Misconception: Sound Genjutsu > Sharingan: Genjutsu

[Solo]

I'm going to make this as brief as possible. Sound Genjutsu does nothing to your senses, but "mediocre" paralysis. Basically, it prevents you from breaking the Jutsu. That's only a hypothesis. Being inside of a Sound Genjutsu still allows you to use your moves. It's like they're still in reality, but outside of it. Sharingan Genjutsu can make reality. Often times, they were completely aware of their surroundings. I'm too lazy to look for scans, but I'll tell you the scans to look for.

Example:
- Itachi and Sasuke was able to perform their Genjutsu.
- Shikamaru was able to perform his Shadow Jutsu to break his finger.
- Pain still had control of his other bodies.

Temari was able to blow the Sound Genjutsu away. If you had a move that could disrupt your chakra such Shikamaru's Shadow Jutsu, then you're still able break the jutsu.


Sharingan: Genjutsu is a bit different. Often times you won't even realize you're in a Genjutsu. Inside a Sharingan Genjutsu you don't have access to your moves, and allows you to control your opponent, your opponent senses, paralyze, or put to sleep. Downside it, breaking it is not impossible.


Overall, it all depends on the situation in which the jutsu is being used. Saying it's greater than Sharingan Genjutsu is stretching it.

 

[Frankenstein]

I'm going to make this as brief as possible. Sound Genjutsu does nothing to your senses, but "mediocre" paralysis. Basically, it prevents you from breaking the Jutsu. That's only a hypothesis. Being inside of a Sound Genjutsu still allows you to use your moves. It's like they're still in reality, but outside of it. Sharingan Genjutsu can make reality. Often times, they were completely aware of their surroundings. I'm too lazy to look for scans, but I'll tell you the scans to look for.

Example:
- Itachi and Sasuke was able to perform their Genjutsu.
- Shikamaru was able to perform his Shadow Jutsu to break his finger.
- Pain still had control of his other bodies.

Temari was able to blow the Sound Genjutsu away. If you had a move that could disrupt your chakra such Shikamaru's Shadow Jutsu, then you're still able break the jutsu.


Sharingan: Genjutsu is a bit different. Often times you won't even realize you're in a Genjutsu. Inside a Sharingan Genjutsu you don't have access to your moves, and allows you to control your opponent, your opponent senses, paralyze, or put to sleep. Downside it, breaking it is not impossible.


Overall, it all depends on the situation in which the jutsu is being used. Saying it's greater than Sharingan Genjutsu is stretching it.

Oh man I so miss the naruto discussion (NOT).

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

I agree, but sharingan genjutsu can be broken idk say if Obito goes to Kamui place and Minato warps away. Would it be broken?

 

[Naijakid]

Sound genjutsu>>Sharingan genjutsu

 

[Prince Charles]

Both have benefits over the other but sound genjutsu would be more useful if your facing alot of opponents as demonstrated by SM jiraiya.

 

[Solo]

Oh man I so miss the naruto discussion (NOT).

Was there a problem with that part, Sir? If you need scans, I'll gladly find them.

I agree, but sharingan genjutsu can be broken idk say if Obito goes to Kamui place and Minato warps away. Would it be broken?

I did state in my post that it's not impossible to break Sharingan Genjutsu. Not really sure at your question.

 

[HiddenSound]

I agree that it depends on the situation.

 

[-Spoiler-]

but not everyone has a jutsu like shadow possession jutsu pein had other bodies of course he could get them out of the sound genjutsu.

 

[Kαmi]

I think sound genjutsu is best for opponents who need to keep their distance or have multiple opponents while Sharingan is better for 1 vs 1. Though you have a point about the opponents still being able to get out of sound genjutsu while still in it. I think Naruto's method of forcibly disrupting his chakra would have worked against sound genjutsu better than his attempt against Itachi's genjutsu as sound genjutsu seems easier to get out of.

Your reputation for Sasuke threads make people automatically assume you're being biased Lol it's kinda sad.

 

[Prince Charles]

I think sound genjutsu is best for opponents who need to keep their distance or have multiple opponents while Sharingan is better for 1 vs 1. Though you have a point about the opponents still being able to get out of sound genjutsu while still in it. I think Naruto's method of forcibly disrupting his chakra would have worked against sound genjutsu better than his attempt against Itachi's genjutsu as sound genjutsu seems easier to get out of.

Your reputation for Sasuke threads make people automatically assume you're being biased Lol it's kinda sad.

This is true, Solo is a very intelligent debater, people simply fall for his troll threads :yeah:

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Was there a problem with that part, Sir? If you need scans, I'll gladly find them.


I did state in my post that it's not impossible to break Sharingan Genjutsu. Not really sure at your question.

If Minato gets hit with sharingan genjutsu, would he or Obito be able to warp out of it? ​

 

[Solo]

but not everyone has a jutsu like shadow possession jutsu pein had other bodies of course he could get them out of the sound genjutsu.

Again, I said it depend on the situation. Someone like Kakashi could break regular Sharingan Genjutsu, but failed when it comes to Sound base Genjutsu. Then again, someone could break Sound Genjutsu and failed when it comes to Sharingan Genjutsu.

 

[Bad Touch Yakushi]

For the normal ninja, it's a game ender.

The only situations you're mentioning are special cases like Six Paths Pain bodies or Shadow Posession, these are very uncommon ninjutsu.

 

[Bronze]

Depending on the situation but for this i will give you a rep.

 

[Kαmi]

This is true, Solo is a very intelligent debater, people simply fall for his troll threads :yeah:

And the people fall for it, every time :leaf:

 

[Solo]

If Minato gets hit with sharingan genjutsu, would he or Obito be able to warp out of it? ​

Some Sharingan Genjutsu has prevented you from performing a jutsu because it instantly leave you either sleep, paralyzed, weakened, or you're being controlled. Therefore, I'm going with no.

With Sound Genjutsu I believe they can.

 

[Boston Rob]

Biting your lip and sound genjutsu is over
When youre under KA, Izanami, Tsukuyoimi you cant do anything
Sharingan genjutsu > Sound genjutsu

 

[Champ]

Forgot Temari was able to blow away Temari sound genjutsu haha, what a lousy counter so all Danzo has to do is blow the sound away if he is fighting SM Jiraiya.

 

[Solo]

For the normal ninja, it's a game ender.

The only situations you're mentioning are special cases like Six Paths Pain bodies or Shadow Posession, these are very uncommon ninjutsu.

For the normal ninja Sharingan Genjutsu is a game ender. Even above normal, Raikage for example.

 

[mrcrazyboyravi]

Some Sharingan Genjutsu has prevented you from performing a jutsu because it instantly leave you either sleep, paralyzed, weakened, or you're being controlled. Therefore, I'm going with no.

With Sound Genjutsu I believe they can.

so if saskue could only use sound genjutsu instead of sharingan then ?