Anime Forum

[Discussion] The Blackbeard Pirates vs The Straw Hat Pirates

KGB Kakuzu

KGB Kakuzu

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
12,448
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Got pretty bored today so I was wondering who will be facing who during the match-up of Blackbeard and Mugiwara!Though its still nearly impossible to decide, I've come up with a couple of match ups.

You must be registered for see images

Blackbeard Pirates from Left to Right: Blackbeard, Shiliew, Jesus Berger, Van Auger, Laffitte, Avalo Pizarro, Catelina Devon, Doc Q w/ his horse Stronger, Vasco Shot, and Sanjuan Wolf.

The match ups I envisioned are actually almost dead on for the most part except for Sanji, Franky, and Nami's who all you have to do is shift them one to the left (Sanji getting the person under Nami, Nami getting the person under Franky, and Franky getting the person under Sanji).




1. Obviously Blackbeard will fight Luffy

2. 99% Sure that Van Auger and Ussop will fight

3. Pretty sure Chopper will fight Doc Q

4. Zoro will fight either Laffitte or Shiliew

5. Sanji will end up fighting whoever of the two Zoro doesn't fight

6. Franky seems to have the same build up as Jesus Berger in attidtude and just being as were Berger seems like a wreslter, Franky was a boxer.

Pretty much after that it comes down to who knows...

7. Nami may fight Avalo Pizarro as he has some cat refrences (she's a cat-burgler)

8. If Jimbei joins he'll probably face off against Sanjuan Wolf

9. Robin will probably face off against Caterina Devon

10. Brook is left with Vasco Shot

Zoro and Sanji's fights are could end up very interesting....Laffitte to me seems to be the number 2 guy so I was leaning towards him being Zoro's enemy, but it is unclear whether he has a sword; hence, why Shiliew may be his enemy. But then I thought of something even more creative....what if it turns out that Laffitte is in fact a leg fighter similar to Sanji.

If so, Zoro may actually end up fighting Laffitte while Sanji fights Shiliew....it would be ironic as they always fight one another and here they are taking on opponents that easily represent their rivalvry!

On a lesser side note...kinda hoping Robin isn't stuck against Caterina as it just feels like she's being pawned off against the strongest female (only female) member of the Blackbeard Pirates where I personally feel she can fight someone stronger....of course assuming Devon is weaker than some of the other Blackbeard Pirates other than the Monster Trio's enemies.

What are your thoughts or what is your list?!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: repulse and KuroKaze
Souji

Souji

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
12,750
Kin
4💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I always thought Laffitte would go against Nami (they're both navigators anyway, so Role vs. Role would be good)

These are great matchups, but we should also take into account possible future crewmates BB and Luffy will have later on.
 
Hori

Hori

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
83,650
Kin
1,160💸
Kumi
27💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
KGB Kakuzu said:
Got pretty bored today so I was wondering who will be facing who during the match-up of Blackbeard and Mugiwara!Though its still nearly impossible to decide, I've come up with a couple of match ups.

1. Obviously Blackbeard will fight Luffy

2. 99% Sure that Van Auger and Ussop will fight

3. Pretty sure Chopper will fight Doc Q

4. Zoro will fight either Laffitte or Shiliew

5. Sanji will end up fighting whoever of the two Zoro doesn't fight

6. Franky seems to have the same build up as Jesus Berger in attidtude and just being as were Berger seems like a wreslter, Franky was a boxer.

Pretty much after that it comes down to who knows...

7. Nami may fight Avalo Pizarro as he has some cat refrences (she's a cat-burgler)

8. If Jimbei joins he'll probably face off against Sanjuan Wolf

9. Robin will probably face off against Caterina Devon

10. Brook is left with Vasco Shot

Zoro and Sanji's fights are could end up very interesting....Laffitte to me seems to be the number 2 guy so I was leaning towards him being Zoro's enemy, but it is unclear whether he has a sword; hence, why Shiliew may be his enemy. But then I thought of something even more creative....what if it turns out that Laffitte is in fact a leg fighter similar to Sanji.

If so, Zoro may actually end up fighting Laffitte while Sanji fights Shiliew....it would be ironic as they always fight one another and here they are taking on opponents that easily represent their rivalvry!

On a lesser side note...kinda hoping Robin isn't stuck against Caterina as it just feels like she's being pawned off against the strongest female (only female) member of the Blackbeard Pirates where I personally feel she can fight someone stronger....of course assuming Devon is weaker than some of the other Blackbeard Pirates other than the Monster Trio's enemies.

What are your thoughts or what is your list?!
Click to expand...
Good list Miss All Sunday. I wonder when will that fight occur.... anyway good list Lad.
 
KGB Kakuzu

KGB Kakuzu

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
12,448
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ausar said:
I always thought Laffitte would go against Nami (they're both navigators anyway, so Role vs. Role would be good)

These are great matchups, but we should also take into account possible future crewmates BB and Luffy will have later on.
Click to expand...
Yeah I thought about that too, and at first almost thought it was even better, but I felt Laffitte seemed to be the number 2 man to me....or at least the number 3! Hence why he was selected to elect Blackbeard as a Shichibukai!

EDIT: Yeah part of that was possible new recruits was Jimbei!!! Its almost impossible to predict what person BB would recruit XD, but we may also have Momonosuke and Kinemon to add to the Straw Hats....would be kinda funny if BB added two cowboys to the team....an East vs West fight (though Robin Pre-Timeskip would have been a nice match up for that possibility)!
 
Last edited:
shri3kbat

shri3kbat

Active member
Regular
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
953
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Nami won't fight Lafitte. Simply put, Lafitte is way too strong for her.

Luffy vs Blackbeard
Zoro vs Shiryu
Sanji vs Burgess or Lafitte
Franky vs Pizarro or Burgess
Robin vs Catarina
Brook vs Lafitte or someone else
Chopper vs Van Augur or Doc Q
Usopp vs Vasco Shot or Van Augur
Nami vs Doc Q or Vasco shot
 
Last edited:
KGB Kakuzu

KGB Kakuzu

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
12,448
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
shri3kbat said:
Nami won't fight Lafitte. Simply put, Lafitte is way too strong for her.

Luffy vs Blackbeard
Zoro vs Shiryu
Sanji vs Burgess or Lafitte
Franky vs Pizarro or Burgess
Robin vs Catarina
Brook vs Lafitte or someone else
Chopper vs Van Augur or Doc Q
Usopp vs Vasco Shot or Van Augur
Nami vs Doc Q or Vasco shot
Click to expand...
Oh is his name Shiryu...that'd make a lot more sense than the Shiliew....I didn't remember any names (except Laffitte and Doc Q who I remembered lol) so I just used the listed names from the OP Wiki.

Anyhow that's what I thought as far as Laffitte...he seems really strong. Really wished he could fight Robin as they both are kind of the Mysterious member of their crews, but I think he's Sanji or Zoro's opponent!
 
shri3kbat

shri3kbat

Active member
Regular
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
953
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
KGB Kakuzu said:
Oh is his name Shiryu...that'd make a lot more sense than the Shiliew....I didn't remember any names (except Laffitte and Doc Q who I remembered lol) so I just used the listed names from the OP Wiki.

Anyhow that's what I thought as far as Laffitte...he seems really strong. Really wished he could fight Robin as they both are kind of the Mysterious member of their crews, but I think he's Sanji or Zoro's opponent!
Click to expand...
The only ones I'm sure about are Zoro's and Luffy's matchups. Shiryu is gonna face Zoro for sure.
I think lining up the list of SH and BB from strongest to weakest would be a way to eliminate some matchups but unfortunately we don't know much about the strength of BB's crew at all, but
I definitely think the strongest are well obviously BB himself, Shiryu, Lafitte, Pizarro and then Van Augur, but it still makes sense for Usopp to fight Van Augur for example. Kinda impossible to know the matchups since we hardly know
what weapons the BB pirates use
 
KGB Kakuzu

KGB Kakuzu

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 20, 2012
Messages
12,448
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
shri3kbat said:
The only ones I'm sure about are Zoro's and Luffy's matchups. Shiryu is gonna face Zoro for sure.
I think lining up the list of SH and BB from strongest to weakest would be a way to eliminate some matchups but unfortunately we don't know much about the strength of BB's crew at all, but
I definitely think the strongest are well obviously BB himself, Shiryu, Lafitte, Pizarro and then Van Augur, but it still makes sense for Usopp to fight Van Augur for example. Kinda impossible to know the matchups since we hardly know
what weapons the BB pirates use
Click to expand...
Yeah that's exactly right! Without knowing the BB Crew its basically impossible to go on nothing, but what we know about a few, and just match up based on looks...

Was watching some OP the other day and saw back during Marineford when Shiryu went all swordsmen on some marines and was pretty sure that this was the swordsmen for Zoro....then was still thinking Laffitte with his cane could be a swordsmen, and I guess I just figured Laffitte was the number 2 man and a swordsmen so there we go. Then Sanji could finally defeat a swordsmen to prove his strength or something like that (in the sense that he can fight swordsmen).

What makes you put up Pizzaro so much just out of curiousity?!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top