~THEORY~ Madara's trump card! ~THEORY~

[Son Ryuto Uzumaki]

Not Impossible but really do you think Obito gives a f at this point to be honest if Madara brought her but it would probably be Obito who kills her

 

[Mitarashi]

Madara may have known. That doesn't change anything, because Madara did not have the ability to bring her back.

The only logical way would her to have never died in the first place, which is impossible because we've already seen that the three tails was on land. Meaning..... That it was extracted from her body or reincarnated itself somewhere.

Either way. She would of had to die to for it be extracted in which case she would have died afterwards.

Who says she really was the 3 tails jin?
If my theory is correct, that was a Zetsu talking to Kakashi, and kishi/Madara could have had that said to make people think exactly what you are.

 

[Revengedace]

Thing is those Kiri nin knew she was a Jin, meaning she must have had the Jin sealed in her in Kiri. Make sense?

Then, take into account the fact that the 3 Tails was, by Shippuden, free living in the lake.

Rin isn't as strong as Kushina so the removal of the 3 Tails would have killed her.

I do agree that Madara had engineered the whole event, but I don't think she's alive...

I beleive that was filler with the 3 tails being in the lake

 

[Mitarashi]

I beleive that was filler with the 3 tails being in the lake

Not when Deidera/Tobi retrieved it from the lake, that was canon.

 

[Beetle]

I mean, the mizukage jinchuuriki was controlled by Madara/Obito, so there may be a connection here. Plus she could be attached to a zetsu tree...

Obito to Rinne-tensei Rin and die?

 

[NarutoDKurosaki]

One problem, madara DIDN'T have the rinne tensei though. Before obitio showed up, nagato had his eyes.

 

[Mitarashi]

One problem, madara DIDN'T have the rinne tensei though. Before obitio showed up, nagato had his eyes.

Already solved.

Rin wasn't 3 tails jin, a Zetsu pretending to be Rin told Kakashi that, as that's who was killed

 

[Senju Bean]

You know what would be crazy? Say Rin showed up due to Madara.

Now Obito blasts her away, saying that she's a "fake" and that only the "real" Rin can exist in the Infinite Tsukuyomi. This is satisfying in two ways.

1) It would show just how crazy/demented/determined Obito is.
2) It would also despell the idea that Obito is a butthurt pedo that wants to take the world out b/c he lost his crush. No, it would be much deeper than that.

 

[Mitarashi]

You know what would be crazy? Say Rin showed up due to Madara.

Now Obito blasts her away, saying that she's a "fake" and that only the "real" Rin can exist in the Infinite Tsukuyomi. This is satisfying in two ways.

1) It would show just how crazy/demented/determined Obito is.
2) It would also despell the idea that Obito is a butthurt pedo that wants to take the world out b/c he lost his crush. No, it would be much deeper than that.

That won't happen.
he is willing to destroy anything too see her again, if it happens for real, then hey why not?

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

Ya her dying and him escaping at the same time just didn't seem right to me...it was wayyy too convenient for madara

 

[The Work]

Bring Rin back to life

Leave Obito speechless

 

[Senju Bean]

No but it should. If Obito is butthurt about Rin, then it would be a sad disappointment

Good story telling requires villains to be complex and unyielding.

One of the best villains I have seen is Sinobu Sensui from YuYu Hakusho. A character that has attained power through divine conviction.

Obito right now is a demi god. He is also the final villain. As such, his character should be very complex. His desire to destroy the world should be a divine judgment. A good way would be to have Obito to not care about Rin anymore. He only cares about righting a wrong commited on him. A wrong done by the very world he lives in. He realizes that if he exists, and can only exist once, then he has a right to not live in a shitty world. A right robbed from him by reality. He develops a Solipcist view of the world, explaining his mass murdering activities. He doesn’t’ care about helping others with his genjutsu. He holds each and every entity of this hell he lives in responsible. But he also realizes that the only way to correct it is to completely erase his memories of the trauma as if it never happened: i.e The genjustu is there to bring him back to the way life was, with Rin in it. Only then, can the problem be fixed and his war against this corrupt world be won.

He only cares about the good memories of Rin simply because it makes him happy. He doesn’t care about the actual Rin at all.

Now that is a villain with complex motives. Again, look up Sensui. He is a model villain.

 

[King-Panda]

really liked your theory, but how are you going to explain this (don't worry, real short):

You must be registered for see links

And I think your theory is better than mine, where I mentioned Shisui and his father

You must be registered for see links

edit:

Obito already had close eyes on Nagato, so it's out of the question that he could of brought her back. You've also got to consider the fact that he probably had no idea who Rin was.

Mate, Madara had everything planned. There's a part where even Zetsu says: I can see why now Madara has chosen you! Do you really think Madara would ask Obito to join him just like that? he needed a plan to make him a psychopath

 

[Mitarashi]

really liked your theory, but how are you going to explain this (don't worry, real short):

You must be registered for see links

And I think your theory is better than mine, where I mentioned Shisui and his father

You must be registered for see links

edit:



Mate, Madara had everything planned. There's a part where even Zetsu says: I can see why now Madara has chosen you! Do you really think Madara would ask Obito to join him just like that? he needed a plan to make him a psychopath

Madara is the 'Evil genius' of NV ( Along with Orochimaru of course )

 

[ObitoGokuKakashi]

Nice Theory! It's possible ... but I'm not sure, what is the purpose of fighting Hashirama than? :erm:

 

[Mitarashi]

Nice Theory! It's possible ... but I'm not sure, what is the purpose of fighting Hashirama than? :erm:

Madara is one of the most powerful people to have ever roamed the NV, Hashirama is his rival, they were friends and Hashirama keeps beating him, Despite Madara having the 'Ultimate occular jutsu'

Now that he has Rinnegan, He wants nothing more than to test his might, against a worth opponent ;p

 

[ObitoGokuKakashi]

Madara is one of the most powerful people to have ever roamed the NV, Hashirama is his rival, they were friends and Hashirama keeps beating him, Despite Madara having the 'Ultimate occular jutsu'

Now that he has Rinnegan, He wants nothing more than to test his might, against a worth opponent ;p

That might be true. But let's see what happens in the following Chapters. =D

 

[Mitarashi]

That might be true. But let's see what happens in the following Chapters. =D

Definitly Nice chatting with you.

 

[Byron123]

That's an interesting thought but you need to elaborate on it, a lot. For instance from the way you wrote it, I can't understand whether or not you're implying that Rin was ever an existent person or a zetsu all along. Because if it's the second, that doesn't make sense since zetsu have to imitate somebody existent. Also who implies here that Madara had used rinnei tensei.

 

[Mitarashi]

That's an interesting thought but you need to elaborate on it, a lot. For instance from the way you wrote it, I can't understand whether or not you're implying that Rin was ever an existent person or a zetsu all along. Because if it's the second, that doesn't make sense since zetsu have to imitate somebody existent. Also who implies here that Madara had used rinnei tensei.

What I'm trying to say is,
The Rin that Kakashi killed was a Zetsu, Madara or zetsu captured the real rin before that occured.