[Theory] Jewelry Bonney, Akainu, Portgas D. Ace and Portgas D. Rogue relationships!

[WhistleBlower]

THIS THEORY IS NOT MINE

So I checked out the search and could not find anything on this theory so I just wanted to speculate.

I will update the theory from comments and thoughts of my own.


WHAT IF...


Jewelry Bonney is a daughter of Akainu?
Ace and Bonney are siblings

How would it be possible?

Well we have had nice hints for it through the manga.
First we have this:

You must be registered for see images

Bonney and Akainu confrontation.

• 
  [*=center]Why would Bonney even say such thing as not forgiving? It has to matter to Akainu.
  [*=center]Why would Akainu keep her so close and have a eye on her?

• 
  [*=center]Why would Bonney get so upset over the Marine Ford War.
  

So story is like this:

Portgas D. Rouge is mother of Ace and Bonney

Bonney is daughter of Akainu. Roger is Aces father!

Akainu loved Portgas D. Rouge but Roger took her from him.

Akainu wants to get rid of Ace cause he reminds him of Portgas D. Rouge and Rogers love.



We can see the desperation of Akainu when he constantly is hunting for Ace int he Marine Ford.
Akainu just wants to get rid of all that associates with Roger.

He even goes so berserk he almost kills Coby ( a fellow marine ).

You must be registered for see images

How are Porgas D. Ace and Jewelry bonney

You must be registered for see links

and sister?

Well first of we can see a lot of personality similarities.

You must be registered for see images

Both have open and fearful personalities

Both like to party and eat a lot

Both have huge sets of crew manship

Both talk with same manere

Their age difference is 2 years... Bonney is older so this holds up!

They even have facial similarities.


In conclusion Bonney knew the story of Akainu and Rogue but Ace did not. How Could he? Roger was long gone. Akainu wanted to get rid of the that gives him huge discomfort and bad memories. He just wanted to rip Ace apart.
In the end Bonney was bad on Akainu cause she knew that he killed Ace just for revenge.

I even think Garp knew... Thats why he called Akainu a bastard. He knew that he did this for his personal matters not for the Marines.

You must be registered for see images

We also have this:

You must be registered for see images

So here we can see Bonney getting really worked up because of Blackbeard who caught Ace in the first place.

So they go into the New World do get revenge on Blackbeard.
But it just does not work out that well...

You must be registered for see images

​

AGAIN THIS THEORY IS NOT MINE, HOWEVER I AGREE IT HAS INCONSISTENCIES BUT STILL VERY INTERESTING xd​

 

[Hypemaster]

Interesting indeed, never in my lifetime would I have thought of this. Though I'm not completely convinced, I'd like to be proven wrong as it'll make for a great plot addition.

 

[Aomine]

Hmm i dont think bonney and ace are related, but what i do think is that bonney is the daughter of someone important, maybe from the world goverment. She experienced something she found unfair or something like that, maybe she saw the cruelty of the world goverment in action and decided not to be like them and became a pirate instead. How else would she escape from akainu? XD

 

[nibilbhai]

Aah, no. It's just impossible. I don't think Eiichiro will let any women have 2 husbands in his Manga.

 

[ekichi onizuka]

what do yhink about this. Ace is luffy unborn child bc luffy is the reincarnation of roger

withbeard said somone will come and pick u he's D and luffy will name his son Ace in memory of his brother.

Luffy will get killed and history will repeat itself

 

[SAmIDeXtEr]

seems plausible hehehe

 

[Skull Knight]

ace and boney r not related.

 

[SAHAN1993]

nice one bro.but garp is the only one know about ace history from the first place.why akainu revenge rogers son.became rogers son is not ace fault may be bonny has a connection with him or WG superior that is why he doesn't kill her.

 

[Sherlock.]

We don't have year number in One Piece Verse....

So lets say for calculation purposes Ace died in the year 2000

Now at the time of Ace's Death....

Ace's Age - 20 (B'day on Jan 1)
Bonney's Age - 22 (B'day on Sept 1)

Bonney had completed 22 years of age and Ace was still 20....

So Ace's execution was somewhere in between 1st Septmber 2000 - 31 December 2000

So Bonney's DOB should be 1st Sept 1978 for her to be 22 at the time of Ace's execution....

Ace was born on 1st Jan 1980.... We know Rogue was pregnant for 20 months with Ace in her womb....

So she got pregnant with Ace in her womb somewhere around May 1978....

She didn't have both Ace and Bonney in her womb at the same time....

So this Theory is False....

 

[Mephew D Kensei]

Cool theory but some parts may be bit sketchy. I theorise it like Bonney was maybe on an island that was undersiege by maybe pirates and the marines(maybe under Akainu as a cpt or other lower rank) failed to assist but Shirohige came to the rescue and then she was WB as an idol and met Ace the rest of WB crew including Teach, so after Teach's betrayal she wants to avenge WB hence she hastily attacks BB that time but got defeated and handed to Akainu. Akainu knowing how much she believed in WB knows she won't forgive them(BB & him) for the hands they played in WB and Ace's deaths plus refusing her, her revenge on BB by arresting her.
And I'm not saying mine is perfect just put it out there for op fans to think about it

 

[Punk Hazard]

Aah, no. It's just impossible. I don't think Eiichiro will let any women have 2 husbands in his Manga.

Roger and Rouge weren't married, they were lovers.