Why do some bash others fro criticizing the series?

[Shadow Phantasm]

Over the past couple of chapters anyone who so much as criticized the way the story is going is often met with remarks such as"Why are you still here then?" or "Don't like it,don't read it."Well correct me if I'm wrong but isn't this section of the Base called the Naruto Discussion and not the Blindly praise every single thing and drive out critics forum?Just saying....

 

[Aya San]

I think critism is ok but some people straight up bash Kishi and call names, those people should feel ashamed

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

I think critism is ok but some people straight up bash Kishi and call names, those people should feel ashamed

Agreed,those people just make it harder for the actual critics to state their case since most on the fanboy side would lump them in with the hostile ones.

 

[rollin]

Because its mostly bashing under the guise of "criticizing"

 

[Aya San]

I hardly see actual constructive criticism anyway.

 

[Kαmi]

I agree. I think it's ridiculous to think that everyone will always like every single thing about the manga. It's common for people to not be satisfied with some chapters every now and then. Kishi isn't gonna please everyone all the time, having critics is normal. I haven't been too satisfied with the current arc or the last but I enjoyed everything before then, does that mean I should quit the manga? No, that's moronic. To blindly worship the manga for every last detail and say it's perfect sounds mindless to me.

Bashing the manga is stupid, those people deserved to be bashed. But people who bash users who are strictly critiquing and not bashing is even dumber to me.

 

[Fecal Matter]

I agree this 'don't log on' card has been used way too much, just shows how little they have to say on that certain topic.​

 

[-Punk-]

Smartasses who think they know better . Some people go overboard with the bashing but still , the other ones ain't shit either .

 

[xcoyote]

People bash those who bash the mangaka,i doubt anyone has problem with constructive criticism.

 

[Οdin]

I don't understand it either. I'm not sure why anybody would drop the entire manga after investing their time reading hundreds of chapters, just because they dislike a small part of it. It's like divorcing your wife and abandoning your children after she accidentally farted during coitus.

 

[muhachiuchiha]

We need constructive criticism, bashing is just mindless, however everyone has their opinnion. and i get where alot of people are coming from, we all love naruto and sometimes its dissapointing to see an awsome manga change in a bad way. But if i know Kishi, he'll make up for all the down with some epic plot twists, fights, ect.

 

[-Punk-]

I agree. I think it's ridiculous to think that everyone will always like every single thing about the manga. It's common for people to not be satisfied with some chapters every now and then. Kishi isn't gonna please everyone all the time, having critics is normal. I haven't been too satisfied with the current arc or the last but I enjoyed everything before then, does that mean I should quit the manga? No, that's moronic. To blindly worship the manga for every last detail and say it's perfect sounds mindless to me.

Bashing the manga is stupid, those people deserved to be bashed. But people who bash users who are strictly critiquing and not bashing is even dumber to me.

Oh Brother Testify !.

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

People bash those who bash the mangaka,i doubt anyone has problem with constructive criticism.

There has been plenty of times where people offered constructive well reasoned critcism and are told to leave the forums if it bothers them that much.I should know because that happened to me a couple of days ago.

 

[Joon]

Hey, it is how they feel about the particular Manga. You can call it whatever you want. It am not going to change their mind or correct them. Juts let it be.

 

[Anorien16]

Well the answer is hidden in ur title only .... while Kishi obviously bit off more than he could chew in the recent arcs, most people bash the entire series, the main theme, mangaka for reasons such as 'the manga is too unrealistic' (duh), 'no ebil valiins' (Go watch DBZ pls .... where people are evil for no apparent reason), 'obito OP shld naut get defeated' (Well this is a common occurrence ...), 'power of friendship' (Did u miss the Sage Enhanced Yang Kurama powered Susanoo blade? .... that also managed to barely cut Obito) .... that actually annoys people who actually has a bit of comprehending power till they start generalizing ... while actual reasons are welcome if presented correctly.

Also 'Dont like it dont read' is valid argument ..... After dedicatedly following Bleach I found my self bored by certain arcs and so I took a break ... and returned now that its great again. I never blamed the mangaka and his capabilities repeatedly in a public forums ...

 

[ekichi onizuka]

some people even say ''i wish kishi dies so he can stop making naruto''

those kind of people have no life:|

 

[Joon]

some people even say ''i wish kishi dies so he can stop making naruto''

those kind of people have no life:|

You cannot judge them. u_u

 

[HiddenSound]

They feel they have an obligation to defend Kishi's honor in absentia over the Internet.

 

[chaos control]

=D Ha ha. Was this thread by any chance made because of the debate we just had in that other thread? I just find it funny that you made this thread just after that debate.

Any way, it is not constructive criticism that I am against. It is just annoying when every little thing is complained about and when complainers contradict themselves.

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

=D Ha ha. Was this thread by any chance made because of the debate we just had in that other thread? I just find it funny that you made this thread just after that debate.

Any way, it is not constructive criticism that I am against. It is just annoying when every little thing is complained about and when complainers contradict themselves.

Nope,this thread was made before that.;P