XD This^
OT: I think the main problem people have with Naruto's personality is that it's the same personality for all Shonen Jump protagonists. Goku, Luffy, Natsu, Yoh, Naruto. All of them are of low to average intelligence who are experts in thinking on their feet during battles and alway stay on the righteous path no matter what. The Saviour architype is not the only architype a protagonist should have.
There is the reluctant hero: guys who don't want to accept the saviour role in the begining but grow into it and eventually except their role
The Anit-hero: Think Death Note's Light Yagami
The Brooding Hero: Hero's like Batman and Angel
That's to name a few. Shonen manga don't stray outside the loveable, dumb, talk you out of anything or beat you sensless Architype. It's been seen so much that readers/watchers tend to shy away from the hero in favor of a character that seems more based in reality. No 2 heroes are the same. And the only difference the Shonen heroes have are their powers and looks.
That's what I've gathered at least. Hope that sheds some light on your inquery. :bye:
Yeah it did. But i believe there are other different mangas with different protagonist twists and that kinda balances itself out wouldnt you agree?
Yes I wholehartedly agree with your point. and there in lies the problem with Naruto. The "twists" in Naruto never seem to really phase Naruto overall save for Jiraiya's death. The Saviour architype if fine and all for Naruto as he is the child of prophecy. But as others have stated, where's the versatility? Where is the doubt? Naruto, frequently, acts like he is still 12.
"I won't let you kill my friends"
"I will end this entire war myself"
"I will stop Madara and Obito without letting anyone die"
Even as a Saviour, these kinds of statements are rather immature and unrealistic in a true Saviour. Saviours don't do anything on their own. Even Itachi mentioned this to Naruto and it's like it went into one ear and out the other. I don't have anything against Naruto. I was fine with his character in part I as he was young. He is what? 18 now? And I really haven't seen a progression in his way of thinking or how he views the world.
Naruto is suppose to be a prankster like the fox spirits of mythology. But when's the last time he actually played a prank on anyone? another poster put it best in saying that Naruto's overall character has been detoured since this war started.
Look at Sasuke for example: We've seen a clear and distinct change in his development over the course of the series. He went from Avenger, to maniac, to where he is now, a young man attempting to find his own path in the world that has made him what he is. In many ways, Sasuke's character development is far more developed then Naruto's.