Yata doesn't block everything.

HadouKage

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
4,178
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Nah, Wolfus dumb comparisons make no sense but since you agree It makes sense.... Anyways.. Why would Itachi use yata knowing it would only save him and leave naruto and bee captured? Itachi being Top 3 more analytical in the series knew that his long range weapon would be required to make sure EVERYONE Survived
It was shown that Sussano can be activated very quickly as displayed with Itachi. Itachi has shown to be nimble, he could have easily advanced toward CT on the debris and used Yata, but alas, he did not
 

Helikido

Active member
Regular
Joined
Apr 3, 2012
Messages
1,825
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It was shown that Sussano can be activated very quickly as displayed with Itachi. Itachi has shown to be nimble, he could have easily advanced toward CT on the debris and used Yata, but alas, he did not
It's called plot. HE was talking with naruto and bee, thus didn't have time to stop it.
 

Wolfus

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
4,855
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
And I'm just gonna say this again since you intend to carry on with this flawed logic.

THERE IS NO NEED FOR IT TO HAVE A MIND OF ITS OWN TO TELL WHETHER SOMETHING IS AN ATTACK OR NOT.

Don't even know why anyone would delude themselves into believing what you are saying makes sense.

Yata Mirror was already stated to block attacks and blocking attacks is all it does. If its not an attack it doesn't get blocked as that goes against the definition given to us by the Databook. Its as simple as that. Yata isn't going to block all light out because all light isn't an attack, it cannot get anymore simple than this.

Throwing a ball is a form of attack whether or not it is intended to be an attack or not, so that example obviously doesn't hold. Not to mention you are referring to light and sound here.

-Can a thrown ball hurt and hit someone? Yes.

-Can Sound or Light on its own? No.

And please don't compare Yata Mirror to a regular shield again, unless your comparison includes some kind of similar item don't even bother making another comparison.

Repeating the same nonsensical BS isn't a rebuttal, sorry pal.




Nothing but a baseless assumption. Its not shown or hinted that he deactivated anything.




Sasuke passed through it and him because ITACHI ALLOWED IT.

lol, where do you think the shield and sword come from? They are formed using Itachi's chakra. Hence the sword and the shield having the same exact look as Itachi's Susanoo. Susanoo also acts as a shield for the user's attacks, why doesn't Susanoo block out light, air, and sound on its own then? Huh? By your terrible logic it should.

You must be registered for see images


Is Totsuka the same as Yata Mirror? No, so there goes your flawed comparison. Its already been shown that Susanoo users can allow people to enter their Susanoo.
The only flawed logic I see here is yours.
A shield cant tell if something is an atack or not. A shield should block anything that goes in it's direction, being an atack or not. If you find a shield as big as you and cover you with it, one won't be able to friendly touch you, one won't be able to see you(light isn't getting through the shield)
This is a fact. No shield will tell if it's an atack or not, it will just block everything in it's way.

Throwing a ball is only an atack when it's thrown with enough force to harm you, otherwise, it's not.
But since you wanted light, I mentioned it above.

Yata would the same. But it is transparent, we can see itachi even when he places the shield in front of him. So light goes through the shield, it's simple as that.
There is nothing to prove that yata would be an exception.

If you wanne say hat I shouldn't use a regular shield as a reference, then you might want to prove what would make yata so different that this basic logic wouldn't apply to it. Do you have any evidence to say that yata or spiritual weapons would differ from that logic? If not, then the comparison stands.
Depending on the intensity, sound can harn you, and so can light. It would harm you to the point that you would get blind and deaf.

Baseless assumption? So is yours. We can't see yata when he lets itachi in, so you can't state that as a fact either It's a double standard. And I got something. Itachi was dying, so perhaps he couldnt even keep yata. The fact is: you cant use a doubt, an assumption, as an evidence

Yata and totsuka are not made of itachi's chakra. They' re spiritual weapons that itachi attached to his susanoo. That's why they have itachi's susanoo pattern. Doesn't mean they are made of itachi's chakra. It was stated in the manga that they are weapons. And if they were made of itachi's chakra, nagato could have absorbed totsuka.

Funny way to "disprove things". Totsuka is not yata, but it is a spiritual weapon( just like yata) and it was attached to itachi's susanoo in the same way.

The user of susanoo can let people inside SUSANOO, it was never said the same to yata. As I said, yata is a spiritual weapon, not itachi's chakra.
 
Last edited:

Wolfus

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
4,855
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Nah, Wolfus dumb comparisons make no sense but since you agree It makes sense.... Anyways.. Why would Itachi use yata knowing it would only save him and leave naruto and bee captured? Itachi being Top 3 more analytical in the series knew that his long range weapon would be required to make sure EVERYONE Survived
i said explain to me why would he use yata if he still havent reached the core he was far away from the core when all 3 attacked the core why would he use yata mirror from that distance ?

@bold "if anything goes wrong" assumption.
And how would he know that the 3 atacks would be enough to destroy the core? Did itachi know the core's resistance to know exactly how much damage does it need to be done for it to be destroyed?

Itachi can use his yasata no magatam atack and use yata. If yata could've blocked CT, he would've used it. He was far from the core, but he didn't know if all the atacks would destroy it, and the core had a great gravitational pull. He wasn't miles away either.
 
Top