Kishi makes mistakes, yes, in fact I'm all for critizining the manga. It sounds silly to me when people don't want others critizing the manga.
But...
Well yeah lets just use a normal eye when the entire Uchiha Clan fighting style is dependent on Sharingan ability of movement prediction, chakra perception etc ...... I am sure that wont create a problem.
PS Grave robbing is also an option, or asking for a donation is also an option.
OT: Such things been happening for a long time .... For example: Madara had a spare eye from a random Uchiha when he first met Obito, yet he was able to control the Black Rods which is seemingly be a Rinnegan power .... So apparently it a more complex thing, Tobirama explained that the special chakra in the brain causes the Sharingan transformation, so apparent the brain is the source of Sharingan's power (So limited acess to the powers should be avaiable) and the eyes is the medium of channeling that power (This also explains EMS .... The Original owner already transforms the eye and then the special brain chakra of the person who gets d implants tries to change it again creating a double pattern eye .... seemingly the similarity of blood creates a resonance effect which makes it immune to effects of sight deterioration). Also it is seen that Susanoo responds to the user's feelings and thus mental state while Amaterasu or Tsukiomy doesnt ... so its more likely that the origin of Susanoo lies in the brain not the eyes.
U guys never looking at things unless they bite you in the rear and announce its presence?
Great your writing a story but come back when your actually famous or critically acclaimed in at least one country (which proves either your literary talent or commercialization talent) to judge someone like Kishi .... Also what people thought was the 'logic' is actually not the logic or settings of the plot, there are many subtle hints that Susanoo is unlike Amaterasu or Tsukiomy and Madara is a person beyond 'normal' abilities. Not to mention as author shldnt you know that at certain times some impossible revelation is made which is explained later on by some authors? Also as a author you should know that manga is actually read in volumes?
I agree with this.
I think it's simply not a mistake. There's most likely a reason why only a "double" mangyekou can awaken Susano'o as opposed to mangeyku that have the same ability in each eye. Also, Susano'o responded to Sasuke's hatred whereas Tsukumoyi and Amaterasu doesn't. Obito said his
body responded. And then Susano'o elevated?
Also, Madara has an EMS. He also have senju DNA, Yin and Yang. It was said that the S06P created form from nothingess using Yin and Yang. Knowing Madara, he's probably a master of both chakras. Could he not manifest Susano'o?
The double mangeykou (MS techs) probably unlocks a
jutsu that can potentially be used without the eyes. Kishi is probably going to explain the origins of Susano'o, why only a double mangeykou can awaken it, as well as being the only "MS tech" that responds to ther user's emotions. Our own assumptions (though we did have reasons to assume) is what we're confused over. Kishi writes the story, we read it. At some point we have to understand that maybe he's going to reveal it later? It's only been one chapter...
Though some seem like they already have their minds made up, and will scream BS no matter
how good and legit the explanation is. It's a bit of a shame when Kishi's past mistakes can be used to derail logical explanations. That's like saying Tobirama's explanation of the shadow clones don't make sense because of X, Y, and Z mistakes. A line have to be drawn somewhere, otherwise nothing in the manga would have any meaning. If the explanation is completely stupid, then bash all you want. However, if it's logical, then at least admit. Regardless, we should wait before dismissing it as idiotic.
Kishi
just made him lose his eyes, then made him use Susano'o? lol let him explain. He's probably going to use it to give further details about Susano'o itself.
