Yes Just because some one has a weird view of a topic in the show and manga it's automatically a troll thread...
Not even weird, more like alternative.
OT: one by one : Itachi: Double agent, working for the good guys. Not much too say
.
Nagato: Even though peace was his target, he had a really violent way to go for it. He is more like a terrorist, where he tries to achieve piece by killing thousands of people. He can be considered good only after his talk with Naruto.
Kisame: He also was fighting for an ideal , like Nagato , and he had really violent ways of doing so too. Wouldn't really call him agood guy, only maybe deep deep inside. We don't know about his really past (childhood) so he might have motives.
Tobito: Good turned bad. Classic. His logic is now flawed and twisted, and works to achieve a dreamworld where there will be only piece and he will be back with Rin. Probably good deep inside, but right now he can't be called good.
Deidara: Really cool guy (one of my faves), was forced to join, works pretty much for him self and his art. Neither "good" or "bad"
Sasori: Good turned bad through anger. Later turned good again, thanks mainly to Chiyo.
Kakuzu: Ruthless Mercanary. So, bad.
Konan: Same with Nagato.
Zetsu: Unknown own motives, simply following Madara/Obito
Hidan: Killing for fun, no known further motives. Wouldn't call him good.
Orochimaru: Ridiculously twisted villain for the first part, now more toned down. Left the akatsuki , which doesn't really say much.
Can't be called good
Pre-Akatsukis (eg Yahiko): Fought against Hanzo and others for piece in the land of Rain.So, good.
Score, based on the character last time we saw him:
Good/Unknown or Neutral/Bad :5/2/5