[Theory] Luffy's Mother = Roger's sister?!!

[WhistleBlower]

Hey, peeps..wazzup!!?? LMAO XD

-----------------

I found this theory on another website. Tell me what youse think yeah. Remember. NOT MY THEORY!!!

Luffy's mother

You must be registered for see images

I have one out there

You must be registered for see links

as to who Luffy's mother could be. I don't know if it is right, but I do have some manga evidence to help support my theory.

I think that is possible that Luffy's mother is Gol D. Roger's sister. I think that the pirate

You must be registered for see links

is related to Luffy, in some way. There have been many instances that Luffy has been directly compared to Roger. Some of the more convincing bits is theyr similar abilities. In some chapters of One Piece Luffy was compared to Roger, saying that Luffy had the same power as Roger. Having the same power is help to convince me they are realated and that it is a familly trait.

If someone told me that Ace, Roger, and Luffy were all related, I would believe them. All three of them have similar personalities and temperments, which run in famillies. They also have a similar appearance. Black hair, that smile, and body type. I still think Luffy looks more like Roger than Dragon, but Luffy does look like he is Dragon's son too.

If Luffy's mother was Roger's sister that would

You must be registered for see links

two things mysteries in One Piece. One is it would explain Dragon's motivation to over throw the world government. The second would be why Luffy's mother has not been in One Piece. Luffy's mother is missing for one of two reasons she is dead or she is hiding. If she is dead, I would bet money that she was killed by someone from the world government for being related to Roger. If they went after Tom for building a boat, then they would definatly go after someone who was related to Roger. Ace was publicaly excuted not because he is a pirate (he just would have been imprisioned in Impel Down otherwise) but because he was the son of Gol D. Roger. If she was killed or forced to hide, that would be Dragon's reason for becoming a revolutionary. It would also explain Dragon's feeling for him wanting Luffy to "live free".

Well it might not be right, but it is something to think about.

 

[Sherlock.]

Sounds Cool....

 

[Javaweb]

That would make him related to Ace but he's not

 

[alex11]

wrong... i believe luffyy looks more like dragon...and that goes for garp too they all look alike and have the same smile

 

[the big boss]

this theory is soo old lol

 

[Borin123]

They are all related. The "D" connects them all. Tho nice theory, could be true

 

[Braveknight]

i do agree about the motivation of dragon that it might be his wife's death that made him go against goverment

BUT

have same smile or power does not prove he is linked to roger

 

[Lt Fresh]

Its all the 'D'. IMO that is what relates them and that's why people say they have similar power. The Will of the D is power

 

[Nakamazi Itchigo]

I believe it, very convincing..certainly would explain why Dragon is a revolutionary indeed

 

[ANiMUS]

I think it was said in the anime that it was Ace's mom that was somehow related to Garp and besides that everyone related of affiliated with Roger was killed by the World Government.

 

[SAHAN1993]

if u think about their ages this is not a good theory.whe gol d roger die his age is 37 if he live he is 60+ mokey d garp is nearly same age as roger.dragon is 15+ years younger than roger.but nice post thanks for sharing mate.

 

[~Yubel~]

Roger is about the same age as Garp. Dragon is his son, it would be a little strange for him to marry Roger's sister.

 

[Olorin]

Roger is about the same age as Garp. Dragon is his son, it would be a little strange for him to marry Roger's sister.

no he wasn't

Garp had a 17 year old grandson when Gol D Roger had a 20 year old son

I think they had more or less a Luffy (Roger) and Smoker (Garp) age difference, Smoker is 17 years older than Luffy

you don't have to be the same age to be part of the same era, Luffy is 19 while Blackbeard is 40

if u think about their ages this is not a good theory.whe gol d roger die his age is 37 if he live he is 60+ mokey d garp is nearly same age as roger.dragon is 15+ years younger than roger.but nice post thanks for sharing mate.

you know what you just wrote? You wrote that Garp had a son when he was about 15, 16 years old, which, considering he was probably a lot like Luffy and this is a Shonen, is completely impossible

 

[OfficialRikudouSennin]

sounds legit

 

[Netferarri]

Hope it true!!!!!!!!!=D

 

[SAHAN1993]

are u kidding me ur calculation wrong bro.roger age when he die=37 after 22 years ace age 22(2 years ts) if roger lives his age is 59.dragan current age 40-45.dragon smoker and current admirals are same time rivals.may be dragon married older women. Lol

 

[thegame]

No way. Anyone affiliated with Roger should have been killed. So unless you suggest the government didn't know...

However, the reason you compare Luffy to Roger is because of the will of the D. But if you look at Teach, he is the exact same as Luffy. He is just "evil" or bad mouthing things in stead of being amazed all the time. However, his carelessness and fearlessness is completely the same.

Luffy has his D from his father and grandfather. Most likely not his mother. It would be rather pointless tbh..

 

[Olorin]

No way. Anyone affiliated with Roger should have been killed. So unless you suggest the government didn't know...

However, the reason you compare Luffy to Roger is because of the will of the D. But if you look at Teach, he is the exact same as Luffy. He is just "evil" or bad mouthing things in stead of being amazed all the time. However, his carelessness and fearlessness is completely the same.

Luffy has his D from his father and grandfather. Most likely not his mother. It would be rather pointless tbh..

hes not he shit his pants when he was fighting WB

 

[thegame]

hes not he shit his pants when he was fighting WB

Well, I still think it wasn't sincere fear of death. It was more a trick to stop WB, because Teach once was his son, after all. I know the anime made it look like he was shitting his pants tho, yet he didn't fear death in other situations, like when they fell from that up-going current when the strawhats entered skypeia. And when he was all swallowed up in Magellans poison, I didn't see much fear either, although he seemed to know he was gonna die from it.. But go watch the first time Teach and Luffy met each other. The similarities are just amazingly portrayed.

 

[ArabianLuffy]

this theory is soo old lol

Since 2008, maybe?

I discussed this topic long ago. I have nothing to add.