[Question] Would you think Shiki>Garp?

[tyltyl]

It took both Senjoku and garp to take down Shiki. The fact that it took both of them would mean Shiki>Garp or would you think Sengoku was just there since it was Marine HQ. So would adding senjoku to go against Shiki was overkill and Garp could've soloed or could Shiki be stronger than garp?

(Shiki showed some feats in a One Piece film)

 

[Lilvic92]

Not sure BUT Luffy did solo Shiki sooooooooooooooo....Garp>Shiki

I'm a Luffy/Garp fanboy so my opinion mayyy be a BIT bias lol

 

[Reaper]

The fact Sengoku was there is related to both the fact it is the Marine HQ under attack and also that Shiki is a strong opponent just putting Garp there alone would be stupid and risky.Not saying he wouldnt win but taking risks under that situations is just a big no.

But I do think Garp > Shiki

 

[VongolaX]

Don't know how that movie worked but I know this for sure...

Shiki has more power through devil fruit, he can control islands and he used a a couple of mountains to one shot the strawhats. (really wasn't a all out fight).


Garp has a lot of physical strength, he was able to topple 8 mountains with his fist. (As much as Shiki lion mountains were produce to tko the straw hats).


Shiki has weak physical strength and a lot of power, while Garp is vice versa.

So garp (having more physical strength than luffy) could lay out Shiki.

Even Shiki can fly sky high (out of reach) and open the earth/water to swallow up Garp.


^^It all depends on the situation and the condition

Overall Garp>>Shiki

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Hard to say, until we see Shiki actually show up in the manga (if he does even) i'm going with Garp being stronger.

 

[Avinash012]

Garp is stronger but not by much.

 

[sravan]

garp is stronger i think