torment him into more madness. why would he go back to people he tried to kill mere weeks earlier?
The village would take him back. What harm did he even do at that point? He had been known to kill Deidara, Orochimaru, and Itachi...3 S-rank criminals.
betray them. as far as the ninja worlds concerned, being a missing nin is a huge dishonor on not just you but your former home. if he tells them the truth, then oro is off the table, and they will be able to see deidara simply kiled himself.
and what, they are gonna give him a medal for ridding them of itachi? theyd only be disappointed two criminals didnt take each other out. sai voiced what everyone really thought of him, that he was just a power hungry douchebag.
deidara died becase he got in sasukes way, not some noble defence of goodness and justice.
They would view him as a hero, and he would just say that he avenged his clan.
so itachi woudl be immediately accepted right back if he killed pain? it doesnt work like that. we have yet to see how a former vllain is treated by the populace. but we have seen that they were all downright afraid and abusive of gaara, pre evil and post turn to evil.
we know they feared even the rival nations. hiruzen was seen saying "wow the sand are dangerous". so how do you think tsnade would react to sasuke? she and the elders would have to convince naruto sasuke isnt gonna be instantly trusted because he says so. this isnt a nagato situation where he truly wanted peace. sasuke has been a selfish douche for 3 years and the peopel who value trust and loyalty above all else is gonna swallow their pride around him? fuk no they wont. no matter what naruto says.
Tsunade didn't even send the Anbu after him when he first left Konoha back in pt1, even though she was supposed to. S
she had no one capable of invading oro's hideout, and she didnt send adult jounins after sasuke because she simply couldnt. oros invasion left them devastated manpower wise. probs why kiba and tenten got promoted to chunin.
Naruto/Sakura/Kakashi would be more than happy to have him back.
doesnt mean he thinks that
The only crime he was known to commit at that point was literally just being a missing-nin, which wasn't a problem
and trying to kill his friends. and joining third's killer. and forsaking any sense of loyalty to his home. and going on a selfish power hungry quest
considering that he took down 3 Akatsuki members to more than enough make up for it.
nothing would "make up for it". theyd only be disappointed sasuke didnt die too.
 
Top