[Debate] Bogard vs Prince Charles

Bogard

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Reaction score
2,378
Jiraya(Bogard) vs Itachi(Prince Charles)

Location: Sannin battle
Knowledge: Manga
Restrictions: None
Judges: Biju Naruto, Lilt, AncientCenturion, Kages

Edit: We decided to add AncientCenturion and Kages as judges and Prince Charles will do the OP
 
Last edited:

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
*UPDATE* ancientcentrion is a judge now so bogard so much editing and ill start off.
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
You guys already know what the deal is, IM TURNT UP~

Ill start off very basic but very informative. Jiraiya using katon techniques in this match will be very useless considering Itachi himself has already shown enough fire power of his own to fend off or counter Jiraiyas Katon with the use of which is more than enough to counters Jiraiyas katon base techniques. Also a different alternative to countering jiraiyas katon is simply copying his own katon with the sharigans predictive abilities. We are all aware of the fact that sharigan can predict the enemies move via handseal as shown against zabuzu when kakashi copied his Suiton technique perfectly[ ][ ][ ] Now in Itachi's case he will be doing the jutsu much more faster due to his amazing hand seal speed as praised by kurenai and kakashi.[ ]

he will know when Jiraiya is pulling off a katon base technique ( one that doesnt require gamabunta obviously but jman himself) and instantly copy it with his sharigan and perform it faster at jiraiya with his hand seal speed praised so much.

Counter to Jmans toad flame bullet.The technique shown is presented in the scan[ ]

I believe a legit counter to this would Amaterasu as shown in the manga fire simply fuels Amaterasu making larger and powerful and will turn fire back at jiraiya injuring him and gamabunta. I will provide the scan supporting my claim flames fueling amaterasu[ ]

Jirayas toads should be no problem here
Honestly a small portion of amaterasu should be enough to injure the toads and cease movement.

A simple genjutsu honestly pretty much ends this.
As shown in the hallway in part 1 even having knowledge on Itachi being a powerful Uchiha and having the sharigan activated at that moment he still stupidly makes eye to eye contact with him.[ ] Idk if he was being arrogant or over confident. Either way it just goes to show vulnerable Jiraiya is to itachis genjutsu which is a pretty much decider in this fight.A simple tysukuyomi will and can end this fight very easily. One can argue that Jiraiya will now know not to look into itachis eyes.

Even so this will be utterly useless as seeing Itachi has been shown to be able to use his crow summoning to put people under genjutsu.[ ][ ] Jiraiya has no knowledge that itachi crows can use genjutsu so he will utterly fall victim to it and get decapitated while under the genjutsu. This is really important, one should note that it was actually a clone that put naruto under that genjutsu with the use of crows.[ ] This shows how itachi utilizes his clones to put people in genjutsu, with his fast hand seal speed he can easily make multiple crow clones and use them as a way to put jiraiya under a genjutsu and Itachi will cease the moment to kill jiraiya while his under the genjutsu.

Even if jiraiya manages to enter sm, the only useful move would be to use Frog song but its too flawed.stated by Pa the frog song takes a considerable amount of time to take effect and it gives away their location if jiraiya and them plan on doing it from a secure location on jiraiya[ ]

and when i say considerable time i actually quite a while as shown against the pains. Here is when the frog songs starts.[ ]

Through all this is when the frog song actually takes effect in sequence, i skip no pages.[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ]

All the scans i provided 1-10 show the frog tech first taking place to the moment where it finally takes effect, it simply takes too long. One could argue it took longer because it was being used on more than one enemy which seems plausible but thats merely an assumption. Manga shows the frog song simply takes too long which will leave jiraiya vulnerable for a amaterasu.
 
Last edited:

Curse Mark

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
7,750
Reaction score
204
No way anything in Itachi's arsenal can counter Jiraiya and Bunta's combined fire+oil jutsu. It's the biggest katon in the series thusfar.
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
No way anything in Itachi's arsenal can counter Jiraiya and Bunta's combined fire+oil jutsu. It's the biggest katon in the series thusfar.

Mate have some respect and refrain from commenting.
 

Curse Mark

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
7,750
Reaction score
204
Mate have some respect and refrain from commenting.

No one ever specified that comments weren't welcome. I simply commented on a thread in the versus threads and offered my opinion. I didn't break any rules. I didn't do anything wrong. I merely commented on a thread which is basically the sole purpose for anyone to be on here..
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
No one ever specified that comments weren't welcome. I simply commented on a thread in the versus threads and offered my opinion. I didn't break any rules. I didn't do anything wrong. I merely commented on a thread which is basically the sole purpose for anyone to be on here..

Its obviously between me and bogard... i see common sense isnt common anymore? your comment wasnt needed. case closed.
 

Draphsin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
14,296
Reaction score
1,200
No one ever specified that comments weren't welcome. I simply commented on a thread in the versus threads and offered my opinion. I didn't break any rules. I didn't do anything wrong. I merely commented on a thread which is basically the sole purpose for anyone to be on here..

Dude its still a matter of respect, is your name in the debate thread?
 

Curse Mark

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
7,750
Reaction score
204
Dude its still a matter of respect, is your name in the debate thread?

No but that doesn't mean I can't comment. Is your name in the title of every single thread you offer your opinion in?
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
Bogard your taking quite a while... do i sense defeat?
 

Draphsin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
14,296
Reaction score
1,200
No but that doesn't mean I can't comment. Is your name in the title of every single thread you offer your opinion in?

:|

I dont comment in debate threads between two people. Other threads are open for opinions, while this thread clearly has the names of the people participating......
 

Curse Mark

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
7,750
Reaction score
204
:|

I dont comment in debate threads between two people. Other threads are open for opinions, while this thread clearly has the names of the people participating......

Considering Prince Charles and I already sorted it out I really don't have anything to say to you. Eventually you'll learn that you can't always expect people to follow rules. Especially un-said imaginary rules that suit only one side of something.
 

Draphsin

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 12, 2012
Messages
14,296
Reaction score
1,200
Considering Prince Charles and I already sorted it out I really don't have anything to say to you. Eventually you'll learn that you can't always expect people to follow rules. Especially un-said imaginary rules that suit only one side of something.

Funny how I got a rep from charles for telling you to not bother posting in this thread *_*

& its not rules, its respect, do you want people to take you seriously on this forum? Then thats where it starts...
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
Ohh shit when i was already almost at the end of my rebutal, my computer stopped working for no reasons and i was forced to restart it again so i lost all the arguments -_- Now i'm typing with my phone wtf

lol :cool: take your time xd
 

Prince Charles

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
12,456
Reaction score
1,326
Funny how I got a rep from charles for telling you to not bother posting in this thread *_*

& its not rules, its respect, do you want people to take you seriously on this forum? Then thats where it starts...

:devil: lets all be friends? because you know... YOLO? xd
 

Curse Mark

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Nov 24, 2012
Messages
7,750
Reaction score
204
Funny how I got a rep from charles for telling you to not bother posting in this thread *_*

& its not rules, its respect, do you want people to take you seriously on this forum? Then thats where it starts...

And I got a rep from Charles saying that it didn't matter.
Lmao this is the internet... Why would I want your respect?
You must be registered for see images
 

Bogard

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Reaction score
2,378
Ill start off very basic but very informative. Jiraiya using katon techniques in this match will be very useless considering Itachi himself has already shown enough fire power of his own to fend off or counter Jiraiyas Katon with the use of which is more than enough to counters Jiraiyas katon base techniques.


Also a different alternative to countering jiraiyas katon is simply copying his own katon with the sharigans predictive abilities. We are all aware of the fact that sharigan can predict the enemies move via handseal as shown against zabuzu when kakashi copied his Suiton technique perfectly[ ][ ][ ] Now in Itachi's case he will be doing the jutsu much more faster due to his amazing hand seal speed as praised by kurenai and kakashi.[ ]

he will know when Jiraiya is pulling off a katon base technique ( one that doesnt require gamabunta obviously but jman himself) and instantly copy it with his sharigan and perform it faster at jiraiya with his hand seal speed praised so much.

Counter to Jmans toad flame bullet.The technique shown is presented in the scan[ ]

I believe a legit counter to this would Amaterasu as shown in the manga fire simply fuels Amaterasu making larger and powerful and will turn fire back at jiraiya injuring him and gamabunta. I will provide the scan supporting my claim flames fueling amaterasu[ ]

Jirayas toads should be no problem here
Honestly a small portion of amaterasu should be enough to injure the toads and cease movement.

A simple genjutsu honestly pretty much ends this.
As shown in the hallway in part 1 even having knowledge on Itachi being a powerful Uchiha and having the sharigan activated at that moment he still stupidly makes eye to eye contact with him.[ ] Idk if he was being arrogant or over confident. Either way it just goes to show vulnerable Jiraiya is to itachis genjutsu which is a pretty much decider in this fight.A simple tysukuyomi will and can end this fight very easily. One can argue that Jiraiya will now know not to look into itachis eyes.

Even so this will be utterly useless as seeing Itachi has been shown to be able to use his crow summoning to put people under genjutsu.[ ][ ] Jiraiya has no knowledge that itachi crows can use genjutsu so he will utterly fall victim to it and get decapitated while under the genjutsu. This is really important, one should note that it was actually a clone that put naruto under that genjutsu with the use of crows.[ ] This shows how itachi utilizes his clones to put people in genjutsu, with his fast hand seal speed he can easily make multiple crow clones and use them as a way to put jiraiya under a genjutsu and Itachi will cease the moment to kill jiraiya while his under the genjutsu.

Even if jiraiya manages to enter sm, the only useful move would be to use Frog song but its too flawed.stated by Pa the frog song takes a considerable amount of time to take effect and it gives away their location if jiraiya and them plan on doing it from a secure location on jiraiya[ ]

and when i say considerable time i actually quite a while as shown against the pains. Here is when the frog songs starts.[ ]

Through all this is when the frog song actually takes effect in sequence, i skip no pages.[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ].[ ]

All the scans i provided 1-10 show the frog tech first taking place to the moment where it finally takes effect, it simply takes too long. One could argue it took longer because it was being used on more than one enemy which seems plausible but thats merely an assumption. Manga shows the frog song simply takes too long which will leave jiraiya vulnerable for a amaterasu.
Rebutal​

Genjutsu counters

First of all, i'd like to point out the fact that all Itachi's genjutsu are made in close range battle. Whether it is against , against , or against

This is also confirmed by the databook

Databook2 said:
NINJUTSU; KEKKEI GENKAI; Tsukuyomi
User: Uchiha Itachi
Supplementary; Close range; Rank: none

So for Itachi to actually even start thinking about puting Jiraya in a genjutsu, it would have to happen in a close range battle. Here is where the problem begins since Jiraya is a long range fighter using and abusing of his superior ninjutsu
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Or summons

You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Jiraya being a long range fighter, Itachi would have difficuties to find opportunities to place Jiraya in a genjutsu and take advantage of it.

Also, contrary to the popular belief, Kai release can break out of any genjutsus including Itachi's. The reason why Itachi's tsukuyomi is unbreakable is not because of the power of it, but because it takes time in few seconds, so not giving time to the opponent to use kai release and break it. Now it depends on the users skills while using the kai release method. Like Jiraya said, to break genjutsu, you must try your best to stop your chakra flow . Doing that will break any genjutsu. That's .

Jiraya , the one he used on a woman to distract him, something that Itachi noticed, which shows he is skilfull in breaking genjutsus

Naruto for example was capable to break that Itachi gave, but still wasn't able to overcome the genjutsu completely. The reason behind this, Itachi already gave it himself. It's because he . That again shows that a more skilful kai release user could have broken Itachi's genjutsu completely

Another example is the Orochimaru vs Itachi battle. Itachi managed to put Orochimaru in . Since Kai release needs both hands to be together to be performed, it's for that reason Orochimaru struggled to break it. But Orochimaru could have broken it if he managed to put his hands together in time. He was already close to it even. It's for that reason that

So like you can see, breaking Itachi's genjutsu isn't impossible at all, far from it actually. Depends now on the opponents skills in using the kai release method. But in general, genjutsu is used to create a diversion for a following attack, not to defeat the enemy

Those are the reasons why i believe that Jiraya could have broken Itachi's genjutsu if necessary. He has already shown the skill even. But would Itachi allow it to happen? That's probably where the real debate is

Anyway, like Jiraya also said, if yourself is incapable to break a genjutsu, . Jiraya always starts battles with summons as partners [ ] [ ] [

So even if either of them was caught in a genjutsu at some point, the other will make him free from it exactly like a Jinchuriki's method for example. Gamabunta has shown the capacity , so he could use this method that would break Jiraya free from it and vice verse

Those are the main reasons why i believe genjutsu won't be an issue in this fight

Ninjutsu superiority

Jiraya is one of the most skilful ninjutsu user in the entire manga. Minato even said he thinks . During their encounter in part1 even, both Itachi and Kisame were that they were already trapped by Jiraya's jutsu from the start, which could be considered as a testament of Jiraya's skilful use of ninjutsu

Here is where the problem begins since Jiraya is a long range fighter using and abusing of his superior ninjutsu
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Or summons

You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Talking about summons, my opponent forgot to talk about Gamabunta's help here. His suiton weree huge enough to even counter Shukaku's high level of fuuton technique(see above), so it will render Itachi's use of Katons meaningless and more importantly, Jiraya will even take advantage of it in the ninjutsu battle

Not only that, but like my opponent stated, Jiraya could also use combo attacks as powerful . Just to make you remember, , but himself look like shit compared to this jutsu. So Itachi won't survive if he receives an attack of this scale and unfortunately for him, he doesn't possess the ninjutsu arsenal to counter or even evade it

Jiraya also has high level of long range attacks thanks to his hair, capable to easily destroy huge summons
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Those are the reasons why i believe Jiraya would totally dominate the ninjutsu battle

How does Jiraya counters Amaterasu:

Jman already has . So he would be really cautious if he were to fight Itachi. Contrary to the popular belief, amaterasu is a that appears instantly withing a certain range, and from there begins the target(it's the reason why eventhough it almost appeared on Raikage, he had time to shunshin out of the way) and depending on where the user focuses. What i mean by that is that if a target is outside the range of amaterasu, it would be easier for him to notice it and therefore counter it with something in his arsenal. Sasuke for example was able during a while and use a to counter the jutsu. Killer-Bee also used a subtitution when he had no knowledge on the jutsu, and with knowledge he has shown that it was even able before he uses Amaterasu(which shows btw that Amaterasu needs some time of concentration to be released)

Jiraya who even already has knowledge on the jutsu. During the time Amaterasu would be released, he could use to protect himself and even at Itachi after that with his needle Senbon. Other method could be (burning a KB is useless).

Also, even without knowledge in part1, he directly created a counter for it in an instant with a

How does Jiraya counter Susanoo:

Gaara helped us to know that . Well, Jiraya has a perfect counter for this with (Jiraya even said it was ). It would totally make sink Itachi in this position with or without his Susanoo

If they are fighting in an enclosed area, Jiraya could capture him(Susanoo or not) in like he already did in part1. He can also create an opening to capture him in the like he did against Pain

Sasuke made us understand because of sound vibration. Well, Pa and Ma have (able to paralyse Pain summons). With this jutsu, it would be easy for SM Jiraya to paralyse Itachi and finish him either with his or or even something else in his arsenal.

We also know thanks to Kabuto, that , so Pa and Ma use this and he is done for:
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

Stamina advantage:

Jiraya undoubtely has the stamina advantage since his chakra was huge enough to even allow him to use Sage Mode. He was spamming techniques since he entered Pain's territory and i never saw him run out of stamina in the entire manga. On the contrary, most of Itachi's powerful techniques take a lot of tole on his body. with more than and use of it greatly. It also gives the opportunity to the opponent to take advantage of it and finish him off

Jiraya wins :scorps:
 
Last edited:
Top