Chunin exams Gaara vs Neji!

Who is the winner?

  • Neji Hyugga

    Votes: 2 40.0%
  • Gaara Of the Desert

    Votes: 3 60.0%

  • Total voters
    5
  • Poll closed .

Brother Numpsay

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
7,879
Reaction score
334
I think you need to brush up on what a straw man is. That is not a straw man.

Im pretty sure I used it right. You comment statement misrepresented my point there.

Right, because backing up is out of the question?

Who said backing up in the starting distance. Gaara will not have time to gather that much sand wave .

Bloodlust =\= Crazy, bloodlust means they will use whatever techs nescessary to win the fight, regardless if it is in character for them.

Thanks for correcting me. Crazy Gaara is not doing his flight and title wave as stated.
 

Booker

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Messages
8,352
Reaction score
958
Im pretty sure I used it right. You comment statement misrepresented my point there.

Nope you didn't, my comment was completely relevant to yours. You claimed Neji could drain the chakra from Gaara's sand with a single strike, but that is false because Gaara has multiple clouds of sand that are not connected by the same chakra. It's not the chakra thread Neji cut where it's a direct line, this is a cloud of chakra, more fluid than linear. Btw, Neji didnmt absorb the chakra, he only cut it. There is not cutting or severing the chakra in a sand cloud.


Who said backing up in the starting distance. Gaara will not have time to gather that much sand wave .

Why couldn't he? That's bare dirt they're standing on.



Thanks for correcting me. Crazy Gaara is not doing his flight and title wave as stated.

Why are you saying Gaara is crazy? This is a strawman.

Bloodlust doesn't mean Gaara is crazy. We had the term "bloodlust" over at the battle sections on Comicvine as well, it just means the character will use whatever techniques needed to win.

In this case, Gaara flies on a sand cloud and obliterates Neji.
 

Brother Numpsay

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
7,879
Reaction score
334
Nope you didn't, my comment was completely relevant to yours. You claimed Neji could drain the chakra from Gaara's sand with a single strike, but that is false because Gaara has multiple clouds of sand that are not connected by the same chakra. It's not the chakra thread Neji cut where it's a direct line, this is a cloud of chakra, more fluid than linear. Btw, Neji didnmt absorb the chakra, he only cut it. There is not cutting or severing the chakra in a sand cloud.

I claim that Neji can drain chakra? Ill wait for a quote.

Did you not see the scans that Neji is able to put chakra via Juuken, to destroy any chakra base attack like even Water Release?



Why couldn't he? That's bare dirt they're standing on.

Because the distance between them is instant KO for Neji or Neji can go behind easily, while Gaara is gathering and grinding sand for no reason?

Why are you saying Gaara is crazy? This is a strawman.

Bloodlust doesn't mean Gaara is crazy. We had the term "bloodlust" over at the battle sections on Comicvine as well, it just means the character will use whatever techniques needed to win.

In this case, Gaara flies on a sand cloud and obliterates Neji.

Didn't I not just thank you for correcting me of telling the difference? Scratch all of this "crazy and bloodlust" and focus on the IN CHARACTER of the match up.
 

fastrthnwind

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jun 9, 2011
Messages
4,539
Reaction score
307
im gonna end this right here.

Neji loses at the very most with high diff and its all because of this:
Gaaras Auto Sand Defense.

Neji does not have the footspeed in order to surpass the sands defensive speed at this point in time and because of this he wont be able to land any crippling blows to gaara himself.

without gaaras auto sand defense, neji can use gentle fist to easily break gaaras chakra formed sand armor and destroy him from there, but this isnt the case

Neji does have the stronger defense so he could easily tank any of gaaras sand attacks should they ever get too close, but without the speed necessary to bypass the sand shield, he wont gain any ground on Gaara, leading into a stakina battle whoch gaara will obviously win.
 

Booker

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Messages
8,352
Reaction score
958
I claim that Neji can drain chakra? Ill wait for a quote.

Did you not see the scans that Neji is able to put chakra via Juuken, to destroy any chakra base attack like even Water Release?

Read post #17, the quotes portion and your response. You led me on to believe that's what you were saying.

He's not cancelling the chakra of the water jutsu with those strikes, he's just punching through them. Any regular punch would obviously go through a water clone. Besides, even if he was, sand is different from water. Water atoms are all connected and are actually pretty sticky, atoms of Gaara's sand however are not connected and are free floating. Otherwise they would be a rock.

And that's a Part 2 Feat. Hardly applicable, as he had (3?) years to fine tune his technique.

Because the distance between them is instant KO for Neji or Neji can go behind easily, while Gaara is gathering and grinding sand for no reason?

Right, because we all know Neji instantly KO'd Naruto, right? Neji doesn't even get past Gaara's sand.

Didn't I not just thank you for correcting me of telling the difference? Scratch all of this "crazy and bloodlust" and focus on the IN CHARACTER of the match up.

Sorry, I thought the OP had it set to bloodlust, that's my fault.

Without bloodlust, Gaara will not be going instantly to Flying/Tsunami mode, but he still handily takes this because Neji won't get past his sand defense without wasting his own chakra.
 

Brother Numpsay

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
7,879
Reaction score
334
Read post #17, the quotes portion and your response. You led me on to believe that's what you were saying.

Oh I thought "He'll" was referring to Gaara, chakra taxing. Since Neji has no feat of draining chakra with Juuken

He's not cancelling the chakra of the water jutsu with those strikes, he's just punching through them. Any regular punch would obviously go through a water clone. Besides, even if he was, sand is different from water. Water atoms are all connected and are actually pretty sticky, atoms of Gaara's sand however are not connected and are free floating. Otherwise they would be a rock.

And that's a Part 2 Feat. Hardly applicable, as he had (3?) years to fine tune his technique.

Read that scan again he canceled the water jutsu by releasing all the chakra points from his body. Juuken works by putting their own chakra into an attack, which disrupt theirs, thus cancel the effects. Nothing is different if the user is using chakra into it.

Mentioning him doing it in part 2 only is meaningless as I already shown him doing it to another jutsu in part 1. [ ] [ ] [ ]

Right, because we all know Neji instantly KO'd Naruto, right? Neji doesn't even get past Gaara's sand.

Instant KO was an exaggerate as your claim as "instant Tsunami", which actually is him gathering chakra to build it, which Neji can see with his eyes.

Sorry, I thought the OP had it set to bloodlust, that's my fault.

Without bloodlust, Gaara will not be going instantly to Flying/Tsunami mode, but he still handily takes this because Neji won't get past his sand defense without wasting his own chakra.

I beg to differ, Sasuke's Taijutsu was enough to his Sand. Juuken makes things alot worst. And with his impressive speed. Gaara is going to have a hard time.
 

Red Slayer

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 7, 2011
Messages
5,682
Reaction score
247
I clicked the first, and assumed the second was Rotation. My bad.

Your argument still doesn't hold though. The sand isn't connected like the threads were, so Neji's chakra poke strategy won't do jack.

I fail to see how the second scan saves him from sand coffin when he can't move.

how can sand catch Neji when he has 360 Degrees of Vision and absolute def.
even if gaara catch him(idk how he will able to pass rotation or trick Genius who can see everything and defeat everything which is made from chakra ) Neji can use Full Body Blow Technique gg send

where is fight? where sasuke and Gaara ? is this CE Gaara or SRA Gaara?
 
Last edited:
Top