Why do people think Gaara's sand is weak to lightning?

xxSAGExx

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
5,197
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The only lightning jutsu that pierced Gaara's sand was chidori, chidori is a piercing attack, it focus the lightning chakra into one point for it's power. This is described by Gai when Sasuke first used it and . That doesn't mean all lightning jutsus can overcome Gaara's sand nor I remember seeing another lightning jutsus do it. Since we have no actual manga prove this falls into the speculation pile but I'm sure Gaara's sand is Wind+Earth, which would make it made from lightning's weakness (wind) and an element lightning is stronger than (earth) but as we seen with Kakashi vs Kakuza when he used water jutsu against wind+fire, that water alone wasn't enough .

Gaara got his sand ability from Shukaku who displayed using wind jutsu and . Gaara is also from the wind country so either he already had wind on his own or got it from Shukaku.

Gaara was able to block A's leg drop even though A have version 2 lightning armor increasing his power . the armor increases A's speed, power, and defenses. He used it light his father, like a chidori like attack to cut off one of the 8 tail's horns . If Gaara's sand was really weak against lightning then it wouldn't be able to stop A's attack. I read someone say A's armor is just lightning chakra on A's body which is different but it's not, chidori is lightning on your hand and chidori lacked the power to impale A and .

Some people say Gaara can't tank Kirin which I believe is false. First off Kirin isn't even chakra made. Second it's not a piercing attack, it's a destructive attack. Did Kirin go thru the mountain or destroyed it? Gaara shown to tank a stronger destructive attack, Deidara's C3 that had a larger blast radius , and . His sand is strong enough to take on 4-5 of Madara's complete Susanoo's swords in a weakened condition (not at full power). and


Like I said in the beginning, it still falls in the speculation pile until his chakra nature is confirmed, same as it's speculation that sand is weak against lightning but it makes more sense that it's not weak against all lightning jutsus but focused/piercing attacks.
 

TheRedAndGreenBeast

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,686
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Coming from a certain country doesn't mean you have the countries element it was named after. Naruto is from the Fire country and has Wind Release only. Atsui was from the Lightning country but he had Fire Release.

Sand is not a mix of Earth and Wind. If it was, Yamato or Kakashi would have said it when Naruto was training in the elements; they told Naruto about Haku's Ice being Water and Wind so why would they not tell him about Gaara's sand?

However, you are correct on your other points. Sand's weakness is not Lightning. It has not been stated in the manga and there is nothing to suggest or imply that it should be weak to Lightning.
 
Joined
Jul 21, 2011
Messages
7,048
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I'd say its strong enough to stop Hashirama's mokton and 5 Madara's susanoo slashes. But it isn't strong enough to stop any of Sasuke's susanoo slashes or lightning variations.

Its not worth mentioning at this point and time in the series though.
 

AlphaScythian

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
14,389
Kin
90💸
Kumi
51💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Amaterasu is said to burn anything but Gaara's sand caught the Enton and was just holding it . Enton>Lightning :p
Not in Kishi's manga :p
Paper>Rock>Scissors right? Now face reality Rock>Paper and scissors. FRS did nothing to raikage, it completely failed, it didnt cut it didnt destroy a shit. Chidori has breached raiton armor and nukite destroyed it.
Raiton owns mokuton, doton, suiton, and by feats fuuton as well.
 

Gatsuuga

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
6,239
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Poeple also think gaaras sand is weak to water, which is false as well. It's weak to oil, but gaara has been seen controlling sand that was underwater (mei's water dragon).

It's like most things on NB people just take a page way to literally. Its the same as people thinking that oro is weak to genjutsu because itachi caught him once.....like really people.
 
Joined
Jul 21, 2011
Messages
7,048
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Poeple also think gaaras sand is weak to water, which is false as well. It's weak to oil, but gaara has been seen controlling sand that was underwater (mei's water dragon).

It's like most things on NB people just take a page way to literally. Its the same as people thinking that oro is weak to genjutsu because itachi caught him once.....like really people.
I mean but we're talking Sasuke's genjutsu lmao! That is staying no matter how you try to sway it.

I agree though. Some people today think just because Naruto hit Madara to the ground means he has a better chance at beating him than Sasuke. Sh!t doesn't make sense, especially when he's blind.
 

xxSAGExx

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
5,197
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Isn't Sand a Doton's variant, like Clay??
If it isn't sorry, I always thought that way...
It was never confirm, that's why I said it's in the speculation pile and we see Shukaku, the sand beast, use wind blast. It's the same as Son Goku's lava (Earth+Fire) in my opinion.

Coming from a certain country doesn't mean you have the countries element it was named after. Naruto is from the Fire country and has Wind Release only. Atsui was from the Lightning country but he had Fire Release.

Sand is not a mix of Earth and Wind. If it was, Yamato or Kakashi would have said it when Naruto was training in the elements; they told Naruto about Haku's Ice being Water and Wind so why would they not tell him about Gaara's sand?

However, you are correct on your other points. Sand's weakness is not Lightning. It has not been stated in the manga and there is nothing to suggest or imply that it should be weak to Lightning.
Well I wasn't solely saying it's because he's from the Wind country but that it can be a factor of if he has on his own or from Shukaku's power much like Son giving his Jinchuuriki the power to use Lava jutsu (earth+fire). Also more ninjas would have their country's chakra type than not, Hiruzen, Jiraiya, Uchiha clan, some unnamed fodders.

Also Kakashi wanted to keep the explanation short, remember he had to fully explain things to Naruto on Shadow clones, shape manipulation and nature transformation. Naruto was even asking him questions on things like medical ninjutsu and such. He didn't mention magnetic chakra that Gaara's dad and the 3rd Kazekage use either.

Why else would the sand beast, Shukaku use wind? Gaara was still able to use Shukaku's abilities so that means wind chakra too. Remember Naruto couldn't pull Shukaku out of Juubito because he didn't have chakra from him but Gaara, being it's container before did and
 

xxSAGExx

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
5,197
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Paper>Rock>Scissors right? Now face reality Rock>Paper and scissors. FRS did nothing to raikage, it completely failed, it didnt cut it didnt destroy a shit. Chidori has breached raiton armor and nukite destroyed it.
Raiton owns mokuton, doton, suiton, and by feats fuuton as well.
Actually FRS took out the 3rd Raikage's lightning armor, the armor took the blunt of the attack while the Raikge's natural powerful defense helped as well. His armor was off after the blast then he put it back on . The Raikage didn't really even tank it, you can see cracks on him . FRS cuts all your cells with tiny blades, not really useful on a edo that would regenerate from it.

I'd say its strong enough to stop Hashirama's mokton and 5 Madara's susanoo slashes. But it isn't strong enough to stop any of Sasuke's susanoo slashes or lightning variations.

Its not worth mentioning at this point and time in the series though.
Hashirama's wood and Madara's Susanoo are stronger than Sasuke's Susanoo slash (not talking about Enton enhanced sword). The only big Damage Sasuke's Susanoo did was when he had Naruto's chakra which was already shown to increase their jutsu's power by a ton. Hinata deflected 1 of Juubi's tail alone, Sasuke had Yin yang Kurama chakra which was much stronger as said by Choji.

Also Sasuke's lightning jutsus are mostly piercing jutsus and I mentioned piercing jutsu in OT
 

TheRedAndGreenBeast

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,686
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It was never confirm, that's why I said it's in the speculation pile and we see Shukaku, the sand beast, use wind blast. It's the same as Son Goku's lava (Earth+Fire) in my opinion.



Well I wasn't solely saying it's because he's from the Wind country but that it can be a factor of if he has on his own or from Shukaku's power much like Son giving his Jinchuuriki the power to use Lava jutsu (earth+fire). Also more ninjas would have their country's chakra type than not, Hiruzen, Jiraiya, Uchiha clan, some unnamed fodders.

Also Kakashi wanted to keep the explanation short, remember he had to fully explain things to Naruto on Shadow clones, shape manipulation and nature transformation. Naruto was even asking him questions on things like medical ninjutsu and such. He didn't mention magnetic chakra that Gaara's dad and the 3rd Kazekage use either.

Why else would the sand beast, Shukaku use wind? Gaara was still able to use Shukaku's abilities so that means wind chakra too. Remember Naruto couldn't pull Shukaku out of Juubito because he didn't have chakra from him but Gaara, being it's container before did and
I see what you're saying but remember: the Sarutobi clan and the Uchiha clan are both known for being fire-wielding clan. If anything, chakra nature runs through the family like genes (somewhat, not the case in all situations). Kakashi didn't know about magnetic chakra as he had never met anybody with the ability prior to the time. Why mention Haku then? Why not mention Gaara since Naruto is more familiar with Gaara's jutsu?
 
Top