Who's more in the wrong? Shinobi villages or the wronged antagonists?

[mikeeozua]

Who would you say is more in the wrong? The shinobi villages or the wronged antagonists? And by wronged antagonists I mean people like Sasuke, Obito, Madara, Nagato, Oro, Akatsuki etc. Please vote on the poll and state your opinions.

 

[AirWind]

wrong antagonists? you mean they got confused by the definition of the real "peace" and try to gain peace through their means of way regardless how cruel that was? If that so, you got the answer already.

 

[COLOSSAL TITAN]

Madara is wrong
Obito is wrong
Orochimaru has nothing to do with the system
Pain was probably one of the most right villains

Sasuke is wrong

 

[Made in Heaven]

THe antagonists are not to be shown any mercy. They know what "real" peace is yet they insist their way to peace is the ideal way.

 

[mikeeozua]

Madara is wrong
Obito is wrong
Orochimaru has nothing to do with the system
Pain was probably one of the most right villains

Sasuke is wrong

Oro had an ulterior motive to attack Konoha didnt he?

 

[Styles]

Raikages village

 

[RNITBmsage]

they murdered nagato's parents and said there sorry... ummmm no villians 1 villages 0

 

[Cooh]

Crush the villages!

 

[vasu 32]

Shonobi Village system is wrong.Those who go with the flow are kages,legends and other things.

But those who defy that system are the ones called,Protagonists and Antagonists.And they both are right in their own perception.

 

[LordRaikage]

Raikages village

explain yourself?

 

[mikeeozua]

THe antagonists are not to be shown any mercy. They know what "real" peace is yet they insist their way to peace is the ideal way.

But its their environment that makes them want to achieve peace. For example there can never be a happy peace in the rain village where Nagato originated from.

 

[Prime Rib]

Well shinobi villages each one shares just as much blame for the world. madara and obito etc. share a blame to but they both came to realize that the world can never change from the past and it would just create more and more people such as themselves as more time passes on thats why madara begain this plan as he knew hashirama idea for peace would only last for a short time

 

[RNITBmsage]

poor nagato

 

[ntel]

Both are right in there own "Eyes"...

The one objective both are wanting is ..peace sounds so simple yet hard

 

[awesomeseimei]

It's the SYSTEM!

 

[darkmanure]

Only Nagato has a proper reason and was wronged. Madara was before the system and attacked the system because he was butthurt. Orochimaru I don't know. Obito has literally the dumbest reason.

 

[mikeeozua]

Only Nagato has a proper reason and was wronged. Madara was before the system and attacked the system because he was butthurt. Orochimaru I don't know. Obito has literally the dumbest reason.

Obito's reasoning goes further than that. His best friend killed his other best friend and even worse, it's completely justified back in Konoha.

 

[Neonian]

Some An. like Nagato.

 

[vasu 32]

people call obito's reason childish,yet they say nagato was the real deal...
both got friendzoned by people's logic,yet both have entirely other reasons to do such things acc. to manga.

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

I'd say the antagonists because they have commited a war and almost a genocide under the justification that their illusions will make up for their deaths.

Sure the villages aren't getting off with a clean slate or a clear concious....but they aren't doing that.

Do note I'm mostly comparing the leaders of Akatsuki as opposed to some of its members...as the non-leader members are basically the result of the village system.