Uhhh... Your topic is a bit misleading. Top 5 favorite GOTYs? Out of those 4 games you listed, only 1 has come out this year. Unless you mean our own personal GOTYs (which may or may not have gotten GOTY awards from critics), or if you meant games that had gotten GOTYs in the past years (in which Batman and Fallout have gotten), I suggest you change the topic to make it less confusing.
Anyways, as for me, my top 5 games so far this year will have to be... In no particular order, mind you
Uncharted: Golden Abyss for the PS Vita
Gravity Rush for the PS Vita
Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm Generations for the PS3 (Got the platinum in less than a month
)
Kid Icarus: Uprising for the Nintendo 3DS (which I haven't exactly finished yet due to my own inconsistency)
Disgaea 3 Absence of Detention for the PS Vita (it came out in 2008 on the PS3, but this Vita port came out this year)
Oh man, can't wait for KH: 3D and Pokemon Black 2/White 2 to come out here in the US
