Could Minato escape a black hole?

[MadaIzuBros1224]

Well, if we are only talking about the event horizon's gravitational pull that makes everything inside not able to escape, and we ignore the fact that the huge one sided pressure and other factors wouldn't kill him, then yes. He would be able to escape simply because he is using something called "Quantum Tunneling". It is not actual "tunneling" but is the instantaneous movement between one space and the other with no time. FTG is a "faster-than-light" technique, but it does not break any fundamental laws of physics, as there is no actual movement going on. He breaks physics to begin with, as there is no such thing as physical teleportation. But yeah, in short, we can escape the huge gravitational pull from a black hole with FTG.

The black hole might be able to crush his chakra(since it can bend even light), so he might not be able to use FTG. Also, I'm not really sure what would be faster, him teleporting out? Or the gravitational force killing him?

 

[olumiday]

Tobi's kamui is similar to a black hole pull, yet he escaped it.
A black hole is also, in some way similar to Chibaku Tensei, so IMO Minato escapes.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

The black hole might be able to crush his chakra(since it can bend even light), so he might not be able to use FTG. Also, I'm not really sure what would be faster, him teleporting out? Or the gravitational force killing him?

FTG doesn't take up chakra and if it does he won't need it since he has kunai's and seals all around the village so yes he could survive.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Tobi's kamui is similar to a black hole pull, yet he escaped it.
A black hole is also, in some way similar to Chibaku Tensei, so IMO Minato escapes.

This.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Gin-San]

The black hole might be able to crush his chakra(since it can bend even light), so he might not be able to use FTG. Also, I'm not really sure what would be faster, him teleporting out? Or the gravitational force killing him?

Well your question was if he could escape the "inescapable" pull of gravity by the black hole upon entering the black hole, ignoring many, and I mean, many factors that are going there. FTG can escape the black hole simply because it is a haxed jutsu capable of bending space and time making quantum tunneling with physical bodies possible. FTG is not possible in real life, as there cannot be physical teleport (Due the mass of a body increasing to infinity as they approach light speed). Though bodies cannot obtain light speed, it is possible to bend space/time around you to go faster-than-light (postulated by Alcubierre). Seriously, FTG is completely broken, as quantum tunneling of such potential would sent Minato back to the past (which he may be doing, as far as we know).

Now, if you ask me what is faster, the gravitational pull or FTG, then that is just pure science fiction and cannot be answered. I gave you the simple answer without any other factor on it. Theorically, we don't know how long it would take to reach super-singularity, as the black hole infinite density and size to matter for the equation, and equation that we don't have as far as I am concerned. If you wanted to be more specific, what kind of black hole? static? Kerr? lol.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

I don't hate Minato(he's actually one of my favorites), I was just thinking up a hypothetical situation where he could survive in space.

LOL! You answered your own question, if he could get to a black hole then he could survive in space.

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

Well your question was if he could escape the "inescapable" pull of gravity by the black hole upon entering the black hole, ignoring many, and I mean, many factors that are going there. FTG can escape the black hole simply because it is a haxed jutsu capable of bending space and time making quantum tunneling with physical bodies possible. FTG is not possible in real life, as there cannot be physical teleport (Due the mass of a body increasing to infinity as they approach light speed). Though bodies cannot obtain light speed, it is possible to bend space/time around you to go faster-than-light (postulated by Alcubierre). Seriously, FTG is completely broken, as quantum tunneling of such potential would sent Minato back to the past (which he may be doing, as far as we know).

Now, if you ask me what is faster, the gravitational pull or FTG, then that is just pure science fiction and cannot be answered. I gave you the simple answer without any other factor on it. Theorically, we don't know how long it would take to reach super-singularity, as the black hole infinite density and size to matter for the equation, and equation that we don't have as far as I am concerned. If you wanted to be more specific, what kind of black hole? static? Kerr? lol.

I see what you said. I guess there just isn't a true answer to this question.

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

If he crosses point of horizon than no since that is when even light can't escape but before that yes

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Well your question was if he could escape the "inescapable" pull of gravity by the black hole upon entering the black hole, ignoring many, and I mean, many factors that are going there. FTG can escape the black hole simply because it is a haxed jutsu capable of bending space and time making quantum tunneling with physical bodies possible. FTG is not possible in real life, as there cannot be physical teleport (Due the mass of a body increasing to infinity as they approach light speed). Though bodies cannot obtain light speed, it is possible to bend space/time around you to go faster-than-light (postulated by Alcubierre). Seriously, FTG is completely broken, as quantum tunneling of such potential would sent Minato back to the past (which he may be doing, as far as we know).

Now, if you ask me what is faster, the gravitational pull or FTG, then that is just pure science fiction and cannot be answered. I gave you the simple answer without any other factor on it. Theorically, we don't know how long it would take to reach super-singularity, as the black hole infinite density and size to matter for the equation, and equation that we don't have as far as I am concerned. If you wanted to be more specific, what kind of black hole? static? Kerr? lol.

Please don't bring real science into Naruto of course it wouldn't make sense.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

If he crosses point of horizon than no since that is when even light can't escape but before that yes

FTG faster than light :3

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

LOL! You answered your own question, if he could get to a black hole then he could survive in space.

I was talking about him surviving regular space conditions, like no oxygen or pressure, not black hole conditions.

 

[Jobrjo]

Well, the moment he got in it he would be oblitereated. But if somehow he wasn't, then yes. Chakra is sorta like the "spirit" of someone in Naruto, not a physical attribute. Therefore, because it's intangible, it can't be sucked in by a black hole.
All theory of course. I don't know what Minato is doing in space...

 

[Micho22]

Ohaaa don't overdo it bkack hole no escape for no one

 

[Gin-San]

I see what you said. I guess there just isn't a true answer to this question.

Well, of course it can't be answered. lol

Please don't bring real science into Naruto of course it wouldn't make sense.

To a degree science can explain Naruto physics, it is just that Kishi really likes to make S/T very nonsensical xD

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

FTG faster than light :3

I am going by earth logic not NV because if I go by NV than he can escape since Kumai is some what like blackhole so i think he can escape

 

[sage1999]

im sorry but no. Black holes are so strong tht they traplight in. And light has the highest escape velocity. Eve if his ftg was stronger thn gravity, which i doubt, minato would be ripped to shreds the moment he enters. Even if he isnt ripped to shreds, the outward pull of the ftg and the gravatational pull of the black holes are likely to rip him. He would also be incinerated in there as the photos(light particles) would have its energy stored in 1 place and it would be really, really hot in there

 

[Reiki]

man.....the balck hole's are just gapes in the countinoum space time. when a star dies all the mase of the star gathers in one point creating a big densiti that makes a hole in the countinoum space time. the density there is too big. not even the speed of light can escape...and a human will be crushed in seconds becose let's be serious....no one can breathe out there, and the distance to a black hole is very big...i can say that is around 10 000 000 years light. could minato send his chakra all the way to the earth if he is at sunch big distance?

 

[MadaIzuBros1224]

im sorry but no. Black holes are so strong tht they traplight in. And light has the highest escape velocity. Eve if his ftg was stronger thn gravity, which i doubt, minato would be ripped to shreds the moment he enters. Even if he isnt ripped to shreds, the outward pull of the ftg and the gravatational pull of the black holes are likely to rip him. He would also be incinerated in there as the photos(light particles) would have its energy stored in 1 place and it would be really, really hot in there

Poor Minato, that sounds like torture.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Lol to the dumb@sses using earth logic, you can't do FTG in real life so that tells you you will never understand or get a real answer than makes sense enough for Naruto not earth logic i mean seriously.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

The thread total says survive a black hole, you didn't say regular space conditions and no one can survive in space -_- so this is a hate thread