[VS] who wouldve really won between itachi and kisame going all out.

[Cody Click]

Location: Gaara vs Kimimaro
Distance: 50 yards
Intel: Kisame has all Intel on itachi, itachi has all Intel on Kisame besides Samaheda fusion.
Intent: To defeat each other at all costs.

Who do you guys think would really win?

My opinion: I got to give it to Kisame. He knows how to break out of genjutsu, and against itachi he'd know not to look at his eyes. Plus he'd probably fuse with Samaheda pretty quick to use his sensory skills to sense itachi. Amaterasu would be the biggest factor, idk if samaheda could absorb it or not, it absorbed normal fire but you know, ima say it can absorb amaterasu from speculation though as it is ninjutsu. For Susanoo, I believe there's no doubt Kisame wouldn't resort to his water dome. Under water I think he could easily evade the totsuka blade. Besides that he could drown itachi and absorb his susanoos chakra from a pretty well distance so yata mirror don't come into play. He also has far better chakra reserves than itachi. It's just my opinion though, I used a little speculation with no proof though, so there's no telling, you'd have to use speculation on itachis side too because some things we just don't know.

 

[ARGUS]

its an established manga fact that Itachi is superior, whre kisame admitted inferiority himself
kisame cant counter tsukuyomi nor could he counter totsuka, both of which are faster that any of kisames jutsus,
feats wise Itachi > Kisame, Portrayal wise, Itachi > Kisame

 

[-immortal-]

Kisame can't counter his genjutsu.
Guess what, itachi one shots

 

[New Dawn]

You must be registered for see images

tsukuyomi one shots. /thread

 

[Eng nawashi]

I personally think kisame wins

-While being fused with Samehada ,kisame can sense the chakra ,he himself stated that and was able to attack bee in the water prison despite being blinded by bee's ink ,so he can evade any eye contact with itachi by fighting with closed eyes ,and even if he was caught in genjutsu ,samehada can break him out from any genjutsu bar tsukuyomi ,and can heal him from the brain damage caused by tsukuyomi considering that base tusonade healed kakashi from this brain damage and samehada has much better healing feats than base tusonade

- Amatrasu gets absorbed ,no doubt about that ,samehada complained from touching itachi's normal fire ,just like any creature would do ,Absorbing the fire / Amatrasu is samehada's only way to get rid of the pain caused by it ,I don't think Samehada will prefer being burned to death rather than Absorbing it

- Susano gets Absorbed by Great water shark ,or kisame can trap itachi in the great water prison ,then summons thousands of sharks attacking itachi's feet considering that susano doesn't protect him form below

 

[Xlad]

Itachi takes this at high difficulty. Not low or mid, but very high.

 

[Sublime Green Beast]

Going all out, Itachi wins. Damn sure won't be a easy victory though.

Itachi can't afford to draw this battle out. He doesn't have the proper reserves to fight against somebody who can absorb chakra.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Kisame can win the battle, but Itachi'll take it more times out of ten.

 

[pateuvasiliu]

The solo king solos.

Kisame has no counter for Tsukuyomi, Amaterasu or Totsuka.

 

[super yang]

Itachi will win everytime because of susano'o...
...restrict susano'o and the tables turn in Kisames favor.