Why did itachi not simple tell the truth to SASUKE???? And simple trade eyes...

[Narusaku619]

Why did itachi not simply tell SASUKE the truth when he was going to fight him???


Had SASUKE known he would of been shocked but like in shippuden forgave his brother.........


Plus ITACHIS illness that was due to overuse of the SHARINGAN could of been reversed if he and SASUKE simple SWITHCH EYES

ITACHIS DEATH WAS UNNESSASRY........MOSTLY FOR PLOT....

 

[daredevil123]

it was for plot you just answered your own question

 

[FemmeFatale]

ITachi didn't have the start tomoe. It wasn a one way deal.
Even though Sakura wouldve gladly regenerated Sasuke some new eyes, but her was playing.

 

[Relostar Devil]

Bcoz he wants you to make this thread on him.

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

Itachi wanted to see how strong sasuke had become, I also think deep down itachi wanted to fight his brother, everytime itachi and sasuke fought itachi negged, with Itachi close to death I don't think he's ever had a real battle since most of itachi's opponents are killed, Tsukyomi negged, or they are too strong. Though Itachi is a pacifist I still believe deep down he wanted to fight his brother as an equal well as equal as equal can be but he wanted to see sasuke's progress, he was going to die anyway from the Kimmamaru sickness, so might as well go down fighting.

 

[Pukkake Pokayo]

Bcoz he wants you to make this thread on him.

The Solo God always gets what he wants in the end :Sparks:

 

[Avani]

Why did itachi not simply tell SASUKE the truth when he was going to fight him?

He explained it when Sasuke found him during war. Read the manga,

Had SASUKE known he would of been shocked but like in shippuden forgave his brother.........

Itachi wanted to die by his hand so that Sasuke could return to Konoha as a hero along with MS and to keep Uchiha reputation intact in his mind.

Plus ITACHIS illness that was due to overuse of the SHARINGAN could of been reversed if he and SASUKE simple SWITHCH EYES

ITACHIS DEATH WAS UNNESSASRY........MOSTLY FOR PLOT....

They do not switch eyes for EMS. They need both sets. Go back to reading the manga.

 

[Torche]

They do not switch eyes for EMS. They need both sets. Go back to reading the manga.

Tbh, I don't think I can recall it ever stating that it was both sets they needed. It never really went into detail beyond obtaining a "replacement" set of Mangekyo Sharingan from a relative (as far as I can recall, anyway ). Unless you could provide a scan where it states or implied that both the blind and "replacement" eyes are needed. I guess you could say the pattern is proof, but it really isn't with manga logic. :hmm:

 

[Avani]

Tbh, I don't think I can recall it ever stating that it was both sets they needed. It never really went into detail beyond obtaining a "replacement" set of Mangekyo Sharingan from a relative (as far as I can recall, anyway ). Unless you could provide a scan where it states or implied that both the blind and "replacement" eyes are needed. I guess you could say the pattern is proof, but it really isn't with manga logic. :hmm:

I don't remember it being defined just as a simple "replacement "set. Scans please. Even Madara and Izuna didn't do it despite being a powerful MS users and wanting more power to fight the Senjus. EMS doesn't seem to be a very common occurrence despite many MS users being mentioned even in previous days. So either all these Uchihas were morons not to figure out this simple trick or it wasn't possible by switching only.

More importantly-Doesn't the EMS merge the designs of the transplanter and the transplantee's original Mangekyo?

Also, Madara the only person with EMS was using a two headed Susano with four pairs of eyes.

Anyway it's been some time but the topic had been discussed variously in old days at NB. Try searching for it and you will find some good arguments for and against it.

 

[HENI]

If he told Sauske, Sasuke would attack the village. Also, swapping eyes does not = EMS

 

[Torche]

I don't remember it being defined just as a simple "replacement "set. Scans please. Even Madara and Izuna didn't do it despite being a powerful MS users and wanting more power to fight the Senjus. EMS doesn't seem to be a very common occurrence despite many MS users being mentioned even in previous days.

More importantly-Doesn't the EMS merge the designs of the transplanter and the transplantee's original Mangekyo?

Also, Madara the only person with EMS was using a two headed Susano with four pairs of eyes.

Anyway it's been some time but the topic had been discussed variously in old days at NB. Try searching for it and you will find some good arguments for and against it.

You're correct, I just labelled it that. Itachi called Sasuke's his "Spare" when he was acting the antagonist.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I just likened spare to replacement.

I know, you could argue that they weren't even aware of the fact that implanting a new set of eyes would make them Eternal. Madara was after all the first to gain EMS, to our knowledge. But you could argue that the Naka Shrine (That is that tablet, right? :|) said about it.

That is true, but I don't think that necessarily means much considering it's a manga. I mean, both things sound really weird. It's either the eyes merge? Or patterns combining upon a new set being implanted. Both sound as far-fetched as the other. XD

Itachi's was shown with four eye sockets, well, the Genjutsu/figure thing. In saying that about Madara's, shouldn't Sasuke's have been the same? :hmm:

I think these two scans lean more towards the fact that it is merely replacing the eyes, but it's still iffy.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

I agree, and have been apart of some of the discussion in the past.

Anyway, I think there is simply too little evidence to come to a complete conclusion, so you can only speculate. I guess we'll leave it there.

 

[Aznkidd]

ITachi didn't have the start tomoe. It wasn a one way deal.
Even though Sakura wouldve gladly regenerated Sasuke some new eyes, but her was playing.

Nice fanfic. After 400 chapters she still rely on Tsunade to do the job...

 

[Styles]

Why did itachi not simply tell SASUKE the truth when he was going to fight him???


Had SASUKE known he would of been shocked but like in shippuden forgave his brother.........


Plus ITACHIS illness that was due to overuse of the SHARINGAN could of been reversed if he and SASUKE simple SWITHCH EYES

ITACHIS DEATH WAS UNNESSASRY........MOSTLY FOR PLOT....

Don't think that's how it works.