[Discussion] Why Senju/Uchiha could not have descended from Uzumaki/Hyuuga

[Megatolium]

Curse of Hatred!​

You must remember that the Senju or Uchiha wasn't necessarily "Uchiha" or "Senju" in the first place, they were merely descendants of their ancestors.

2nd of all, if the two ancestory had great immense hatred for one another, wouldn't Uzumaki and Hyuuga be cursed with that fate as well?

Unless they came BEFORE the two sons of Rikudou Sennin.

Rikudou taught a normal group of people how to use ninjutsu, the Shinobi Sect. This was also the time when Rikudou taught the Uzumaki's how to use Fuuinjutsu, reassuring nothing goes wrong after he dies. (Which btw Madara knew and sought to destroy them).

 

[3MESSIAH]

wait so did you just negate your own title?

 

[Shinobi2012]

1.The sage was a priest.

2.priest use funinjustu

3.The sage after sealing the juubi had two sons

They went onto carry certain traits the uchiha ancestor gaining the sages spiritual energy and the chakra of the juubi

The senju ancestor (Uzumaki) gained the psyhical energy of the sage (The body)

4.

The uzumaki are known for Funinjustu a.k.a. SEALING JUSTU and have a strong vitality which has been shown when all uzumaki who have been jinchuuriki survived the extraction and live long lives.


4.B

The sages son believed in peace so the uzumaki son kept close ties with his descendants the senju and when kurama needs a jinchuriki who is always there to become the host ?

Was it a senju ? No ? Was it a uchiha ? Nope.

It was an uzumaki every time.
5.

They are distant relatives not direct descendants of the senju

6.
Rinnegan requires the progenitor genes.
These genes cannot be replicated.
You need the exact dna to make the rinnegan surface.

Uchiha + Senju = rinnegan

Oh but wait nagao doesn't have senju dna so how is that possible ?

Oh wait because he already has the required dna because he is an uzumaki.



If they were descendants then the genes would be diluted and any uzumaki would still need senju dna.

The uchiha dna was already provided through the rinnegan because the rinengan was formed from the sharingan.


/////thread