[Question] The Strawhats vs. Whitebeard

[MickNerks]

If the current strawhats were to fight marineford whitebeard who would win.

The strawhats consist of:

Luffy
Usopp
Nami
Sanji
Zoro
Chopper (Starts in Monster Point)
Brook
Nico Robin
Franky (Starts in Iron Giant)
(With special guest)Bartolomeo


vs


Edward Newgate


Location: The coliseum

 

[Fireplay]

Whitebeard takes them out. Currently the Strawhats are far from WB's level. Hell, an admiral could solo them.

Inb4fujitoradownplay

 

[TheHokage]

Prime Edward Newgate or Old Sick Edward Newgate?

Anyway Prime Edward Newgate wins low diff.

Old sick Edward Newgate wins mid diff.

Basically Whitebeard would win.

 

[Cursed Prince]

Whitebeard gets stomped Lol

 

[xxSAGExx]

If the current strawhats were to fight marineford whitebeard who would win.

The strawhats consist of:

Luffy
Usopp
Nami
Sanji
Zoro
Chopper (Starts in Monster Point)
Brook
Nico Robin
Franky (Starts in Iron Giant)
(With special guest)Bartolomeo


vs


Edward Newgate


Location: The coliseum

I have to go with White beard, he was said to have the power to destroy the world. He can kill most of the Strawhats in 1 blow. I see White beard splitting the land, then breaking the ground under them. If he wasn't on the same island then he could make a tsunami which would take them all out especially devil fruit users. What we saw of White beard was him in an old sick state as well. Luffy's group need more training before they can hope to take White Beard down.

When I was reading Wiki on Shanks, I'm sure it said Oda said Shanks Haki is so strong that he could have took out all 100,000 merman while Luffy took out 50,000. I was hoping Luffy some how was able to eat Ace's fruit but I'm not sure how well that would work out in his fighting style, Sabo might not even give it too him and only Black Beard seems to know how to have more than 1 power.

 

[Fireplay]

Whitebeard gets stomped Lol

Lol. This quote is sig worthy (not in a bad way). You really don't see the sentence "Whitebeard gets stomped" very often.

 

[VongolaX]

Whitebeard would clobber them for now...

 

[MickNerks]

I have to go with White beard, he was said to have the power to destroy the world. He can kill most of the Strawhats in 1 blow. I see White beard splitting the land, then breaking the ground under them. If he wasn't on the same island then he could make a tsunami which would take them all out especially devil fruit users. What we saw of White beard was him in an old sick state as well. Luffy's group need more training before they can hope to take White Beard down.

When I was reading Wiki on Shanks, I'm sure it said Oda said Shanks Haki is so strong that he could have took out all 100,000 merman while Luffy took out 50,000. I was hoping Luffy some how was able to eat Ace's fruit but I'm not sure how well that would work out in his fighting style, Sabo might not even give it too him and only Black Beard seems to know how to have more than 1 power.

I think the strawhats would stand a better chance because i included bartolomeo to their team. His barriers were durable enought to block the KINGS PUNCH, and the KINGS PUNCH is said to be strong enough to overpower a yonkou. So if bart can protech from quakes, I can see them slowly but surely taking whitebeard down with high diff.

 

[Love Cook]

Whitebeard was up versus the almost the entire marine forces with some of the strongest names from the New World.

Strawhats rock but they're not at that level yet, they've been in the NW for 1 week tops now.

Monster point and Iron General aren't helping chopper and Franky at all because they only become bigger targets. Monster trio might get an attack in but it would be the final thing they do if they get close.

 

[Hexuze]

Sick WB low-diff.

 

[Kuzan]

Whitebeard low-diff, the weak trio gets taken out by 1 punch.

 

[Uchiha seeker]

So If the SH just stand long range, they can say it was a long battle but they lost Luffy, Chopper and Robin because of the tidal wave that occurred.

Kidding Zoro solo's.

 

[Olorin]

Well let's see if Luffy really takes on doflamingo, if he does and we know Zoro isn't far behind the Monster trio could actually give WB a good fight, if Luffy can't beat Dofy than it is a no-brainer, let's not forget that we have no idea how strong they are, if Luffy could take on Dofy (most expect him not to be able to but still) than together they should be ble to take on an Admiral and by extension, be able to give WB a good fight

Don't forget that Luffy cant be THAT far from Admiral level because he still does need to eventually get to Roger level and if he was weak that could be a problem

Also I think that if you are taking on someone like WB the non m3o would be a hindrance

 

[Mephew D Kensei]

They are not taking WB IMO even though as a group they are powerful their individual strenght is probably nothing vs WB coz when u take a quak bubble fist u take it as an individual and 6 of the SH are 1shotted more lyk shitted really and the useful 3 will give him a low to mid diff fight as I see it now, but there a some variables e.g G3 and Asura and the Barto addition but all in all WB will still b the victor.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

People thinking Whitebeard can solo the Strawhats...

MFWB - Strawhats High diff
Prime WB - Whitebeard Mid diff

 

[Avinash012]

The dude rapes whole crew anyday untill M3 reaches Admiral level.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Prime Newgate low diff. People are really underestimating him.

 

[Olorin]

The dude rapes whole crew anyday untill M3 reaches Admiral level.

3 admirals would rape WB, he got a pretty bad beating from Akainu alone

If all 3 m3o were admiral lvl they could easily defeat WB

 

[jiraiya lives]

any original admiral can solo the crew midd-High diff...old whitebeard is a little too much even for the whole crew.

 

[Hexuze]

People thinking Whitebeard can solo the Strawhats...

MFWB - Strawhats High diff
Prime WB - Whitebeard Mid diff

ROFL XD

I seriously hope you're joking. The SH's can't even take down an admiral atm lol.