First this thread isnt about the moral implications of the Infinite Tsukuyomi, its about discussing why the Infinite Tsukuyomi Plan is Unrealistic, Unsustainable, and Selfish
Some people argued its better to live in a perfect world made of lies and illusions than live in a 'harsh' reality , and fine, i disagree with that and thats final, but this thread is about the IT itself
The IT is unrealistic and unsustainable, i say this because assuming people live in 'dream world' they would need sustenance for their real bodies to survive, if people continue to live in reality, and eat normal food, there would still be people who live in poor countries and starve with lack of food...
People pointed out that, for both cases the Madara or Obito will connect EVERYONE in the planet with roots or cables from the shinju and channel chakra to 'feed' them, whether that is logical or not, decide yourself
But the reason i say its not is, Madara and Obito claimed to create a perfect world, however, Obito, and Madara if he were to be able to control the shinju, must be MORTAL and be the juubis jinchuuriki, since the Shinju and the Juubi is one and the same.
We found in the last chapter that the Shinju's true nature is to devour chakras from its victims and leave them dead as dry husks, but they argue madara and obito will channel chakra instead to 'feed' them, by controlling it
However, the SO6P, who was the jinchuuriki of the PERFECT juubi aka the shinju, grew old, ill and died, so he was powerful, and mortal like everyone else...
So what will happen if Madara and Obito fell ill e.g heart attack/disease or simply grew old and died?
The shinju would be loose and instead of giving chakra would instead devour everyone with chakra and killed all those it was originally feeding, which means game over and goodbye to so called 'perfect' world..
I tried to think about how it might be possible for IT to be sustained, like maybe Madara passed the juubi/shinju into someone else when he is old, but there is no guarantee said host would be able to control the shinju, as we saw with obito, which is why i say, the IT is not the salvation of the world, it is the opposite
There is no 'Eternal happiness' in IT, there is only death and despair at the end of the road
Some people argued its better to live in a perfect world made of lies and illusions than live in a 'harsh' reality , and fine, i disagree with that and thats final, but this thread is about the IT itself
The IT is unrealistic and unsustainable, i say this because assuming people live in 'dream world' they would need sustenance for their real bodies to survive, if people continue to live in reality, and eat normal food, there would still be people who live in poor countries and starve with lack of food...
People pointed out that, for both cases the Madara or Obito will connect EVERYONE in the planet with roots or cables from the shinju and channel chakra to 'feed' them, whether that is logical or not, decide yourself
But the reason i say its not is, Madara and Obito claimed to create a perfect world, however, Obito, and Madara if he were to be able to control the shinju, must be MORTAL and be the juubis jinchuuriki, since the Shinju and the Juubi is one and the same.
We found in the last chapter that the Shinju's true nature is to devour chakras from its victims and leave them dead as dry husks, but they argue madara and obito will channel chakra instead to 'feed' them, by controlling it
However, the SO6P, who was the jinchuuriki of the PERFECT juubi aka the shinju, grew old, ill and died, so he was powerful, and mortal like everyone else...
So what will happen if Madara and Obito fell ill e.g heart attack/disease or simply grew old and died?
The shinju would be loose and instead of giving chakra would instead devour everyone with chakra and killed all those it was originally feeding, which means game over and goodbye to so called 'perfect' world..
I tried to think about how it might be possible for IT to be sustained, like maybe Madara passed the juubi/shinju into someone else when he is old, but there is no guarantee said host would be able to control the shinju, as we saw with obito, which is why i say, the IT is not the salvation of the world, it is the opposite
There is no 'Eternal happiness' in IT, there is only death and despair at the end of the road
