Would L and Kira/Light be able to figure out who Tobi was?

[Tera Path]

Well........ could they?

Edit: Could they maybe also figure out who was behind the akatsuki?
They also get sherlock holmes on their side.

 

[The Big Boss]

most of the readers figured it out, but kishi was just toying around

 

[Vandenreich]

Instantly. Kakashi's eye is a give away.

 

[Kαmi]

If they knew about Kakashi's eye, definitely. They would put two-and-two together like nothing.

 

[ElementNami92]

He's a genius. But Maybe..who knows? Most of the base knew.

 

[Joon]

It would be nothing to them. Everyone knew, but was in denial. Many thought Kishi was bring more to the table for minds how enjoy a mystery.

 

[XxLapizxLazulixX]

Depends. Nobody would have had a clue until one witnessed Obito using Kamui to warp.

 

[FitzChivalry Farseer]

Well Shikamaru that is a genius could not figure it out so I don't think Kira could do any better

 

[Tera Path]

Well Shikamaru that is a genius could not figure it out so I don't think Kira could do any better

I would rank Kira and L way above Shikamaru though.

But of course, this is only but my opinion.

 

[Bijuu Bomber]

If Sherlock Holmes was there then there would be no need for L or Kira...

 

[SoulKiller]

Well Shikamaru that is a genius could not figure it out so I don't think Kira could do any better

Are you comparing Shikamaru to Light yagami? Lol

@Topic : it would be nothing for Light yagami and L to figure out tobi identity.

 

[Sir Blades]

Probably so.

 

[-Punk-]

Let's put them in the forest when Kakashi noticed Tobis sharingan & ability. I can see L asking Kakashi "how did you got that eye again ? & that ability is the same as yours too .' then Light will just figure it out no diff . so yeah .

 

[Mypower]

Yeah they could in terms of intelligence
Death Note >>> Naruto

 

[Disquiet]

Yes they would. Obito told Kakashi that the kamui wouldn't work on him after Sasuke's fight with Danzo; and his eye's ability is similar to Kakashi's. He continued wearing a mask even after claiming to be Madara. Additionally, his physique and mobility is far superior to that of an 80+ year old man. Not even Mito (strong life and vitality) could keep up such a youthful appearance, so even with Senju DNA, it's unlikely Madara's could (and he didn't). So now they have an eye technique that resembles Kakashi's and a seemingly youthful body (compared to a would be 80 year old man), and even more the statement from Obito "That won't work on me." Of course, there's always the possibility that teleportation techniques shares the same dimension, but they have three (or was it four?) shinobi that is capable of utilizing the FTG. I can see them experimenting with that and Kakashi's kamui. After they inquire about Rin's death (if they didn't already know), they'll find out that Kakashi killed Rin; and Kakashi's promise to keep her safe. It's a motive to consider. As for Obito's pretense as Madara, even Tsunade realized the power in a name. Obito's surviving the boulder incident may be puzzling, but so would Madara's survival.

After collaborating with the hokage and doing some research, they may have even got the idea to have Kakashi read the Uchiha Tablet with his mangekyou (I wonder if this would work), which most likely reveals on how to obtain the rinnegan, info on the god tree, the sage etc. They will probably begin to suspect that Madara fought Hashirama to obtain this (Kabuto and Oro also came to suspect this even without reading the tablet). And they would know exactly the true goal of akatsuki.

The details of all Rikudou's jutsu is probably written on there as well, but more importantly, the Seventh Path. It has the ability to revive the dead. I wouldn't be surprised if they started picking apart Madara's plan from there.

I think at the very least, they would have always considered Obito as a possibility, and knew without a doubt once Obito started preaching to Kakashi (if they didn't circumvent his plans before then). Also, referring back to Obito's survival, it seems it was known that Hashirama was an excellent healer, after suspecting that Madara lived on through such means, it's not absurd to believe Obito did the same. Furthermore, the tablet speaks of traumatic experiences unlocking the MS (in the form of murdering a sibling), and Obito's 'disappearing' act is very convenient for such as that boulder occasion. It's almost like it was made for that lol.

Let's not forget that Kabuto and Oro managed to figure out a lot.

So yeah, there would definitely be lots of clues and methods at their fingertips.

 

[OMGitsShakra]

im not entirely sure how they would do it, but it would take seconds for them to figure it out with just a tiny bit of information. these guys make shikaku seem like average intelligence

 

[HiddenSound]

If given proper but minimal resources, they'd have Tobi cracked in about a couple days.

 

[GodOfThunderAndLightning]

No L and Light would have figured the whole plot of Naruto just by reading the Description then they would figure out Naruto only saying

"Believe It Cause We Just Did It"

And they would say it in unison

 

[Anorien16]

If the similarity between Kakashi and Tobi's Sharingan wasnt proff enough ..... they just have to ask 'Who let Rin die?' and volia, identity revealed.

 

[paratise]

Most of the fanbase did; they would realise as well.

We just view this as a story; therefore we expect some twist from this story controlled by the author. İf we were in NV and have been given the same info the manga gave us on the matter; we would realise as well.