Who's attacked Konoha 16 years ago? Proof

[Olyasama]

I've got tired of people saying nonsence things like "It was Madara, he's borrowed his eye and attacked".
Here's the list of the facts we have:

1) KURAMA's recognized Obito to be the same one who were attacking Konoha. He even tells "Minato gave Naruto my power to defeat YOU in future".
2) The one who attacked Konoha has exact same haircut, voice and sharingan eye as Obito does.
3) Despite the popular speculation like "He couldn't match Minato at the age of 14-15", he hasn't defeated Minato, they had 3 clashes, 1 of them was a draw, and 2 of them Minato's beat the shit out of him. And Obito ran away.
4) Last chapter revealed that Madara was extremely old by that time already, so it couldn't be him.
5) Watch carefuly that chapters again: Kakashi and Gai appeared pretty mature by that time, somehow like Naruto and Sasuke right now.
6) Madara's behaviour is different from the attacker's. And do you realy think MADARA would've lost to Minato that easyly?
/discuss

 

[Ajinkya Jumbad]

dont discuss, this is probably a trap that will engulf your $5,000

 

[Punk Hazard]

Could be Obito. Look how far Sasuke got under Oro in three years. It's only true that Obito, with MS, got pretty far under Madara.

 

[~Puppet Master~]

Hmm... Interesting... With the facts that you gave us, the most probable candidate is....

Obito.

 

[JasonTheArgonaut]

just wait till kishi tells us

 

[Lentz]

The title sounds like you have a proof that Doctor Who attacked Konoha.

 

[upilloncat]

dont discuss, this is probably a trap that will engulf your $5,000

what the .... ?

 

[Migualon J.J.]

i thought it's obvious that it's Tobito xd

 

[Maaggel]

Although it's obvious it's Tobito I like how you sum it up

+rep

And why couldn't he become so powerfull during that time span? He didn't win, but he got pretty close considering who he fought!

So yeah.. Great post

 

[SymphonyX]

Well, I don't know who it is, but I don't think it was Obito. In the fight it seemed like he didn't even know/understand or predict Minato's FTG even though if he was Obito, he should have known about it.

 

[scorpiowarrior]

Yeah, I also think it was Obito. Though, I'm still pretty confused about the reason why he decided to join Madara in destroying the world. I guess, we just have to wait for Kishi to explain it.

 

[Exaar]

It can't be anyone else apart from obito.

When madara first met Obito he was old and i'm guessing not fit for combat against Kage ranked ninja, Also like hiruzen, Madara's chakra most likely weakened also so he might not of been able to controll the kyuubi.
Also the "Tobi" that attacked 16years ago had the same S/T as the current obito/tobi, madara has no S/T as far as we know.

Plus we saw his arm "melt" after getting hit by rasengan, we also know that Obito is made up from zetsu like cells.

Everything points towards obito.

 

[Olyasama]

Well, I don't know who it is, but I don't think it was Obito. In the fight it seemed like he didn't even know/understand or predict Minato's FTG even though if he was Obito, he should have known about it.

You can think whatever you want to think, but the facts are against your opinion.
And I also suggest you should read the fight again. And my post as well. He WAS aware of Minato's ability, he's made up a perfect plan to split up Kushina and Minato. And even took special chain in order to use it against FTG.

 

[FatalAnimeJW]

good analysis
+rep

 

[IKSOKRIPS]

I agree with all, but there was always something bothering me, how could he have become so much powerful in one damn year?! :shrug:

 

[Forbidden Technique]

I also believe it was Obito. Since a large part of his body is made up of zetsu, his appearance to be an adult is possible.
Also, Madara took Obito under his wing. So its not that shocking Obito was able to advance in such a short time that he did.

 

[Babce]

yes you are totaly right it is obito and another fact is not only is madara 100 or so years old but his hair is white in the last page which prooves it cant be him

 

[Kira was Righteous]

I really doubt obito would rip out his eye and give it to Madara lol and old Madara wouldnt lose easily to Minato

It was obito has to be

 

[Simple Math]

it must be obito