Why was Edo Madara young? (plot defect?)

Magnolius

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
2,969
Reaction score
222
I never serious with my answer to begin with. It bcus I'm not in the mood for serious/proper discussion.

It just meant for sarcasm but apparently you failed to see it.

No, I noticed the sarcasm. Well to be honest, I didn't sense sarcasm but I could perceive the lack of effort in your post, as if you were saying something just to say it.

I just thought that what you said was worth replying to :sdo:
 

DominiqueX

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
4,841
Reaction score
448
That still doesn't add up to how it was possible for Kabuto to alter his physical appearance. Everyone is brought back the way they were when they died, Nagato, Chiyo, ext. This should have been the case for Madara.
But that's just the way it is :p
You can call it plot-hole, inconsistency, asspull, artistic freedom by Kishimoto. It doesn't matter.
 

Magnolius

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
2,969
Reaction score
222
But that's just the way it is :p
You can call it plot-hole, inconsistency, asspull, artistic freedom by Kishimoto. It doesn't matter.

Well considering that "it" is the main focus/topic of this thread, then I would say it does matter here at least.


Edit: OH THAT'S BS! You joined January, how do you have more rep points than me? :nosh::noes:
 
Last edited:

DominiqueX

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
4,841
Reaction score
448
Well, then yes, it is a "plot-defect".
@ your edit: sorry? D:
 

minamoto

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
23,852
Reaction score
5,071
Status
He got played by a character who doesn't exist? Crazy.

he does exist !! only God ,Kishi and I know this!!! ...also thinking tobidara doesn't exist means a lack of understanding to Naruto Manga from your part...in other words..you are just another victim of Kishimoto's Illusion
 

Bad Touch Yakushi

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 26, 2011
Messages
19,411
Reaction score
1,553

he does exist !! only God ,Kishi and I know this!!! ...also thinking tobidara doesn't exist means a lack of understanding to Naruto Manga from your part...in other words..you are just another victim of Kishimoto's Illusion

Tobidara exists even less than God does.

You're a victim of many disorders I presume.
 

Magnolius

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
2,969
Reaction score
222
Oh god, here we go.

Must we rastle each others jambos in my thread?
 

minamoto

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
23,852
Reaction score
5,071
Status
Tobidara exists even less than God does.

You're a victim of many disorders I presume.

dont get teh wrong idea cuz im a truth spreader also read and understand verry well what itachi(kishi) is telling you readers :

You must be registered for see images



You must be registered for see images



its a genius warning and hint what itachi( kishi) is saying is that Madara is teh reall tobi , but this truth will one day be rejected by readers(teh obito reveal)....but no matter what one day tobi will end up to be Madara again....

-your brain should use logic : why teh goofy tobi was acting like goofy spiral zetsu??...minamoto's answer : that's becuz spiral zetsu sealed himself within obito's body and controlled him .

-why kisame and itachi always believed tobi to be Madara...Minamoto's answer : it's becue tobi was indeed Madara : the second Madara tobidara!!

-you watched harry potter?? the empty shell of voldmort?? teh horcruxes??....so yeahh that is tobidara.. he is an empty shell of rikudo Madara he is an immortal who was planning to rejuvenile his reall vessel (the other rikudo Madara)

-there were 2 Madara's running around...one died (rikudo) but the other is very much alive and showed identity to kisame and itachi..


-tobidara used obito as a weaker vessel untill he gets his reall vessel (rikudo Madara revived)

-you know it damns well that ther's a worlld of difference between the boss mastermind masked tobi(tobidara) and the fodder unmasked obito...

-you know it damn well that itachi and kisame are so skilled ninjas and can't die being fooled by Bobito

-you know it damn well that if Bobito did indeed fool itachi and kisame he would've been teh final villain


...yet you deny monamoto's truth....im just trying to save you from kishimoto's illusion...JOIN MY SIDE COMON BRO!!!
 

minamoto

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
23,852
Reaction score
5,071
Status
omgmy english is,lil bit terrible sorry
 

Holy God

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Aug 30, 2014
Messages
4,017
Reaction score
164
You can't simply do that with Edo Tensei, or chakra in general. If that were the case, he would have made a lot of other people who were in there Old Man edo tensei form, young. If Kabuto really wanted to revive Madara young because his physical capabilities would allow him to excel in battle, then he would have done so for many others.

Granny Chiyo came in her old form, all hobbling like an old lady.

The 3rd Raikage was revived old and wrinkly.

Nagato was revived all old looking.

Altering their physical state to make them younger and more physically fit would have benefited them just as much as it would Madara.

And there theirs what I said above. The soul takes the form of a hosts current physical appearance, so if the soul leaves the body then it is permenantly stuck in that physical appearance, which is why everyone who was revived with Edo Tensei came back looking exactly as they did when they died. It isn't at all possible to mold the physical apperance of a soul to your liking, so therefore if Madara died an old man and his soul was in the form of an old man, than when his soul was attached to a body for edo tensei, then he should have been revived with the physical appearance of his old man state.

You're assuming too much therefore you can't go around stating your opinion as fact. As for your first cases, no, Kabuto modifying them would not help as much as Madara because mobility is of no issue and their powers throughout their lifetime does not vary as much, and then there's Kishimoto having only the intention of saving it for the trump card, Madara himself. You may be forgetting, but you need the DNA of the person in order to use the technique, meaning that it may have an influence in the resulting body. The soul itself does not determine everything and nothing suggests that as so.

As I told you, there's no reason to argue against me. We've been shown it's capable by Kabuto himself and if you want specific logic, you're not getting it without talking to the author himself.
 

Magnolius

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2015
Messages
2,969
Reaction score
222
You're assuming too much therefore you can't go around stating your opinion as fact. As for your first cases, no, Kabuto modifying them would not help as much as Madara because mobility is of no issue and their powers throughout their lifetime does not vary as much, and then there's Kishimoto having only the intention of saving it for the trump card, Madara himself. You may be forgetting, but you need the DNA of the person in order to use the technique, meaning that it may have an influence in the resulting body. The soul itself does not determine everything and nothing suggests that as so.

As I told you, there's no reason to argue against me. We've been shown it's capable by Kabuto himself and if you want specific logic, you're not getting it without talking to the author himself.

At no point in this post were you close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. I'll set you straight soon enough.
 
Top