Whose pain was greater when they lost a loved one? Nagato or Obito

[AngryRock]

Nagato because they were best friends while Rin acted almost like Sakura to Obito(nicer but close).

 

[Chatte]

Obito's. At least Nagato had the comfort (if you can call it that) of knowing that Yahiko was happy to die for his comrades. Obito likely believes that Rin's death was unjust, unnecessary and avoidable. You could say the boy was obsessed with Rin (and that this was one-sided), but that wouldn't make it any less painful.

No offence but what makes Yahiko's death just, necessary and unavoidable? Or his parent's death?

I agree that Rin's death was painful but still not a powerful reason as Nagato's.

 

[OnPoint]

No offence but what makes Yahiko's death just, necessary and unavoidable? Or his parent's death?

I agree that Rin's death was painful but still not a powerful reason as Nagato's.

If Yahiko was not killed, Konan's life would be taken. There was no other way out of that situation unless Nagato was willing to sacrifice Konan's life. For all we know, Obito thinks Rin's death could've been easily avoided had, for instance, Minato been there to save her.

 

[Tosen]

Nagato lost his parents

Obito lost his bitch (who friendzoned him not to mention)

The answer is clear has day :|

 

[shelke]

Obito's love is one-sided, Nagato lost his parents to Konoha's BS politics, formed a peace alliance but Konoha got him again, had to kill his best friend whom he loved dearly as if he was his own brother...is this even a question? Obito's pain is nothing compared to Nagato's.

 

[Chatte]

If Yahiko was not killed, Konan's life would be taken. There was no other way out of that situation unless Nagato was willing to sacrifice Konan's life. For all we know, Obito thinks Rin's death could've been easily avoided had, for instance, Minato been there to save her.

We still don't know the circumstances of the whole Rin death, so until that is unveiled, still Nagato's painful.
And even if it was Konan who would've been the one to die, still doesn't make her death just and necessary. Plus, don't want to be bitchy or anything, but Obito got mad over a girl, but could care less that he kills his own clan, from what we may suppose, as far as we know, his parents could've been there.
Not to mention the children.

Nagado did everything because of the pain he suffered after he lost his parents and his best friend.

Now, think as this... Who would you suffer more for? Your parents or your loved one?

 

[OnPoint]

We still don't know the circumstances of the whole Rin death, so until that is unveiled, still Nagato's painful.
And even if it was Konan who would've been the one to die, still doesn't make her death just and necessary. Plus, don't want to be bitchy or anything, but Obito got mad over a girl, but could care less that he kills his own clan, from what we may suppose, as far as we know, his parents could've been there.
Not to mention the children.

Nagado did everything because of the pain he suffered after he lost his parents and his best friend.

Now, think as this... Who would you suffer more for? Your parents or your loved one?

He is under the impression that Rin's death was avoidable. Even in the present day he claims 'Kakashi let Rin die', as if to imply the former had a choice over whether or not Rin would be saved. So the circumstances behind Rin's death aren't particularly relevant in this case, because that is what Obito believes. The same can hardly be said for Yahiko's death. He was happy to die for Nagato and Konan. He was happy. That in itself would clearly comfort Nagato to a degree (as oppossed to if Yahiko had been wailing with pain or the like). And yes, someone had to die in that situation - to this day, Obito seems to believe it was wholly avoidable, therefore adding to his pain. What he had was an obsession with Rin. This was not a simple crush as some people try and make out. You think it was on the level of Naruto-Sakura? No. What Obito was feeling was some serious shit. The fact that it was so one-sided makse it all the more painful for Obito.

I never mentioned Nagato's parents. I specifically spoke about Yahiko and the pain Nagato felt then. How can a straight comparison be made when it is clear Nagato lost more people (and, therefore, likely to feel more pain); i'm looking at how the death of individuals close to Obito and Nagato affected their sanity in those particular instances.