[VS] Gai VS 5 kage

Who wins?

  • Gai

    Votes: 20 55.6%
  • 5 Kage

    Votes: 10 27.8%
  • Draw

    Votes: 6 16.7%

  • Total voters
    36

Inert Brian

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 13, 2013
Messages
2,338
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
5 Kage win.

Tsunade and the other 5 kage can stay safe inside Katsuyu.

If Gai can defeat them then it automatically ends in a tie. Because he dies shortly after.
 

WreckRolled

Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
492
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Fukasaku: .
wow ok i admit i was wrong, but still

sm jirayia died from this

tsunade is running around with these

sm can't give that much durability

I'm talking about Jinchuuriki durability. 50% KN4 laughed at Kusanagi swords to the gut. 50% KN6 physically resisted Shinra Tensei. 50% KN8 resisted Chibaku Tensei. Add in another 8 tailed beasts, and you think Madara won't be far more durable?
my point is naruto was that tough in tailbed beast form, madara is in his normal form


Madara: " "
-_- what was i reading so far...

he was still bleeding, hashi's auto healing appears to be slower than byakugo and since madara is still alive this turns into an argument in tsunade's favor


He literally has Hashirama fused onto his chest, and has displayed the ability to actively use it. He has used Hashirama's Wood Dragon without Sage Mode, massive AOE Mokutons like the pollen technique. Considering Spiral Zetsu is using a lesser version of the Buddha, Madara can easily do the same, as he not only has "more Hashirama" genes in him, but is also in Sage Mode.


What ABC logic? Madara's durability is far above Tsunade's; it isn't even debatable.
Regeneration is not durability. Durability is the ability to take attacks without damage, much like Kakuzu's Doton Domu or Raikage's iron skin. Tsunade takes damage just like everybody else, only she heals from it before dying from blood loss. If dealt with more damage than she can heal from, she dies before regenerating. Tsunade has not healed from damage anywhere near what Gai has shown to output.
when i say durability i generally refer to how much damage someone can receive, never the less gai has not shown any output damage that tsunade can't heal since hirudoar/pecock/elephoot/kicks have never put anyone's body in such a miserable state for byakugo not to heal it

And Part I Naruto's Rasengan is far, far inferior to anything gated Gai can do, let alone 8th gate.
gai's attacks don't hit the insides, kabuto did not have byakugo


If the fire generated by Asa Kujaku was potent enough to vaporize water, it's natural enemy, it will do far worse to a human (not to mention a human's body is primarily composed of water). The version he used against the Shoten clone was nowhere near the level of the one he used against the thousand sharks.
it was clearly the same thing, he was in 5 gates in both cases,nothing suggests that the water sharks evaporated, the fodder's body was in one piece and not evaporated so it is really ridiculous to think tsunade would evaporate


Gai: "There are too many . . . I have no choice."

The ones he hit were evaporated. Several escaped, not due to durability but due to their sheer quantity and Gai being unable to hit all of them.
the ones he hit turned back into normal water and dispersed

Not faster than any gated move can deal damage.
i don't know how you can say that considering how fast byakugo constantly heals any internal and external wounds and how gai never did any damage to his victims that would not be healed

I don't think you understand what ABC logic is. I am comparing a stronger version of the same character.

Furthermore, even if I wasn't, ABC logic is okay when we are dealing with multiple tier gaps. Transitive logic is only an issue when there are two opponents of similar level, and one can manage to win thanks to a favorable match up (like Deidara vs Sasuke).

If we're talking about the Naruto-verse God (which is essentially what Juubi Madara is at the moment) vs any lesser character, transitive logic is perfectly fine, as the gap is so overwhelming that even a favorable match up won't be saving them.
ABC logic is allways wrong, but A1-A2-A3 logic is not wrong, if you compare an exact atribute it's fine, but if you compare different things it's not fine


Madara does not have time to do jack, you mean. Considering he is too busy getting blitzed before being able to mount proper offense.





he had all the chances in the world and was reacting to gai
he had many oportunities to stop gai's movement like he did to sasuke, he could have use ST to block his elephoot, rinbo was an option, giant poisoned forest, wood clones i don't know something, he was just using his black orbs defence and was still winning if not for gai's little friends

Gai is giving current Madara a run for his money, who is literally nine tailed beasts and a Sage Mode Hashirama stronger than his self.
madara is not attacking, don't you think his dancing moves against the kages were much more...existent ?

Those four helped him land one hit. He had already landed four on him without their help.

Gai already saved Kakashi from the black orbs several chapters ago using lesser gates; he has the movement speed to dodge them. All his allies did was make it more convenient for him.
he was obviosuly not going to dodge them and we don't know what 6 of them would have done


What you need to understand is Madara's durability is tiers above Tsunade's. Saying "because GodMode Madara survived, so can Tsunade" shows a lack of understanding as to what level of durability current Madara possesses. He has Sage Mode durability as well as Jinchuuriki durability. Tsunade has normal person durability, just like anyone else; the only pro is that she can regenerate from it. If she is dealt with more damage than she can heal from, which gated Gai's attacks can easily invoke, then she dies.
how can you say that when tsunade tanked everything so far in byakugo ?
considering how spectacular his lesser gates moves are and how little they do to human bodies,the best thing he can do is crush her so i have every reason to believe she tanks since she can heal any damage including internal as i have shown



here
 

Strict

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 20, 2012
Messages
4,166
Kin
6💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
...one blow had enough momentum to penetrate the ground with Madara ahead and create a huge hole with a depth of 100 meters. And it was only Madara's horn that cracked. Are you high to think a human could survive this as well, even with minor damage, as you called Madara's form normal? A human's body can't take such a strain, how can't you understand??
 

WreckRolled

Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
492
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
...one blow had enough momentum to penetrate the ground with Madara ahead and create a huge hole with a depth of 100 meters. And it was only Madara's horn that cracked. Are you high to think a human could survive this as well, even with minor damage, as you called Madara's form normal? A human's body can't take such a strain, how can't you understand??
i agree, tsunade would get utterly crashed and she would regenerate
 

Black Wolf

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jun 27, 2013
Messages
1,060
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You very clearly do not understand the difference between durability and regenerative capabilities.

3rd Raikage, Kimimaro (although he also has regeneration in addition to durability), Kakuzu's Doton Domu - that is durability. They are impervious to most forms of damage. You try to cut them with a sword, they will not be damaged. You try to punch them, they will not be damaged. You try to squeeze them with Gaara's sand burial, they simply stroll out of it undamaged. They have "tougher skin," so to speak. Tsunade does not have tougher skin. You cut her with a sword, she gets cut and bleeds. You punch her, she will get bruised. You squeeze her with Gaara's sand, she will pop.

What Tsunade has is regenerative capabilities. You stab her with a sword, she will bleed . . . and then close the wound before she loses more blood. You punch her in the face, she will get bruised . . . and then heal the damaged tissue. She is not immune to damage - she simply heals it before it can become detrimental to her.

. He did not immediately die. You know why he ended up dying, though? Because he didn't have regeneration. If he had Byakugo, he would not have died in that scenario. Same idea with Tsunade; she would get pierced by those swords just as Zabuza did. The swords aren't going to bounce off her shoulder / neck / torso. They will impale her, and if she takes them out on time, she can heal the damage. She isn't immune to the damage, though - she simply heals it off.

To answer your question, Ramen Guy will suffer similar damage to Tsunade; he will be covered in lacerations from head to toe. However, it is quite likely he will die from blood loss, or at the very least require immediate hospitalization to survive. Tsunade only faired better thanks to regeneration, not because she is durable.

wow ok i admit i was wrong, but still

sm jirayia died from this
And you are wrong once again. Jiraiya was not in Sage Mode. . Shima had disconnected from his shoulder, and he needed her to maintain the mode.

Furthermore, Jiraiya has an imperfect Sage Mode - his face literally turns into a frog. Hashirama has a perfect Sage Mode, as did Naruto. You cannot pass over perfect Sage feats to the likes of Jiraiya.


tsunade is running around with these
Again, having swords in your stomach does not spell immediate death. Zabuza had half a dozen swords thrust in his torso, and he did not immediately die. You can survive having swords thrust through you for several minutes. Neji had a bunch of branches skewer his torso, and did not immediately die either.

If Neji and Zabuza had Byakugo, they would have survived too. Look at my previous post above; Byakugo is regeneration, not durability.

sm can't give that much durability
I'm not saying Sage Mode durability alone is the deciding factor. I'm saying that Sage Mode durability in addition to being the host of the freakin' ten tailed beast is the deciding factor.

50% Kyuubi tanked Futon Rasenshuriken, god knows how many Odama Rasengans, and was still ready to fight Naruto. Hachibi tanked his own Bijuudama. Throw in another seven tailed beasts, and you're telling me you think Madara's durability is anywhere near Tsunade's?

Hell, Tsunade . The mere fact that the 50% Kyuubi took one of those like a champ, and Madara has that same 50% Kyuubi inside of him, alongside another 8 beasts, should tell you his durability is on another level.

my point is naruto was that tough in tailbed beast form, madara is in his normal form
Madara is in his Juubi Jinchuuriki form. His hair changing to white, and him having a chakra robe and growing a horn is not "normal form."

-_- what was i reading so far...

he was still bleeding, hashi's auto healing appears to be slower than byakugo and since madara is still alive this turns into an argument in tsunade's favor
On the , those wounds are gone (top right panel).


when i say durability i generally refer to how much damage someone can receive
Then you clearly don't know what durability is. Durability =/= regeneration.

For current Madara to be forced to resort to regeneration, the attack would have to first bypass his immense durability, which is nigh impossible. The fact that Gai is having him cough up blood goes to show just how powerful the punches are.

gai's attacks don't hit the insides, kabuto did not have byakugo
Pretty sure they cause immense internal trauma if they cause the target to cough blood.

it was clearly the same thing, he was in 5 gates in both cases,nothing suggests that the water sharks evaporated, the fodder's body was in one piece and not evaporated so it is really ridiculous to think tsunade would evaporate
There were thousands of feeding sharks on one page, and then the next page they are suddenly no longer there (barring a few that managed to escape). If you're going to deny clear cut feats, like Gai vaporizing the shark wave, then there is no point of this debate.


ABC logic is allways wrong, but A1-A2-A3 logic is not wrong, if you compare an exact atribute it's fine, but if you compare different things it's not fine
No, it's not.

Transitive logic has always been a problem in Naruto because of matchups and elemental attacks. It is not fair to say that anyone Deidara can beat Hebi Sasuke can beat by default. Why? Because they are characters of similar level, and Deidara only lost due to a match up disadvantage.

When we are talking about something like the Naruto-verse's equivalent of a God versus anything else, ABC logic is fine. The sheer gap is far too immense to be overshadowed or affected by matchups.

And as I already told you, I'm comparing Edo Madara to Juubi Jinchuuriki Madara. It is the same exact character, and the gap is enormous.

he had all the chances in the world and was reacting to gai
He reacted to one blow, only to be blitzed from behind by the second.

he had many oportunities to stop gai's movement like he did to sasuke
Provide evidence that something moving as quickly and as powerfully as 8th gated Gai can be stopped by what he used on Sasuke.

he could have use ST to block his elephoot
He used something even better to block the Evening Elephant; the black element.

rinbo was an option, giant poisoned forest, wood clones i don't know something
Provide evidence that Madara can hit a target moving as fast as 8th gated Gai with Limbo. Provide evidence that the forest will be effective against someone moving as fast as Gai.

"I don't know, something" just shows how desperate you are, reaching for some sort of contrived excuse that Madara was playing around.

he was just using his black orbs defence and was still winning if not for gai's little friends
Gai's team-mates only helped Gai land one punch. Gai has already proven he can dodge the black orbs using lower gates back several chapters ago, where he not only dodged them but got Kakashi out of harm's way as well.

madara is not attacking, don't you think his dancing moves against the kages were much more...existent ?
It is kind of hard to attack when you are being pinballed in all directions like a rag doll. The Kage's never pressured anywhere near that level, thus why he was able to respond accordingly with flashy techniques.

he was obviosuly not going to dodge them and we don't know what 6 of them would have done
He saved Kakashi from a chakra orb using 4 gates when he first arrived. He definitely has the speed to avoid them. His team mate's presence just made it more convenient / easier for him to land his blows.

how can you say that when tsunade tanked everything so far in byakugo ?
She has never tanked anything. All the attacks damaged her. What she did is regenerate from them before blood loss became an issue.

She has never been hit with an attack that is instantly lethal. An attack that instantly kills her would prevent her from regenerating, which she has to be alive to accomplish. Swords to the stomach are eventually lethal if medical attention is not sought out. However, they are not immediately lethal, otherwise Zabuza and Neji would not have been able to stay alive for several minutes after having their organs skewered.
 
Last edited:

m33km00k

Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
179
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Gai wankers are the ones that shouldn't be taken seriously. Just because he seemingly beat up the Madara who fodderized the Gokage doesn't mean he could do the same thing against said team. ABC logic on this one is a sure fail.
 

Powermill

Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
226
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I believe Guy could defeat the lot of em after opening all the gates.

The question seems to be whether that's considered a win or not.

I'm voting guy because I feel that killing the 5 kage warrants a win.
 

m33km00k

Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
179
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ay is only slightly slower compared to Minato with FTG. With Onoki's jutsu, he could even go faster. How can Gai hope to tag them? The current chapter may seem like Gai is beating the crap out of Madara but whose to say that the Uchiha isn't letting him do it on purpose? Just look at his face at the very end, he's even mocking Gai. Unless it is clearly stated that Gai's 8th gate speed = or > Ay's, the raikage should still be treated as the faster one.
 

paratise

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 28, 2013
Messages
16,197
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
^^^Fascinating.

Kyuubi's jinchuuriku with average base speed was keeping up with A, Juubi's jinchuuriku with insane base speed and Sage mode was getting tossed around by 8th gate Gai.

Not that hard to figure the speed state Gai is in.
 

Inert Brian

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 13, 2013
Messages
2,338
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You guys do realize Gai going 8 gates and dying is a draw right?

Going 8 gates means he's forced to use it because his enemies are that strong. Otherwise he could use 7 and barely live.

That's like saying Sasuke didn't kill Deidara because he suicided, Deidara was forced to do it.
 

Rike Senju

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 20, 2012
Messages
3,095
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You guys do realize Gai going 8 gates and dying is a draw right?

Going 8 gates means he's forced to use it because his enemies are that strong. Otherwise he could use 7 and barely live.

That's like saying Sasuke didn't kill Deidara because he suicided, Deidara was forced to do it.
It's different. Deidara explodes he dies about the same time or before kage die. In the VS section the moment the opponent dies the match ends. Once Gai kills the last kage he wins.
 

RicardoA

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 8, 2013
Messages
4,436
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It's different. Deidara explodes he dies about the same time or before kage die. In the VS section the moment the opponent dies the match ends. Once Gai kills the last kage he wins.
Still, he would've died because of something that happended during the battle.
It shouldn't matter if he died instantly or 1 hour later.
If he killed his opponent and died as a consequence of that same battle, its a stalemate.
 

WreckRolled

Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
492
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You very clearly do not understand the difference between durability and regenerative capabilities.

3rd Raikage, Kimimaro (although he also has regeneration in addition to durability), Kakuzu's Doton Domu - that is durability. They are impervious to most forms of damage. You try to cut them with a sword, they will not be damaged. You try to punch them, they will not be damaged. You try to squeeze them with Gaara's sand burial, they simply stroll out of it undamaged. They have "tougher skin," so to speak. Tsunade does not have tougher skin. You cut her with a sword, she gets cut and bleeds. You punch her, she will get bruised. You squeeze her with Gaara's sand, she will pop.

What Tsunade has is regenerative capabilities. You stab her with a sword, she will bleed . . . and then close the wound before she loses more blood. You punch her in the face, she will get bruised . . . and then heal the damaged tissue. She is not immune to damage - she simply heals it before it can become detrimental to her.

. He did not immediately die. You know why he ended up dying, though? Because he didn't have regeneration. If he had Byakugo, he would not have died in that scenario. Same idea with Tsunade; she would get pierced by those swords just as Zabuza did. The swords aren't going to bounce off her shoulder / neck / torso. They will impale her, and if she takes them out on time, she can heal the damage. She isn't immune to the damage, though - she simply heals it off.

To answer your question, Ramen Guy will suffer similar damage to Tsunade; he will be covered in lacerations from head to toe. However, it is quite likely he will die from blood loss, or at the very least require immediate hospitalization to survive. Tsunade only faired better thanks to regeneration, not because she is durable.
I know the difference, tsunade heals while taking damage and duplicates her cells, including hemoglobine

read what she says



And you are wrong once again. Jiraiya was not in Sage Mode. . Shima had disconnected from his shoulder, and he needed her to maintain the mode.

Furthermore, Jiraiya has an imperfect Sage Mode - his face literally turns into a frog. Hashirama has a perfect Sage Mode, as did Naruto. You cannot pass over perfect Sage feats to the likes of Jiraiya.
ok, still tsunade can survive things that would kill a sm user


Again, having swords in your stomach does not spell immediate death. Zabuza had half a dozen swords thrust in his torso, and he did not immediately die. You can survive having swords thrust through you for several minutes. Neji had a bunch of branches skewer his torso, and did not immediately die either.

If Neji and Zabuza had Byakugo, they would have survived too. Look at my previous post above; Byakugo is regeneration, not durability.



I'm not saying Sage Mode durability alone is the deciding factor. I'm saying that Sage Mode durability in addition to being the host of the freakin' ten tailed beast is the deciding factor.

50% Kyuubi tanked Futon Rasenshuriken, god knows how many Odama Rasengans, and was still ready to fight Naruto. Hachibi tanked his own Bijuudama. Throw in another seven tailed beasts, and you're telling me you think Madara's durability is anywhere near Tsunade's?

Hell, Tsunade . The mere fact that the 50% Kyuubi took one of those like a champ, and Madara has that same 50% Kyuubi inside of him, alongside another 8 beasts, should tell you his durability is on another level.
these were tailed beasts, madara is not a tailed beast

Madara is in his Juubi Jinchuuriki form. His hair changing to white, and him having a chakra robe and growing a horn is not "normal form."
yes he is in juuby jincuriki form or rukudou form or whatever, he is not in tailed beast form and he does not use the bijuu chakra form, he is not engulfed by dark red chakra, he does not have 10 chakra tails and he is not a giant juuubi at the moment so it's not the same thing
rasenshuriken is a special kind of attack, gai has just air flaming cannons

On the , those wounds are gone (top right panel).
i know, i am just showing that hashirama regen is slower than byakugo



Then you clearly don't know what durability is. Durability =/= regeneration.

For current Madara to be forced to resort to regeneration, the attack would have to first bypass his immense durability, which is nigh impossible. The fact that Gai is having him cough up blood goes to show just how powerful the punches are.
it also goes to show how ineffective evening elephant was


Pretty sure they cause immense internal trauma if they cause the target to cough blood.
trunade can heal all internal trauma, in NV characters spit blood for dinner



There were thousands of feeding sharks on one page, and then the next page they are suddenly no longer there (barring a few that managed to escape). If you're going to deny clear cut feats, like Gai vaporizing the shark wave, then there is no point of this debate.
yeah clear cut feats, since it has been clearly shown and water can't just fall back into the sea right ? also clearly the fodder being just burnt up a bit from a full peacock to the face is not contradicting your clear cut never shown feats at all right ?



No, it's not.

Transitive logic has always been a problem in Naruto because of matchups and elemental attacks. It is not fair to say that anyone Deidara can beat Hebi Sasuke can beat by default. Why? Because they are characters of similar level, and Deidara only lost due to a match up disadvantage.

When we are talking about something like the Naruto-verse's equivalent of a God versus anything else, ABC logic is fine. The sheer gap is far too immense to be overshadowed or affected by matchups.

And as I already told you, I'm comparing Edo Madara to Juubi Jinchuuriki Madara. It is the same exact character, and the gap is enormous.
yes it is, if i say that apple A weights more than apple B, and apple C weights more than apple A than i can also say that apple C weights more than apple B and it would be completely right, you are comparing exact atributes

but comparing edo madara to rikudou madara is wrong because they do not have the same abilities, rikudou madara does not have ps, is not immortal and also doesn't do anything other than playing with his black orbs

He reacted to one blow, only to be blitzed from behind by the second.
he was stuck in that position because of evening elephant


Provide evidence that something moving as quickly and as powerfully as 8th gated Gai can be stopped by what he used on Sasuke.

all the time in the world to stop gai's movement and destroy him


He used something even better to block the Evening Elephant; the black element.


perfect time for shinra tensei

Provide evidence that Madara can hit a target moving as fast as 8th gated Gai with Limbo. Provide evidence that the forest will be effective against someone moving as fast as Gai.
no need for explenation
blocked with orbs before he even got attacked, could have used limbo
limbo to da face
idem
all the time in the world but is worried that his dancing pal could be tired


"I don't know, something" just shows how desperate you are, reaching for some sort of contrived excuse that Madara was playing around.
it makes total sense


Gai's team-mates only helped Gai land one punch. Gai has already proven he can dodge the black orbs using lower gates back several chapters ago, where he not only dodged them but got Kakashi out of harm's way as well.
he was in mid air


he was not going to dodge them
It is kind of hard to attack when you are being pinballed in all directions like a rag doll. The Kage's never pressured anywhere near that level, thus why he was able to respond accordingly with flashy techniques.
he had chances to use flashy moves and also had chances to use wood clone but i guess he does not fear gai as much as the 5 kages


He saved Kakashi from a chakra orb using 4 gates when he first arrived. He definitely has the speed to avoid them. His team mate's presence just made it more convenient / easier for him to land his blows.
he was in mid air


She has never tanked anything. All the attacks damaged her. What she did is regenerate from them before blood loss became an issue.


She has never been hit with an attack that is instantly lethal. An attack that instantly kills her would prevent her from regenerating, which she has to be alive to accomplish. Swords to the stomach are eventually lethal if medical attention is not sought out. However, they are not immediately lethal, otherwise Zabuza and Neji would not have been able to stay alive for several minutes after having their organs skewered.
she heals while being damaged and does not stop until byakugo runs out, how is she going to die from an attack if she is completely healed one second later ?

enviromental damage and damage done to people are different in nv so you can't judge based on the damage a real human would receive compared to the environment


tsunade said that in byakugo she can never die in battle, the only thing that may kill her is vertical evening elephant like the first one gai used against madara, if her regeneration is slower than the damage caused by the pressure enough for her to get completely turned into tomato sauce she may not regenerate, but we will never know, byakugo may regenerate all her body even than

however this is 5 v1
gai may not attack tsunade first


gai can't move while using hirudora vertically
he is vulnerable to raikage blitz/dust release every time he does that
raikage/gaara could most likely survive horizontal hirudora
with intel kages can just hide in katsuyu
v2 raikage can blitz gai for sure if he is not watching
kages win
 
Last edited:
Top