[Question] Why was Roger the only one to find One piece?

[Aampt]

Hey guys, you can close this or disregard this if its been answered in manga, if it has I have forgetten, but why was Roger the only one to find one piece? When Roger died his crew split, correct? So if Roger found the One piece before he was executed, wouldn't you think his crew came with him? So even buggy would know what it is? Sorry if this is has already been answered, it just came to my mind and I can't find an answer to it

 

[Im Still Robin]

Good question .. um ..

I personally believe Rodger was once part of the government like in their dirty plans

He didn't find One Piece, but it was his.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Roger didn't find One Piece, One Piece belonged to Roger. He then hid it on an island that is assumed to be Raftel.

 

[7th Biggest OP Fan]

This has always been speculated as to why, but most conclude you can't get to the end without some special way of knowing it is there.

Some speculate Raftel is a moving island(because of the root word raft), and the only way to find it is with the voice of all things. Gol D. Roger was the only one we know to have it, so even if others know about it, they have no way of being able to go there.

 

[Gitch]

Personally I think One Piece isnt an object ...
I read a theory saying it would be destroying where the grand line and red line cross ...
Yea right where the governement base is .
That way all the oceans would be linked and create a time of peace , also give more freedom and create all blue
Tha would at least realize the main 3 dreams.
Freedom for Luffy
Best swordsmen for Zoro ( he will have to foght the strongest there)
And all blue for Sanji
Also history for Robin
Brook and the whale could also be reunited

 

[Punk Hazard]

Personally I think One Piece isnt an object ...
I read a theory saying it would be destroying where the grand line and red line cross ...
Yea right where the governement base is .
That way all the oceans would be linked and create a time of peace , also give more freedom and create all blue
Tha would at least realize the main 3 dreams.
Freedom for Luffy
Best swordsmen for Zoro ( he will have to foght the strongest there)
And all blue for Sanji
Also history for Robin
Brook and the whale could also be reunited

Oda hinted it won't be an immaterial thing like this. He said it wouldn't be a concept or anything like that because he said the Strawhats deserve a reward if they make it that far. He pretty much guaranteed it's an object.

 

[Gitch]

Oda hinted it won't be an immaterial thing like this. He said it wouldn't be a concept or anything like that because he said the Strawhats deserve a reward if they make it that far. He pretty much guaranteed it's an object.

What would be a better reward than all their dreams coming true ?
And I dont see any of the strawhats wanting material stuff except for Nami

 

[Skylar Knight]

What would be a better reward than all their dreams coming true ?

I don't think destroying one fifth of the world is how they'd like to achieve their dreams, to be honest.

 

[Punk Hazard]

What would be a better reward than all their dreams coming true ?
And I dont see any of the strawhats wanting material stuff except for Nami

Seeing as Oda said it's not an immaterial concept, I'm leaning towards an object they'd like.

 

[Gitch]

I don't think destroying one fifth of the world is how they'd like to achieve their dreams, to be honest.

No more governement .... Most freedom of the world ...
What would be better really ? A staff ? A crown ?

 

[Punk Hazard]

No more governement .... Most freedom of the world ...
What would be better really ? A staff ? A crown ?

But who says that has to be One Piece? That could just be something they have along the way TO One Piece.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Oda hinted it won't be an immaterial thing like this. He said it wouldn't be a concept or anything like that because he said the Strawhats deserve a reward if they make it that far. He pretty much guaranteed it's an object.

Now I'm more sure than ever, ONe Piece is the One Piece of meat that will go great with this egg Roger hid.

You must be registered for see images

It's the perfect prize for Luffy.

 

[Gitch]

But who says that has to be One Piece? That could just be something they have along the way TO One Piece.

Roger figuered it was the One Piece missing for world peace ... Lol
But everyone dream coming true also mean a better place for all the citizens

 

[Punk Hazard]

Roger figuered it was the One Piece missing for world peace ... Lol
But everyone dream coming true also mean a better place for all the citizens

How is Nami drawing a map for the world, Franky going around the world, Luffy becoming Pirate King, Zoro becoming WSM, Brook seeing Laboon again, or Sanji finding All Blue benefit each and every citizen or the world as a whole? The only Strawhats whose goals can have an impact on the world as a whole are Chopper and Robin.

 

[Amaterasu]

Now I'm more sure than ever, ONe Piece is the One Piece of meat that will go great with this egg Roger hid.

You must be registered for see images

It's the perfect prize for Luffy.

I read a theory bout it, it says that it is Kaido

 

[Ken Kaneki]

I think Raftel might be a graveyard. Roger might have earlier worked as a henchmen for World Govt and hid bodies there of people who revolt. But he had a change of heart and went against them. So when Straw Hats or anyone finds One Piece and find atrocities of WG, a war would begin.

 

[Gitch]

How is Nami drawing a map for the world, Franky going around the world, Luffy becoming Pirate King, Zoro becoming WSM, Brook seeing Laboon again, or Sanji finding All Blue benefit each and every citizen or the world as a whole? The only Strawhats whose goals can have an impact on the world as a whole are Chopper and Robin.

Well for a starter , no governement means good things for the whole world ...
Also all blue means more fish for everyone , robin dream means true history for everyone , luffys dreams mean no more slavery , etc etc

 

[Amaterasu]

I think Raftel might be a graveyard. Roger might have earlier worked as a henchmen for World Govt and hid bodies there of people who revolt. But he had a change of heart and went against them. So when Straw Hats or anyone finds One Piece and find atrocities of WG, a war would begin.

So they find One Piece and start a war, all the travelling since all these years to strt a war ? No, just no

 

[Ken Kaneki]

So they find One Piece and start a war, all the travelling since all these years to strt a war ? No, just no

It is supposed to change the world remember?

 

[Amaterasu]

It is supposed to change the world remember?

A war won't change the world. One Piece is something material however. So your argument is flawed.